I am not a huge fan of the show, i've seen several seasons way back many years ago, i don't like the artstyle really, i went in with lowest expectations possible thinking that the high rating is a result of a rabid fanbase clicking 5 stars on everything related they see.
I was happy to be proven wrong.
Writing is surprisingly great and faithful to the show, characters are faithfully portrayed and stay within their personalities and roles, it's a fun and decently interesting read, the amount of content is absolutely monstrous, it got a ton of QOL things (like picking your age, the way you see certain characters, to do it inside or outside e.t.c.), there is an option to skip any scene you aren't comfortable with, even the artstyle grew on me. If you like a heavy incest/harem type of game, that is absolutely something to experience.
There were couple detractors from experience however, first of all is a complete lack of sound. I am used to it but in a game of such otherwise immaculate quality this is something that stands out like a sore thumb and bring it a little bit down. Another thing that got on my nerves is characters often doing the same routine as previous sexual interactions, which is especially notable in Beth and Summer. You would think after first 7-8 times they would act at least a bit differently.
The main dissapointment however is how many secondary threads and characters are just completely abandoned. For good 90% of secondary characters you see just several times you keep thinking "alright, there is one last defining scene left, i can't wait for it", but it just never comes. Nancy, Gazorp people, Frank's mom, Vindicators, Reka, horse princess and many others feel like their stories are simply unfinished, their potential pregnancy never pays off (hell it doesn't pay off even for main cast), and overall the game just doesn't feel... finished. It just really need to tie a bow on everyone involved in one good perfect epilogue and it will be a rare geniune 5/5 game that actually deserves it. But it doesn't have this epilogue yet, so here we are.
Other than that it's a truly unexpected display of care, quality and passion that shines in almost everything it set out to do. So if you approach this with caution because you are not familiar with source material or doubt this is good, tis good.