Overall, I think an alpha cuck (alpha stage) is way more interesting than just a plain alpha
Alpha characters in vanilla games are so boring—they all have godlike powers, and girls fall for them at first sight

! which is funny, boring, and cliché
I don’t mean your words—you might’ve meant something else. I’m just comparing these two personality types
"Everyone jerks off as they want", everyone has different tastes!
Every game is good and bad in its own way.
I'm also not particularly interested when MC fucks everyone without any consequences! But again, everything depends on the plot of the game. There are harem games where at a certain point you need to make a choice, + there are games where some people think that there are moments of NTS and NTR, but these are controversial points, for example, incest with the mother, while the mother can sleep with the father or someone else, many people think that this is NTR-NTS, but she is not the MC's girlfriend or his wife! The mother can do whatever she wants, just like the MC and such situations are much more interesting than just a vanilla harem, especially when there is a choice whether there will be this scene or not!
In NTR/cheating games it is interesting to see the heroes' experiences, their struggle, thrill, while they fight with their "inner demons" and ect., while it exists, such a game is interesting to me!
And NTS is voluntary, and MC is happy about it. Meh/