Unity - Completed - Scarlet Maiden [v1.3.3] [Otterside Games]

  1. 2.00 star(s)

    Deleted member 2191732

    TL;DR: Doesn't live up to the hype, not worth your time, play Rogue Legacy 2 instead.
    2/5.

    If you are like me, you'll have checked the comments on the first two pages and checked the two existing reviews.
    And if you are like me, you'd wonder what all the hype was about.
    And if you're like me, you'd download and try the game.
    And if you're like me, you'd immediately notice that the spears have no attack chain, just the basic thrust with a little pause and then repeating that thrust. And you'll notice that some elite enemies stagger when you hit 'em and some don't, and sometimes you take single digits of damage from a particular enemy but sometimes you take upwards of 80 (on the second floor, no less) and 99% of the stuff you find is utterly useless because you only have four equipment slots (ring, necklace, weapon, spell) and if you keep finding things only for one slot then you're SOL and you'll wonder why are there teleportation points in direct line of fire of traps you can't disable and--

    I mean, it wants to be Rogue Legacy, but it doesn't have any of the inspiration, the charm, the variety in classes (you're a girl that twats things with her melee weapon until the game randomly drops you something that returns mana, then you're still primarily twatting things with your melee weapon because it stunlocks them until you come across something you cannot stunlock then you can choose to cast a spell if that's so interesting). It doesn't have the spell or weapon variety, it doesn't have pretty much anything remotely resembling what RL has.
    So why bother with it? Go play RL. This game isn't worth your time.

    Oh, maybe it's good for the adult content? No, it isn't. What's there is a few sprite animations you'd get far better and easier elsewhere, and there isn't even a gallery so you can't excuse it by "shooting for 100%". There is simply no reason to bother with this.

    In points:
    Combat is whack (-1*): if an enemy hits me for 3-5 damage with a particular move when I have 0% damage reduction, it shouldn't be able to also hit me for 60-80 damage with the same move on the next run when I have 60% damage reduction. Remember, your starting maximum health is 88, so if you took ANY damage before that hit, you're within one-hit-kill territory even with 60% DR. What is this, a sniper rifle headshot? No, get back to the drawing board and balance this nonsense.
    No gallery (-1*): self-explanatory. I don't know why developers stopped making those, but by God Almighty I'll score every single game I review -1* if they don't have one. If I were the kind of person who really liked something in the game and kept this installed (although in this case, there really isn't any reason to), I want to be able to see the goods on demand once I've unlocked them. This not only gives you a clear way to tell when you've seen everything, but also makes shooting for 100% interesting, fun and worthwhile. Lacking a gallery is missing out on all of this.
    Why are there teleportation points in direct path of traps? (-1*): this is a personal pet peeve, but this is my review, and I'm not going to let this slide. If you dared to minimize while it's loading, and the particular point you chose has traps on it, you come back to being dead. This doesn't make any sense, does nothing for game balance, does nothing for progression (as someone else pointed out, you can probably unlock most things in a few hours anyway) and only frustrates you if it happens, and the game this thing is trying to ape figured this years ago, so I don't understand why this is still a problem.

    2/5. A poor imitation you shouldn't play because Rogue Legacy and Rogue Legacy 2 exist and are both infinitely better.
  2. 4.00 star(s)

    silentndeadly

    As of posting the game is not finished, despite it being released on Steam.

    I recommend this game just for the gameplay.
    Aside from a rather abrupt ending, Scarlet Maiden is some kind of love-child between Rogue Legacy and a random hentai schoolgirl.

    Gameplay loop is on-point. Each run (if you survive to the end) can take anywhere from 20 to 30 minutes, and it's all buttery smooth and decently challenging.
    Platforming is responsive, combat is snappy, and exploration changes each run.
    My only complaint would be the dark rooms, with no light. Ranged enemies that you can't see hitting you from off-screen is just rude.

    The game looks good, and I would have loved to see more of it. There's a lot of fetishes for a lot of different folks, from spanking, blowjobs, strap-ons, futas, giantesses, slime-girls, lactation... the list goes on.
    Sadly, the animations are terribly short. I'm not sure it's even possible to actually get off to this game, especially with no gallery.

    But it is just good to play. By the 3rd hour in (of like, five, I dunno) I was actively avoiding the smut because it slowed the gameplay down.

    Heroine-chan~! I need you to fist my lewd, dripping, giantess pussy~
    Hell Naw! I stacked flame damage, upgraded my dash, and grabbed a Fire Shield.
    No time for your needs; I'm killing the boss!
    Pain train comin' through! CHOO CHOO!


    So, yeah. Game's good.
    I despise unfinished releases, but I ain't even mad on this one. Game's good.
  3. 5.00 star(s)

    Risvell

    'Rogue Lewdacy' plays way better than it has any right to, somehow this is a proper roguelite! The way the characters are styled in their sprites isn't my thing, which is a shame when the majority of lewdness comes from in-game miniscenes, but I have respect for the level of craft at display and wouldn't want somebody passing this without giving it a shot. My eyes are on these devs for whatever comes next
  4. 4.00 star(s)

    Eepy Poss

    They've done it, the horny man's Rogue Legacy. For real though this is basically rogue legacy meets porn and it's done pretty well. Its far easier than RL and still has a decent variety with the weapons and spells as well as the accessories that support a variety of builds. There is definitely a ton more game than there is porn with porn being just the visual theme of the game for the most part.

    That said the difficulty being far easier than RL means you can have a more casually fun time with it as it's ridiculously easy to amass a ton of sin (money) per run that you can probably max out all the vendors in about 3 runs depending on how good you are. Aside from that you just pump it into stats and this game snowballs at a pretty good pace that'll still beat your ass if you sleep on it and try to rush through everything.

    I think if I had to point out some issues it would be some relatively minor nitpicks. Things like not knowing which chests drop what or even if you have to trade for them are never explained, although you learn quickly that they're all free. There's a handful of interactable things that are all basically just a different porny visual of a chest. Other than that there's definitely a lack of survivability. There's no health drops anywhere and most life steal weapons are at like 2-5% chances. Once you're out of potions you're at the mercy of the game and whether or not it rewards you with a place to buy another potion. Also the bosses barely give you any sin compared to all the sin you accumulate through just destroying objects, let alone killing everything.

    Don't play this if you just want the porn. This is one of those ones where the game is the priority and it's done well. You'll definitely need to beat the game before you can really enjoy the animations but even then the pixel work and animations are pretty great. Definitely worth it.