This must be the most inconsistent NTR shitfest I've ever played, reaching from very bad to really good in its quality on multiple occasions.
The chaos starts with the enginge: u either have to play the first chapters as RPGM or opt to install one of the (multiple?) RenPy Remakes of the first chapters available on this site. Those come without the obvious downsides of RPGM games, but bring other flaws like missing sound/audio. In any case, after u make it through this first challenge (u also could just give a shit and skip the first chapters, starting with the later Renpy chapters here all along), u finally land in the current wip-live version of "Shadows of Desire".
But how is the whole thing executed? As a first disclosure: If u have a general problem with NTR or the more specific premise: "black alpha male steals white beta's girlfriend"- don't play the game.
The main trope- your girlfriend cheats on you, cuckolds you or gets blackmailed (3 paths available) by/with a black bull is basically excellent. Camila is extremely hot and, within limitations of porn logic, is written and developed okayish. If the game would just focus on that, it might be a clear 5/5. But the game SPAMS you to oblivion with unnecessary sidecharacters. U will propaply lose track of who the fuck this girl or mom was. Your mom, sister, stepmother, girlfriend, stepmother on your father's side, step-sister on your degenerated mothers-aunt-side, your best friends girlfriend and their best female friends...all of those and more (yes, I exaggerated a little) basically get some BBC action aswell. Game is COMPLETELY over the fucking top with it and you most likely will start to be annoyed by constantly being drawn into side plots.
Then there is more flaws:
- General writing quality is often meh. Both formally and in terms of content. Not always though, I found the micrrowriting of the lewd scenes with Camila really good most of the time. (And this is something a lot of porn games completely fail in- long enough h-scenes with accordingly exectued microwriting).
- There is a lot of racism in the game. And no, not the "mimimi im a SJW and find the idea of black man stealing white GF in NTR porn games racist itself"-racism, but blatant N-word-dropping etc. I personally find this completelly unnecessary and disgusting.
- Quality is just inconsistent. Generally the game improves qualitywise the deeper you're in. You start with a very basic RPGM/silent RenPy-Game and later on you get pretty solid CGs, animations and audio support. But even in later segments of the game you will have parts which stand out or fall off.
- There is some unnecessary open-worldish sections in the game in which you will partly try to figure out what the hell to do and where the fuck to go.
- U basically decide for one of the 3 main routes, and then this was it with decisions. Not only can u not really influence the outcome of the game from there onwards (for the most part), u can also mostly not skip side-content you don't want (like the legions of additional girls) or specific kinks. I personally would have really liked to be able to skip the blatant and cruel rape-content for example.
- Audio. Game could make use of more lewd sounds (there are some, but just not enough) and especially needs to fix the volume mix of its audio files, especially in h-scenes. Lot of the times the lewdsounds are too quiet and hardly hearable, even if u play with 100%, music off and your pc volume turned up quite high.
It is almost absurd how many flaws and downsides "Shadows of Desire" brings, but still propaply is one of the better NTR games out there. Cause there is also just so much GOOD stuff of a surprising and unusual quality. Did I mention the high quality of the main trope and the microwriting? But there is more: there is actual voicing of Camila in later segments of the game, which fits in really well (for the most part exclusively in h-scenes).
At the end of the day: if your into (BBC-)NTR, you should play this. You will almost certainly be annoyed from this game from time to time or feel like just wasting your time, but you will also have a lot of hot moments and opportunities to squeeze one out.