POLL: How GOOD(Morals) aligned do you want to be when playing a porn game?

[hakarlman]

I'm wondering if anyone here actually wants to play as a Christian/Catholic/Muslim (or similar fantasy wording that represents the same values ), in a porn game; with the exception of being able to have multiple -optional girlfriends/wives/flings. Your MC could carry themselves with high moral value, fiber, decency, while still having tons of sex with multiple women, but who rejects degeneracy. My guess is that you'd consider fetishes and kinks as unnatural, so vaginal and blowjob is about as far as you'll go, and MAYBE anal (optional)? OR maybe you still want access to all the most perverse kinks, but play your MC as the most moral person possible?

I've noticed that a lot of people complain about the MC being too much of a jerk or asshole in games. They want to play their MC as a nice and decent guy who still has lots of sexual fun. I'm curious just how good aligned you want your MC to be, in a porn game?

(Let's not worry about Harem for now, because that will complicate the poll.)

Long story short, does anyone actually want to play as a righteous MC(like a Christian/Catholic/Muslim, but with different wording and context)?

This is just a rough, core example, that can be expanded on or altered, yet its core ideal remains intact:
a) Love & Lust (Pragmatic)
b) Love only (Righteous)
c) Lust only (Corrupt)

Then being GOOD or EVIL is separate from the above, because you could technically enjoy love and/or lust, while being evil, or while being good, correct?

EDIT: If enough people smash the logic of the poll, I'll close it, but hopefully it withstands.

EDIT: Basically, I don't want to create a Super Good and Moral path in my game, if no one is going to pick it.

EDIT: To clarify, I would never use the terms Christian/Catholic/Muslim in the game, since the goal is not to remind anyone of real life, rather make a game that serves as a fun and naughty escape from everything.

EDIT: The two responses already received on this thread have helped me IMMENSELY. Very much appreciated.

 

[Meaning Less]

It really depends on the game.

On comedic games I don't mind playing with an asshole mc, it can be funny and silly when done right.

On games with a more serious tone, asshole mcs are going to be harder to balance, there is always a line where it stops being fun and you start disliking the mc and just feeling bad for every other character involved.

Righteous MCs I don't mind, but those are used mostly for corruption otherwise there would be no sex, like femdom or reverse rape games where you play with a MC that is trying to follow the righteous path but ends up being dragged out of it.

 

[Deleted member 440241]

I've noticed that a lot of people complain about the MC being too much of a jerk or asshole in games. They want to play their MC as a nice and decent guy who still has lots of sexual fun. I'm curious just how good aligned you want your MC to be, in a porn game?

Mostly I just don't want to be an asshole. The MC can do morally questionable things, but when he's constantly perving on the girls around him it gets old fast. Especially when doing so becomes a requirement to moving the sex scenes/story along. I want LIs in a game to be characters I can get attached to. By extension, I don't want the MC representing me to be a total douchenozzle to the LIs I'm attached to. In short leave their panties alone, stop peeping into the shower, and don't make sleep molestation a prerequisite for a loving relationship.

 

[Pretentious Goblin]

Female MC: Starts out virtuous, then falls into corruption. The better that's written, the more I will enjoy the game. If it's badly written, I'm going to drop it regardless of other qualities.

Male MC: No good guys, please. No rapists or horndogs either. The more aligned the male MC is with my focus on corruption, the better I'll like him. Whereas most male MCs I just find annoying. An evil overlord who avoids violence where possible but enjoys manipulating and corrupting those around him would be a good example of one I'd enjoy playing as. Female version of that would be fine too, but the corruptor isn't the focal point of the sex.

Romance does nothing for me unless it's part of a corruption arc.

 

[ayy]

Male MC: No good guys, please. No rapists or horndogs either. The more aligned the male MC is with my focus on corruption, the better I'll like him. Whereas most male MCs I just find annoying. An evil overlord who avoids violence where possible but enjoys manipulating and corrupting those around him would be a good example of one I'd enjoy playing as.

Romance does nothing for me unless it's part of a corruption arc.

yeah what this guy said.

 

[Deleted member 5410619]

It is a hard pick.
I like my mc to be manipulative.
The goal is to corrupt woman into sex starved bitch eager to please my every whim.
Who are compleetly devoted to me(or atleast my cock).

There are two types of villian.
The thug and the big bad.
The thug is rude, stupid and only good to die for there betters.
This is the jerk mc that many people hate.
The big bad is smart, well spoken and manipulative.
He makes you believe it was your choice to betray your daughter and help him rape her.

I am not playing these game for the love part.
Honestly the suger talk is sicking.
I am playing these games to feel empowered.
To feel like i can control people in a way i could never do in real life.

