I honestly have quite mixed feeling about this game. On the one hand this is product of fine quality, quite consistent story, and also finished one. Clearly creator put a lot of work in it. On the other hand, it has multiple flaws, that prevent it from being much better game.
First, and most important one, could be summed up in one word - CHILDISH.
I'll try to explain, because it feels that way for many different reasons. For the starters, all dialogues seems kinda naive. It feels... I can't quite put a finger on it, but maybe like how teenagers will imagine adult conversations are, instead on how adult conversations actually are. There also isn't much suspense, and pretty much every situation resolves itself in like 2 minutes.
Next, behaviour of characters is as childish as it can be. Main LIs mother acts like a bitch and creates contradictions basically in every sentence. There are things being said, that come as blatant lies after a while (or right away), "I don't do anal, but ok I do anal and I love it". Or even better situation - near the end, no matter if you have relationship with Lisa Roche or not, when she and you enter house together one time, she suddenly says, she smells sex from you, and both of you must take bath with her, or else she will gossip about it everywhere in town. What the hell? She just behaves like a big child.
Older daughter is comically antagonistic, but her pranks aren't little things, but rather close to serious criminal offenses. Like drugging, blackmailing with false accusations, or lying to police to have MC jailed. And everyone just gloss over it, like 'ok, she did bad thing, but that's how she is, besides she won't do it again'. And guess what, then she does it again. And always thinks about how to mess with somebody (even if it isn't MC). Basically personality of 12YO bully kid.
Now let's talk about MC. He poses as rational adult, and yet in any case of actual confrontations is complete irredeemable pushower. Like burglars - dude is breaking into their home, MC is like twice his size, and yet what does he do? Screams like a girl and runs away, while throwing stuff. Only by accident ending in room with a gun, but even then he lets burglar go and don't call police. Or maybe when some drunk guy wanted to "hook up" with Charlotte. Try to get MC to push him and start a fight? Nice try, he only ended up with twisted arm and humiliation. The one and only moment when he acted like a man, was beating a guy, who promised to not defend. What a joke. Who behave this way? You guessed right - KIDS, again.
Now, before I played, I also saw some reviews, where people complained about just skipping some stuff. I didn't understand at first, but now I do. This game has a lot of content, which actually is good thing, but fails to make you emotionally attached to characters enough, and also fails with any form of keeping suspense, and can't do anything that will keep players focused and make them be interested with what's going on. Sad, but true, and I also skipped some content in the latter part.
Now, the endings are good, and actually managed to please me, after rather boring experience of latter half of the game. I'd say it was very satisfactory, and that's probably why I'm giving 4 not 3 stars for this. But it's worth mentioning, that every ending did skip some things, that seemed to be pretty important earlier. Like no mentions of Bonnie, no follow up on burglars after that one "super important" choice of giving alibi or not, nothing after this one weird event with money thief, which also had a choice and renpy variable. And probably there were also other things, but I can't remember now, even tho I just finished playing.
From the graphic side everything looks nice, maybe other than dev clearly liking to reuse some character poses. While thanks to the skillfull manipulation with camera angles and characters rotations it wasn't very noticeable in most cases, that one 'running' pose is so characteristic, I see it everytime, no matter how he tries to hide it, this was awfully generic.
And last thing - I don't understand why sex scenes have to be split on so many different positions. It felt like characters had to stop and change it every minute. 3 dialogue lines, BANG, change. And again. AND AGAIN! And yet another time! It's unnecessary and unnatural, I'd prefer if sex scenes only consisted of 2-3 properly done positions with longer dialogue parts.
