Requesting CP/banned content = INSTANT BAN

[Ukghar]

I don't think you understand the context or meaning here.

Maybe so.

From my understanding proposed regulation was "Requesting CP/banned content = INSTANT BAN". And list of banned content isn't public. As such it would be punishing someone for doing something that they could not have even known was prohibited. That's similar to punishing individuals by the North Korean authorities for violating parts of the country's criminal code that are not publicly disclosed. That's why I saw "a disturbing similarity".

Still, have I wrongly assumed that "Requesting CP/banned content = INSTANT BAN" also means that requesting games/comics with CP that appear occasionally/once is subject to instant ban? If my interpretation is correct - the question "what level of due diligence [in checking if the work contains cp] is required?" persists.

 

[morphnet]

Still, have I wrongly assumed that "Requesting CP/banned content = INSTANT BAN"

Ok to make it absolutely clear....

"Requesting CP/banned content = INSTANT BAN"

CP is real life stuff i.e. real children
Banned content is rule 7 stuff etc. i.e. loli / shota.

also means that requesting games/comics with CP that appear occasionally/once is subject to instant ban?

I know of no comics or games that contain CP but IF they do exist then YES, VERY MUCH YES instant ban and I hope they also get reported to the authorities.

BUT it is not limited to comics / games, ANY form = instant ban

If my interpretation is correct - the question "what level of due diligence [in checking if the work contains cp] is required?" persists

None, NO due diligence, if someone asks for CP they don't get or deserve "due" anything, instant ban and again hopefully reported to the authorities.

This is why I said I don't think you understand the context or meaning...

Next time it might be better to ask rather than comparing the site to NK and implying the rules might be unfair.

 

[Ukghar]

Ok to make it absolutely clear....

"Requesting CP/banned content = INSTANT BAN"
CP is real life stuff i.e. real children
Banned content is rule 7 stuff etc. i.e. loli / shota.

I know of no comics or games that contain CP but IF they do exist then YES, VERY MUCH YES instant ban and I hope they also get reported to the authorities.

BUT it is not limited to comics / games, ANY form = instant ban

None, NO due diligence, if someone asks for CP they don't get or deserve "due" anything, instant ban and again hopefully reported to the authorities.

This is why I said I don't think you understand the context or meaning...

Next time it might be better to ask rather than comparing the site to NK and implying the rules might be unfair.

Well, I assumed that "CP" stands for "child pornography", meaning something like "any visual depiction of a minor engaging in sexual activity." If "CP" is restricted to "real life stuff" that changes a lot.

I also don't know of any comics or games that contain "CP" as defined by you, but as you wisely pointed out, they might exist. And if they do, we're back to square one: "What level of due diligence [in checking if the work contains CP] is required?"

Here are some examples that I hope are non-controversial:
1) comics or games from the dark web – these should not be requested for various reasons;
2) comics or games from respected publishers – these should be safe to request for various reasons.
But what about things in between? For instance, comics or games published by smaller creators, where the available information does not indicate the presence of CP content? In such cases, I believe it would be unfair to impose an instant ban on someone for requesting the game or comic in question.

Of course, if "CP" is strictly limited to "real life stuff", such situations are less likely to occur, but they remain a possibility.

 

[morphnet]

If "CP" is restricted to "real life stuff" that changes a lot.

Not sure why you would think IF here, the title says Requesting CP/banned content = INSTANT BAN, the / stands for, and or, so if someone requests CP and or banned content.

I also don't know of any comics or games that contain "CP" as defined by you

It is not my definition but one I fully support and agree with and so does everyone else who know the term and content.

And if they do, we're back to square one: "What level of due diligence [in checking if the work contains CP] is required?"

You have already asked this and I answered it.

None, NO due diligence, if someone asks for CP they don't get or deserve "due" anything, instant ban and again hopefully reported to the authorities.

You have full access to the request section and can clearly see the types of requests made.

Here are some examples that I hope are non-controversial:
1) comics or games from the dark web – these should not be requested for various reasons;
2) comics or games from respected publishers – these should be safe to request for various reasons.
But what about things in between? For instance, comics or games published by smaller creators, where the available information does not indicate the presence of CP content? In such cases, I believe it would be unfair to impose an instant ban on someone for requesting the game or comic in question.

You clearly are NOT thinking this all the way through.

I am hoping / assuming this is a translation issue and not you ignoring that facts.