When it come's to making a main characters these are my tips:
1: No internal dialog.
Too many mc have entire internal debate's.
Internal dialog at most shoud be used as a tip to find the next trigger.

2: Be polite.
Cursing, namecalling, smoking.
None of these add to a game.
Cursing shoud be used sparingly.
Nobody like a pottymouth.

3: No opinions.
Every time i read an mc talking about how he like big tits or his mother is hot i want to uninstall the game.
The mc is our vessel to experiance the game.
He shoud be as blank as possible.
Only having dialog and thoughts to advance the story.
If it doesnt help with the quest dont add it.

 

[derkholmLord]

I prefer characters who essentially follow the golden rule - respect those who respect you in kind, but seek revenge on those who try to take unfair advantage.

 

[Eagle1900]

I have no limits! in games they are really the worst part there can be, i don't know why, in my real life i would never think about doing certain things, while in games i don't give a damn about being the "good guy".
fortunately there are the tags and I look first to get an idea of what I'm getting into, for the rest ... depravity endlessly go go

 

[anne O'nymous]

He can be the nice guy that even his own cat bully all day long, or have turned cold blooded killer seeking for revenge, depending what the story need him to be, as long as the MC is neither unfair with others, nor a pure asshole, generally I'm good with it.

It's not the acts that define if the MC is good or bad, it's the motive behind them. You want him to kill everyone ? Well, if it's because each one of those victims are responsible for the death of his daughter, by example, I'm totally fine with it. But if it's just because he's a psychopath who like to kill, then it will be without me.
Take The DeLuca Family by example. It stand on the parody side, but with a serious writing and, while the MC is presented as a good guy, he now works for the mafia. I tend to play him with restraint, but if one day the MC is facing one of the guys who did that to Luna, HopesGaming can let us without choice and present the MC performing the most sadistic torture scene ever wrote, I would be totally fine with it. It's an evil act but, from the point of view of the story, after what they did to Luna and what happened to Sofia, it's also a good deed and the MC would still be neutral/good even after this.

To reference what have been said above, to some extend I'm also fine with a pervy MC, as long as there's a real meaning behind his peeping habit and sleep molestation. And by "real meaning" I don't mean that he's a horny douchebag, it need to be something effectively relevant to the story. He can be under someone's control (a Succubus by example but it's a cliché), blackmailed to it, or on a Femdom story it can be the premise that will force him to submit.
In those case he act like an asshole, but have a reason to do it and it's not necessarily who he effectively his. Outside of those moment he need to drop his asshole attitude and be hmm... Not necessarily a nice guy, but at least not a total jerk.

 

[eeeira]

I voted for
Degenerate: I NEVER play a moral MC in porn games, I go for mega corruption, evil & max perversity.

having voted for this, I wish to point out I dislike the cartoon villinary version of this. Nor do i enjoy it this style of play when it, dosn`t even make sense in world lore setting. Some game have it so brokern with the above answer it dosnt even make porn logic sense.

I perfer my answer above that I voted for with a bit more of a touch of realism in the game and game world lore etc.

The reason for this, is because I hate excessive grind stats etc and content locked by doing more of a good or pragmatic play through.

Nor have i seen any game truly implement this concept well eg 10/10 ever. More so when its judged by context of world building lore of game universe.

Something else i like to say in my opinion, I`ve always wanted but never found any games to my satisfaction, that dose decent corruption of MC from eg religious order to slut well.

Edit: two themes I want to do with my above answer i voted for but never seen in a game where your Female mc.
Is be evil via: forcing other girls get pregnant on purpose. To knowing they catch std`s. Are to evil like themes I`ve not seen in any game that i come across.
Again each person has different likes and dislikes thats fine I believe in live and let live for kinks to each person.

 

[Porthas]

hakarlman

I picked "other". I'd prefer a choice, like the Renegade/Paragon system for Mass Effect.

And I'm going to lean "Paragon" but sometimes that just doesn't make sense. That Renegade... sometimes it just feels right.

Not exactly like that system, of course. But the idea behind being able to go through the story the way you want is extremely appealing.

Every game is going to have limits. That's a given.

But let us pick if we wanna be a creeper or a white knight or warm-hearted/cold hearted pragmatist.

Also let us pick how we want to have the sex.

An even *more* interesting poll would be how people feel about stupid MC's. I think it's not as funny as dev's think it is, and it comes across as a lazy story device to get some drama going.

 

[MasterGamer1234567890]

Below has nothing to do with my moral or how good aligned I want to be with the MC. This is all about how I want the MC to be in a game which is a fantasy and has nothing to do with real life.

