VN - Ren'Py - Completed - NTR'ed by My Friend [v1.0.0] [NTR.ai]

I'll start by stating that I don't usually play games with the NTR tag, so I'm not familiar with what the difference between only Alan's perspective to both? does that mean I lose content (scenes) if I choose only his? and if I choose both, do I see repetitive text? (yes I did at some parts). The game isn't clear enough about that for players who are not familiar with this genre

The main girl is pretty hot, but this is AI so of course she would be, but that's a good eye candy so no complains yet. The first scene was 15 minutes in, this is the lowest interval I've found between scenes playing the game (up to the point I played it), though the first scene is pretty lame, but I assume that is on purpose to setup what to come.

The next scene became further apart, ranging from 20-40 minutes in-between, which is HUGE compared to what I'm about to say about the narrative.

There is a lot of filler between dialogue. I understand that a good novel should be descriptive and make you image stuff, but this is a VISUAL novel, and especially one made with AI, so generating images is just a fraction of what it takes to actually create content for an artist, so I think the dev here could take some effort adding more sprites instead of the over detailed descriptions. (I myself also played with some diffusion models, so I know it is sometimes hard to generate exactly what you try, but yet...)

I don't know what with the writing, but the thoughts of the characters are very weird, I assume they are translated (?) like this so they kind of incoherent, but it feels like the minds of different characters think in the same patterns... mmm.
But other than that, the writing is pretty boring, and the reason for that is that the game narrative has no purpose to it, there is no real direction for the game, so you as the reader has nothing narrative-wise to look forward to - this leaves only the NTR part to hold the whole game, but the NTR being so far apart with filler meaningless dialogue in-between, making this game very hard to bear. I managed for 3 hours and decided to put it aside, despite the gorgeous animations.

The artwork is magnificent. The detailing of every curve is immersive. The naughty acts began on time and there was no dragging on like some of the other games. I was hoping the mother would also be involved in the raunchy perversion. Overall, a satisfying game.


Thanks.

This is AI gone RIGHT, and I don't know what the dev has publicly stated but my guess is this is AI to generate sprites/animations but then a lot of real human work on how to display that and the text. Maybe the text was generated via AI but I guarantee it's had at least one if not several significant human passes, if not generated in total by a human.

This game uses AI as a tool instead of the central pillar, and the content flourishes. I can't say that this is QUITE good as something like "A promise best left unkept" or those similar type of tonal and format, often ntr-focused, games, but it is VERY close. I'm giving this 5 stars because it is a great, finished product and it's clear the dev knows how to use AI for gain and not as some shortcut. There's still real human difficult work that needs to be done when you use AI, and this dev has done that work. Bravo.

This kind of execution should be encouraged. Great job, dev!

Nice use of AI! Even the voice implementation, which usually doesn’t work that well, turned out being sometimes very hot. The animations were smooth, and I really liked the scenes, they were hot. As for the story, it was solid, nothing groundbreaking, but you managed to deliver a nice NTR with some hidden scenes that were really spicy . I waited for the full release, and I ended up enjoying the whole game. Bravo!

A fantastic game! It delivers exactly what it needs to with simplicity, plenty of intrigue, and top-notch animations. Plus, it has a great and fitting Netorare ending.
My congratulations to the developers.

This game is amazing, the only reason I can't give it 5 stars is simply because of all the wasted potential.
I can't help but feel like the Dev really wanted to end the game as soon as possible, making us miss all the GODLY scenes we could get with the mother and the sister.
I hope we get some "specials" in the future giving us a bit of the best that we could have had with this game.
GJ Dev, but take it slower with the next game and come back to give us what we want when you can!

I hope you will add more scenes with Daphanie and Eveline. super hot models. just wish their faces are little bit more adult looking. They look like baby faces attached to adult bodies. please add more threesomes and foursomes.

