Pissing scene: a Pro or a Cons?

[The Dark Moonshine]

What's your opinion on Pissing scenes in porn games (just a few scenes, not all game related to pissing)?

Is it a plus? Or Is it something that should be avoided?

 

[MarshmallowCasserole]

I think that's one of those fetishes that you either avoid completely, or actually make it your focus. One scene is going to pi... annoy. It's going to annoy people who aren't into it, but won't be enough to attract people with that fetish.

 

[Rafster]

For me, it's hot, but I'm also into the WS kink.

But I don't think it's a popular kink, so if you include ways to skip it for people who doesn't want to see it, better. I do that in my game.

 

[redknight00]

I peed on Veronica in Pale Carnations, not because I'm into it, just as sign of disresect.

 

[FAEN1134]

Its good, but its a thing should be in a very close relationship or in humiliation, other than it devalue the narrative imo.
IRL many woman do not even shallow cum let alone piss.

 

[anne O'nymous]

What's your opinion on Pissing scenes in porn games (just a few scenes, not all game related to pissing)?

Is it a plus? Or Is it something that should be avoided?

Define "pissing scenes". Is it like in (too many) games, where you can watch at the girl pissing, or is it (way less frequent) effective Water Sport ? Players who aren't into WS would dislike the first one less than the second, and players who are into it would feel betrayed if it limits to the first one.

This being said, make the game you want, with the kinks you like and know how to write correctly enough. Then, when one of those kink is borderline, like here, either ask beforehand (and once for all) if the player agree to see it, or make it explicitly avoidable the few times it happen.

 

[Deleted member 440241]

I always hate it. If it can be avoided I do, but it's also rather irritating to get asked every time in repeatable scenes. Even worse is when one of the LIs bring it up as their fetish. You're either dealing with a scene you don't like or shutting down an LIs interest in a pretty harsh way.

 

[khumak]

Anything that normally involves a toilet is an automatic hard pass for me. I don't ever want to see that in a game. It could otherwise be the best game in the world but I'll never know, because the toilet scene disqualified it.

IMO, the only things I should ever see in a bathroom are the shower, the bathtub, and the sink.

 

[baneini]

I peed on Veronica in Pale Carnations, not because I'm into it, just as sign of disresect.

How does your monitor survive the water damage?

 

[baloneysammich]

I don't go looking for watersports content, but I can enjoy a bit of it from time to time. Whether as a "random" kink or an expression of masochism/humiliation fetish.

Thing is, I prefer when it comes as a surprise, which is probably the worst way to implement it if you don't want to anger most people. I'm not talking about withholding it from the list of tags of course. Just I prefer not to have a "Do you want to enable watersports?" question at the beginning or such. But I can appreciate what Tinman95 says about shutting down interest, so this leaves a bit of a dilemma. It's a shame we don't have a universal framework where players could specify acceptable content in a patch-type file that would be used by any game.

My advice would be to avoid it unless it's something you really want to include. And maybe if you're not too concerned with making money...

 

[The Dark Moonshine]

Great discussion, thank you to help me clarify the idea!

 

[amBest]

Honestly, I think it's an all or nothing type of deal. I don't think the general audience just goes "and after 30 hours of vanilla sex, someone pissed in somene else's mouth. AWESOME!". Most likely you'll get outrage from most people, and virtually no praise for people who are into that.

Me? I'm into that shit. In one of my favorite games, Defending Lyda Coller or some such. My brain doesn't do names. You can date this super cute ex stripper cop girl and have a wholesome relationship. Very cool, well wriiten. Nice. I like it.

Or you can turn her into a bimbo, force her to have breast enlargment surgery. Make her lick the floor of your car, throw a credit card in the toilet and have her dig it out of her own poop using nothing but her mouth. It is, and I can't say this enough, fucking amazing. Out of this world. Yes! MORE OF THAT.

It's perfectly fine, because you have a corruption path where you take her down this spiral of depravity, and it's awesome. But now think of this in a what would otherwise be a vanilla game. And out of nowhere, tongue fishing in poop. Do you think that would go well?