There is missing an option between pragmatic and degenerate. I hate any kind of violence, but I like the MC to cross the girls lines like cumming inside them when they say no, use sabotaged condoms, have them tied up with consent and then fuck their asses against their consent, rent the girls out against their will, while they are tied up, have the girls working in a brothel, despite it's clearly something they don't want to do, but do it because they depend on the MC, not because they love him.

Games like that is unfortunately very rare.

 

[VegitoHlove]

It really depends on the game.

On comedic games I don't mind playing with an asshole mc, it can be funny and silly when done right.

On games with a more serious tone, asshole mcs are going to be harder to balance, there is always a line where it stops being fun and you start disliking the mc and just feeling bad for every other character involved.

Righteous MCs I don't mind, but those are used mostly for corruption otherwise there would be no sex, like femdom or reverse rape games where you play with a MC that is trying to follow the righteous path but ends up being dragged out of it.

This, I feel the same way about my play style and the games in general, not to say I don't do the corrupt paths in the same games but my first playthrough often follows the same kind of logic.

 

[GuiltyZ]

Female MC: Starts out virtuous, then falls into corruption. The better that's written, the more I will enjoy the game. If it's badly written, I'm going to drop it regardless of other qualities.

Male MC: No good guys, please. No rapists or horndogs either. The more aligned the male MC is with my focus on corruption, the better I'll like him. Whereas most male MCs I just find annoying. An evil overlord who avoids violence where possible but enjoys manipulating and corrupting those around him would be a good example of one I'd enjoy playing as. Female version of that would be fine too, but the corruptor isn't the focal point of the sex.

Romance does nothing for me unless it's part of a corruption arc.

Do you have recommendations for that kind of Male MC? A game where sex isn't the MAIN focus (Could be a large part but there's rich story telling), it's there and nice to have sure, but you have multiple ways of dealing with situations (Whether as evil as possible, righteous, neutral, pragmatic, Horny, a combination of these, and etc).

 

[..........t]

I chose the second option but sometimes I choose to play as a degenerate because I'm trying see more content.

 

[Pretentious Goblin]

Do you have recommendations for that kind of Male MC? A game where sex isn't the MAIN focus (Could be a large part but there's rich story telling), it's there and nice to have sure, but you have multiple ways of dealing with situations (Whether as evil as possible, righteous, neutral, pragmatic, Horny, a combination of these, and etc).

Most games don't give you that much freedom, because it involves a lot more work for the dev. Maybe they'll give you "rape" and "not-rape". If you want story-rich with male-MC, TLS is probably your best bet, and I think it gives you choices sometimes too.

 

[haksaw]

Depends on a plot. I generally like when MC is in opposition to the cast. Either he is evil corrupting good girls, or he is good reforming bad girls (with his holy cock of course). Good MC + good girls is boring. Love is boring too, of course. If the MC is good, he should roast witches at his stake, not do dates or some other uwu crap.

 

[PTSdev]

Chaotic neutral is the way to go.

 

[GuiltyZ]

Most games don't give you that much freedom, because it involves a lot more work for the dev. Maybe they'll give you "rape" and "not-rape". If you want story-rich with male-MC, TLS is probably your best bet, and I think it gives you choices sometimes too.

What about Games such as these: "The more aligned the male MC is with my focus on corruption, the better I'll like him. Whereas most male MCs I just find annoying. An evil overlord who avoids violence where possible but enjoys manipulating and corrupting those around him would be a good example of one I'd enjoy playing as. "

 

[Pretentious Goblin]

What about Games such as these: "The more aligned the male MC is with my focus on corruption, the better I'll like him. Whereas most male MCs I just find annoying. An evil overlord who avoids violence where possible but enjoys manipulating and corrupting those around him would be a good example of one I'd enjoy playing as. "

These aren't without violence but the MC is interested in corruption rather than just brutality or sex.

https://f95zone.to/threads/something-unlimited-v2-3-95-gunsmoke-games.326/
https://f95zone.to/threads/tyrant-quest-ch1-to-10-ending4-7_rin-redikal.30393/
https://f95zone.to/threads/venus-blood-chimera-ninetail-dual-tail.11015/ (post-mortem netoring the hero who sacrificed himself trying to kill you. Delectable)
https://f95zone.to/threads/hero-party-must-fall-v0-4-alpha-nitrolith.100153/
https://f95zone.to/threads/corrupted-saviors-release-36c-csdev.63932/

Overwhored also works great because the MC is basically an avatar of corruption with mind-melting powers, while the MC from News Desk has exactly the kind of attitude I want - the sex is secondary compared to making his rival his submissive bitch.