Rance IX is not a bad VN, or a bad entry to the series, but it's a product that is susceptible to inner comparisons. Much of the "irreverence" of the initial (2) titles is gone. Worldbuilding, and some aspects of storytelling are inferior to VI. Gameplay mechanics were much better in Quest (personal). And the spark of brilliancy that can be found in Sengoku is certainly not here. With that said, there are addendums to these ideas: Rance is at a point where "he still does his thing", but his evolution has reached a state of maturity, and balance; Some new characters manage to surpass expectations, and generate likability ("Miracle Tor"); 18+ is still great; And Rance IX exists to wrap up things nicely, before moving to the "big stage" (advancing mechanism, if you will). If you like Rance there's no reason to avoid this, it's just that comparisons are getting in the way of a better score.
Positive:
- Adult content has quantity, quality, diversity, originality...; The new (main) heroines become relevant quickly, the old ones that got the spotlight were well picked; Gameplay is OK (not that engaging maybe); Scenario and narrative organization have focus and "smaller scale" going for them (always a problem before); Rance's character progress is in full display, with many previous events contributing to that result (long-term development); And it's always subjective, but this might be one of the funniest "Rances".
Negative:
- Most mentions would be born of unavoidable comparisons to other entries in the series. This is a good mix of story, gameplay, and 18+, that's what needs to be said.
Score: 7/10, and a mandatory read for Rance fans. In the grand scheme of things, this is solid entertainment with adult content, that is made better by reading what came before. Unfortunately, the notion of "what came before" is filled with examples of quality (or just a different approach), that surpass some of what's delivered in Rance IX. Hardly fair, and yet you are not playing this by itself (well, you shouldn't). Recommended for fans of the series.
Positive:
- Adult content has quantity, quality, diversity, originality...; The new (main) heroines become relevant quickly, the old ones that got the spotlight were well picked; Gameplay is OK (not that engaging maybe); Scenario and narrative organization have focus and "smaller scale" going for them (always a problem before); Rance's character progress is in full display, with many previous events contributing to that result (long-term development); And it's always subjective, but this might be one of the funniest "Rances".
Negative:
- Most mentions would be born of unavoidable comparisons to other entries in the series. This is a good mix of story, gameplay, and 18+, that's what needs to be said.
Score: 7/10, and a mandatory read for Rance fans. In the grand scheme of things, this is solid entertainment with adult content, that is made better by reading what came before. Unfortunately, the notion of "what came before" is filled with examples of quality (or just a different approach), that surpass some of what's delivered in Rance IX. Hardly fair, and yet you are not playing this by itself (well, you shouldn't). Recommended for fans of the series.