But why the poop example? Well, if you're considering watersports, you are probably not disgusted by it. But even someone like me, who is into scat, can look at it and say "yeaaaah, that's obviously disgusting and horrible". So I raised the stakes.

There are people, like me, who live for that shit (heh, pun). I actively look for games like that. I play every shitty Miel game that comes out, not because they're good. But because I know, my man, my dude, MC, will piss in every slut he ever meets. But the vast majority just wants nicely animated doggy-style and be fine with it. Maybe some daring wall-pinning action as a crescendo.

-------------

What I'm trying to say. It's off-putting for people not into it. And it's disappointing for people who are really into it (because there's not enough, no escalation, no downward spiral). Either go full hog or simply avoid.

 

[Meaning Less]

I played so many games that have just one or a few urination scenes, so I assume it is common to use it that way, often they use it tastefuly:
spying on a character peeing, character being drunk and peeing where they shouldn't, light bdsm scenes where you walk the character like a dog and make them pee on their fours.

There are many different ways to use urination kink without going into the "pee in my mouth" territory, which isn't as common and often reserved for more hardcore games.

 

[Chalker]

WS is okay, I don't really have much of an opinion on it.
scat is going to far for me personally.

 

[HarveyD]

Pissing scenes? God no. I'm so glad the whole POV MC takes a morning piss, which used to be in so many games, seems to have died off. Spying on a girl pissing doesn't do much for me either.

Actual watersports content though? Great!

I always hate it. If it can be avoided I do, but it's also rather irritating to get asked every time in repeatable scenes. Even worse is when one of the LIs bring it up as their fetish. You're either dealing with a scene you don't like or shutting down an LIs interest in a pretty harsh way.

It doesn't have to, and shouldn't, be written as shutting them down in a harsh way though. It should be fine to have two characters discuss kinks and have one not want to do something the other is into.

 

[hakarlman]

The question is flawed.

If you're into pissing fetish, add it to your game, but don't force it. Make it optional. That's it, problem solved. Add whatever turns you on to your game, then make every sexual encounter optional. If the player finds themselves enjoying 80-90% of your games sexual content, there's a high chance they'll sub to your patreon.

The worst mistake you can make is forcing a sexual scenario on the player they're not into. So the easiest solution here: never force any sexual scenario, EVER.

If your game has transitotyr sex scenes, where you transition from vaginal to anal, you need to make sure the player CHOSE to have vaginal sex, but you can't just force anal afterwards, have to present it as an option, so anal is never forced.

If you follow the above logic, you'll make $$$.

 

[Bombmaster]

Depends on the situation. I'm kinda neutral about.
For dominance like cited in pale carnations is cool.

And when the participants have real Intimacy. Not just a fling.

Young again with MC sister is hot because is pushing their boundaries.

And obviously in a bathroom is acceptable.

 

[Beatrix Kiddo]

Not something I look out for, but a sprinkle of watersports is always a nice touch.

 

[Seneque514]

It all depends on why and how. A woman who urinates is in a position of ''fragility'' and offers a sharing of her most complete intimacy to her partner, Lover, or Master. The Game Fallen has such a scene the lady urinates squatting and asks her companion to watch telling him 'you always liked watching me urinate'. In the case of domination a form of control by the master over the submissive, and for the submissive a testimony of total submission. For exhibitionist women it is a pleasure, a form of seduction game for her and their father. Fetish locator addresses these aspects a little. In a vanilla relationship during riding or grinding some women let a little of their urine leak out because of a weak bladder, or excitement and total abandonment, if they know they are confident. and feel that their partner enjoys this moist and warm communion. Many women when approaching an orgasm feel an urge to urinate Caused by the internal network of nerves of the clitoris which becomes engorged with blood, swells and puts pressure. on the bladder. And by the way, all men, from childhood, have once or sometimes spied on women in the toilet... How the other sex pees is one of the first curiosity about the other sex. At the end Juliette Lewis ( Mallory ) pee scene

You must be registered to see the links