Promising NTR-NTS project with an enjoyable story, good art, lovable characters but with room for improvement like made more long animations or made more shots for sex scenes, rework or improve the bathroom scene with the lights out to made more understandable how that situation occurs ( is the first cheating penetration scene, is key in a NTR game that you have to make it the most possibly graphic, detailed and memorable)

Always remember the Key scenes of any NTR games that need more work and details to be successful and memorable is the first cheating penetration and the first time when the guy discover his girl cheating.

Hi, congrats you made a really nice game, it will be wonderfull if later you can add a DLC chapter with focus on the Mother maybe add some extra scenes before they leave the mother house, is a shame show a Milf like that and dont see some scenes with her haha, wish you the best, thanks again for the hard work.

Fan of the genre. Love watching a whack or lame MC get cucked. I also love sneaky sex and those type of situations. I'm one of those people who imagine themselves as the Bull or just views the game in a third person mode. I secretly hate the aspect of the MC because its almost always some generic weakling that I could never identify with.

The MC in this game is not ALL that bad. As a matter of fact, the bull and his hairstyle actually made me cringe initially. That's the beauty in this game, you can't judge a book by it's cover.

PREMISE
If you've played an NTR game before there's nothing that's absolute groundbreaking and if you've played as many as I have you won't see anything new. But if it aint broke, don't fix it. That being said, it has the usual tropes as far as plot is concerned just not as much teasing if I had any criticism. MC has a hot GF and a friend who wants to smash--Again if it ain't broke dont fix it.

SCENES
Top tier. If this is the future of AI we are COOKED. Even the first accident scene in the bathroom is amazing and done well. The later scenes are INCREDIBLE. It's as if the dev started mastering the prompts towards the end. The animations are not only good but they speed up and transition to Ahegao.

CRITICISMS
The beach scene was hot but it seemed like it could have been padded a bit more. The hottest scene in my opinion is the card game with the sister but the game doesn't really come close until later. The modeling scene was hot but felt like filler. The other characters don't really do much for the story

CONCLUSION
Dev became my top 2 dev for games. I followed the game during it's entire development. The game is virtually flawless and even has an NTS route if you want.

Version 0.10.1

NBMF is a "traditional" NTR visual novel following closely by the playbook of most Jap hentai games in this genre i.e. a loser and mentally retarded MC with a small cock who cannot see the obvious signs his girl is cheating with his monster cock best friend.

Although it's AI made, the game boasts nice graphics and tons of animations that are better than most AI slops out there. That is not to say they are on par with the good hand drawn / animated 2D games out there, but it's a good trade off between quality and frequency of updates.

Story
The plot is about as straight forward as it gets - MC and his girlfriend, Cristie, stay in the same apartment as his best friend Blake. While staying together, Blake corrupts Cristie and they engage in hanky panky while cuckholding MC behind his back or right in front of him.

It's basically a nukige story in the Netorare / Netorase genre, so it's expected that players do not come here for the story. The narration is extremely verbose akin to an erotic novel initially, but thankfully it gets thinned out substantially in the later parts.

Game Mechanic
There are a few but critical choices that determine whether you are on the Netorare or Netorase route. I understand in subsequent chapters beyond the version I played you also get a few more choices to determine the type of Netorare ending you get.

You also get to choose either a full experience with both MC and Cristie's POV or a mystery one where only MC's POV is available. However in practice there is very little content if you play only MC's POV so I doubt that choice is really feasible.

Another thing that irks me is the game doesn't have a consolidated narrative combining both MC's and Cristie's POV. If you choose to play with both POVs, it simply plays the same event one POV right after another. This means a lot of text and graphics repeat needlessly and lots of disorienting messed up chronology.

Background / Character Renders
Very skilful use of AI to render background and characters. There's good quality control with no obvious inconsistencies on a casual playthrough and all the characters are well designed.

Character models are standard porn caricatures with MC having a small dick, Blake being a white version of BBC, Cristie and Daphne spotting mega boobs and butts. Nonetheless they are hot and achieve what they set out to do.

Character Development
As a nukige game, character development is certainly not the focus. All the characters are as tropey as they can get in a NTR game.

