I understand the qualms others seem to have with this game, however, I feel they are a bit strong with their negative opinions and worry they may scare off players who may actually enjoy a game such as this, I certainly did.
First off, the artwork is excellent. I prefer animated scenes but for still images, this game does all you can ask for by providing several different portraits of each girl.
Next, the gameplay is fun and simple. 2 choices. Either you attack or defend. If you're wrong, you get to experience unique and entertaining dialogue before having to restart the battle learning from your one trial and error. In other words, the game doesn't waste your time.
Finally, the story and dialogue is entertaining. The characters silly and quirky, the main character pitiful and loveable. And no character is introduced who you don't end up seeing naked, so everything has a payoff.
As stated in other reviews, the game does have flaws. My biggest problem is the size of the games window. It doesn't allow you to go full screen, while also taking up enough space within the limited sized window that you have to scroll to see all content. The problem with this is that the artwork doesn't adjust to your scrolling, meaning you end up cutting off the girls heads in orer to continue the dialogue.
Secondly, there is no gallery and only three save slots, meaning if you like more than three scenes, you better have bandicam ready otherwise it's a few battles and a lot of dialogue every time you want to rewatch a scene.
Lastly, the ending is a mixed bag. On one hand, there are 14 endings, which is fun to go through and see them all, the only problem is that they all require you to face the final boss repeatedly, which take a minute. I won't let the unsatisfying nature of the endings affect my review for they are plentiful and entertaining, but I will say that a final aftermath scene with the big boss herself was sorely missing. It isn't satisfying o have to restart the game in order to get the single panel in which you actually tame the dragon, especially after having seen it already. Why wasn't she included among the girls you could settle down with?
All in all, fun game that is enjoyable for what it is, which is a unique adventure with unconventional fighting strategies that are great. I truly believe it deserves 4 stars, but need to off set some of these more scathing reviews. Game isn't that bad at all.