4.5 out of 5 stars.
I was nervous about playing this one; the girls' looks are wonky at first, especially when compared to the standard Daz character models also in the game, but you quickly grow used to them and find them endearing.
I was also nervous about all the reviews describing the MC as a cuck or loser, but it didn't take long for me to realize these reviews are written by douchebags. The MC is a good man- one of the best I've seen in a porn VN. He's kind, honest, and principled; his initial hesitance to pursue the three main girls is entirely justified and respectable, especially considering the bullshit he's been through. I found myself agreeing with him roughly 80% of the time.
The sex scenes are above average; there's plenty of dirty talk and dialogue to make them feel real, even if there's a whole lot of "UNNGH" and "FWAAAGH" jargon.
The overall narrative feels great. Character development is slow but visible from one day to the next. I'm not entirely sure where the story is going (besides the harem endgoal), but I'm eager to see it.
I only noticed 2 cons to the game so far. The first is the writing; while the intent behind the dialogue is great, there are a LOT of grammar issues in chapter 1. Punctuation mixups, capitalization issues and the omnipresent misuse of the words "to" and "too". It really fucks with the flow of the dialogue at first. It nearly killed the game for me, but I powered through it and got engrossed by the characters and the story enough that I was able to ignore the writing issues. Chapter 2 seems to have almost no such problems in comparison.
The second problem is with the MC in the last third of chapter 1. I know, I said I like him, and I do- but that last 20% of the time I didn't agree with him, it was because he just won't shut up about how wrong all this is. As things are ramping up with some of the girls, he refuses to acknowledge simple, obvious facts that he and everyone around him can see; he's not wrong, this whole situation is absolutely fucked up, but that apprehension doesn't apply anymore. He does start to get over it, but it takes a LOT of grinding down to accept the score.
Overall, one of my favorites. Do want more, now now now.