MC is weak, ineffectual and dense. Blake is a Caucasian version of the dominant BBC bad boy trope while Cristie is an innocent girl that gets corrupted at record pace. Daphne plays the typical slut role to create sexual situations.

Sex Scenes
Plenty of them and well-animated. Most of the scenes are pretty extensive with a good dose of teasing / corruption dialogue, various erotic camera angles and occasional use of polyptych presentation and sound effects.

While these AI generated animations are yet to match those done manually using SPINE, the decent quality and large number of them add life to the numerous sex scenes. Needless to say nearly all of them centre around NTR so don't waste your time if you're not into it.

BGM and Sound Effects
BGMs are sorely lacking in NBMF, other than one or two occasional tracks and on and off ambient noises, the game is otherwise silent. Quite a shame as many of the cuckholding and cheating tease scenes could do with appropriate music for added immersion. I don't recall any normal sound effects either.

Conclusion
NBMF is a well-done piece of work using AI. The graphics and animations are about as good as can be done with AI presently, but narration and dialogue is inconsistent and clunky at times while the lack of meaningful sound leaves it flat where it matters most.

It caters to a specific genre of NTR heavy on cuckholding and mental masochism, so it isn't suitable for those who can't stand playing an idiot and weak MC or want a realistic story. Other than that, it serves fans of the NTR sub genre well.

[v0.13.1]

In the sea of AI slop, there are a few devs that actually have the skills and desire to use the tech as a tool to get the results they want.

What I'm saying is that this dev is one of the few that has some standards in visual presentation when using AI art. This game has the rare quality of consistency in art while using AI.

The outfits, the style, the multitudes of variations in the sprites and CG variations during scenes/animations, they all have a consistent quality and never feel jarring. There is only the barest hint of minor inconsistencies like belt buckle being slightly different shape, but over all, the visual part of the VN flows extremely smoothly. The animations are also exceptional and fit right in.

This is one of the few examples of someone using AI art as a suitable substitute for hand drawn art in VN format. Not necessarily in terms of art quality, although this style is really good, but in terms of the control an "artist" has in presenting coherent visuals for the scenes. Most AI art games will have nice individual CGs, but rarely have a coherent and consistent flow to it.

Unfortunately, the AI writing leaves a lot to be desired. Maybe it's not apparent to everyone, but as someone who has massive hours gooning to LLMs, all the flaws of LLM smut are amplified here. The overly dramatic prose, the em dash spam, the cringe, some logic holes, and the repetitiveness of the writing.

To be fair, I think the dev also tried to use LLM to its advantage in their workflow, but they just didn't quite succeed as they did on the visual side. The AI writing is still better than some of the godawful implementations I've seen of it, but it's certainly not great. Particularly, the dev failed to reign in the LLM tendency to repeat motifs incessantly when it permeates the context window. Whether it be certain ideas or a specific pattern in writing, poorly guided LLMs can get stuck in a loop because it's getting influenced too strongly by a repeating motif in the context window.

All in all, this is a very basic NTR story with LLM writing that can get old very fast, but the AI art was done much better than what you normally find around here.

I rated it higher at first, but the more I play it, the more weaknesses I find in the writing. The stupid way the LLM was doing the internal monologues was incredibly annoying.

Oh god—Alan—watching—best ever—Alan never—bad girlfriend—feels good.

That's the kinda shit you need to stamp out of the context window, not let the LLM repeat it until it becomes the standard.

There are not many games that provide you with a great experience from the female cheating POV. This is one. I wouldn't say it is perfect; every aspect of it serves its purpose right: an erotic game prioritises cheating kink, under this context, IT'S HOT. I recommend it to those who are looking for games that focus on FPOV cheating kink.

Decided to play this for the first time at v0.13.1 - Tried both NTR routes so far, hitting the end of the (currently) shorter one, and almost through with the other one. I had been a bit hesitant about trying this one because I recall the initial ratings being quite poor. Turns out, I had nothing to fear, and have been loving the game so far.

For once, I decided to first play only through MMC's perspective. While it's not Tolkien level, the writing is really good. The MC isn't an oblivious idiot, and while we as the player knows it's an NTR game, his reactions - measured suspicion - is actually quite believable. After the path splits in three, my favourite was the NTR one where MC remains suspicious, but sadly that one isn't that far along yet.


Anyway, I started replaying it in dual perspectives mode, and while the GF's corruption is kind of abrupt, it was quite believable too, if we are a bit generous when filling in her background and personality. The game introduces her without really giving too much information in this regard - which I think is a good thing, allowing for a good experience when playing either as one perspective or both.


Visuals are pretty good, for AI. Certainly some room for improvement, but quite good. Sound isn't perfect, but it's a nice touch - especially the moans and slurping sounds in a certain scene.


Finally, I'd like to mention that I really liked the pacing. There are periods where the MMC and FMC get some prolonged time away from the "villain", and while I've so far only seen these scenes as the male MC, you get a sense that things could turn out quite well for them. FMC manages to calm down, seemingly able to actually convince herself that she only loves MMC, and can place her guilt/lust/whatever far out of her mind, having a great time with MMC... at least until the villain (or should that be plural? - FMC's sister is not the best influence on her sister) decides to re-appear and shatter that illusion.

The art is amazing at the highest level.
The art at the beginning had a gap with the still images, which felt a bit unnatural. However, the art towards the end resolved that issue and was fantastic.
This work made me a fan of this artist.
I've also supported him on Patreon.
I'm rooting for you.

One of the best games made with AI so far. What I love is the story; both paths are incredible and really keep you hooked. The intensity and extremes that the game handles are top notch. Highly recomended.

A must-read hilarious story for any NTR fan. The ability to rename the antagonist so you don't have to identify with the cuckold is pure genius. The AI is top-notch and the animated scenes are seriously hot.

Does it deserve 5 stars? Not quite, it's more of a 3-4 star experience for me. But seeing all those 1-star reviews from people who clearly came just to hate on it purely for being NTR – and whose profiles show they barely comment on anything else – reeks of an unfair brigade. So my 5 stars are to balance that shit out.

Seriously, I don't get people who hate a genre and go out of their way to trash it. If I hate golf but love football, I don't go to a golf forum to talk shit about their sport – I stay in my own lane where I belong.

0.12.3

- Lots of environmental description, vibes, but the "Visual" part of the Novel doesnt really match said descriptions, BGs are extremely limited apart from a few filler scenes.
- The pace is akward, while it tries to take itself serious showcasing the couple eating a meal for instance, the next scene completly breaks the immersion with: WOW THATS A HUGE COCK, I MIGHT JUST SIT IN IT CARELESSLY WHILE GOING TO THE BATHROOM WHAT CAN BE DONE LOL
- Weird, lazy cuck trap, but the scenes are ok, beautiful models... like folks said here, this one is a wall of text then super intense sex scene.. the build up is also weird.

v12.0.3
I'm not sure where I stand with this game.
On a technical level, there 's nothing to complain about. AI done right. Animations are good, Sound design is good and welcomed.

On the NTS path, ddnt test the NTR route.
It's more about the writting .. I don't know. Something feels off. Like, mechanical ... The corruption of the Gf is weird.
I'm curious where the story is headed since last updates.

These guys are ahead of the game on AI Animation. Say what you want about the story and the pacing, but the animation is second to none. It's just a simple story of a "friend" taking another friend's wife and making her submit to him while the husband becomes a full fledged cuck. I don't care much for the story, but the animation, insane.

Fantastic game! I really liked the developing story, and loved the visuals. I think you couldn't have gotten a hotter girl for the leading role. I really like her dimensions, and they're used very well in the scenes.

For the story, I think it works. I'm mostly one to follow the girl in ntr, not really interested in the guy story. But, I still read through what he did. Boring. But, I guess it all adds up.

I do think she reacts realistically. The language is pretty good, and I like the dialogues. Mostly, I like the animations though, they're great.

I don't think there's much to correct with this game. I look forward to seeing how the rest of the story goes.