Okay, here is my brief little review. (Possible spoilers ahead, be warned.)
~ Art? 4/5
I don't have much to say here as the world around the characters looks pretty solid, nothing groundbreaking in terms of quality, but just solid all around, thus the 4.
~ Character Models? 3/5
I was teetering between 3 and 4, but, in the end, I couldn't justify a 4. It's not even the big heads or eyes, although they were pretty odd/jarring at first, I got used to them pretty quickly, and I think they have some unique charm.
So why the lower rating? I mean, the characters just look off. I don't have a better way to describe it than that.
Each of the sister's heads looks disproportional; too big at the top (maybe 'cause of the eyes?) and too narrow at the chin, making them look kind of like bugs. Vanessa is pretty normal, though her partner Beth suffers the same syndrome as the sisters, only way worse. Her head looks like an upside-down triangle. And as for Meiko? I'm sorry, but she looks messed up. She not only got the big eye treatment, but her mouth is obnoxiously small making her proportions look even more out of whack than the others.
~ Sound? 0/5
I mean, the game is dead silent, not much to say here.
~ Story? 2/5
In one word? Cliché. It's just an average story, and while there's nothing wrong with that per se, there's nothing really good about it either.
I'll be honest; I feel like the story is a little on the boring side. It's not even the lack of H content; I love a good story-based game. I just feel like there's nothing that ever happens in this world, just same-old-same-old dialogue after dialogue. It gets a little dull after a while.
I was tempted to give the story a 1, but after the divorce scene with the Judge, I had to bump it up to a 2. As a guy, I know how rough it can be for guys in real life when it comes to divorces, so seeing the author make a scene like that was pretty satisfying.
~ Characters? 3/5
I'm leaning toward the negative with the MC. He has his moments where he's alright, but then there are others where I want to smack him with a pipe. Despite me writing this at v0.10.1 he has had next to zero character development, he just waivers over the same stupid crap over and over again, and just when you think he's finally made some progress, he starts having an inner monologue about what he did or what he thought isn't right and we're right back where we started.
And can I just comment on the inner monologuing for a second? The MC never shuts up. It's like, I get it already, enough with the monologuing,
And one more quick note on the MC before I move on - spoilers ahead - there is a scene where the MC sniffs Abby's dildo, yes, her dildo after she'd just finished using it, and it has to be one of the crepiest, most disgusting scenes I've ever seen in a lewd game. My stomach actually turned a little.
Anyways, as for the female characters, I guess we'll start with Abby, and I'll just come out and say it. I don't like her. I get her character is supposed to be the naive, sweet, nice girl or whatever, but the author – as so many do – took it way too far, and she just comes off as intrusive and annoying.
Also, and this isn't really her fault, just how the author wrote it, but I hate how the father turns into a spineless cuck whenever she's around. Around any other character, and he has a respectable level of backbone without coming off as a jerk, but with her, it's "how may I please you, mistress?"
Anyways, I just don't really like her or the interactions she has with the MC. I even started skimming through dialogue that has her in it 'cause I'm just not interested.
I – surprisingly – like Lilith. Usually, I hate her type, the 'bitch for no reason' kind of character. And she is a bitch for no reason. I can understand having daddy issues; from what we are told, she idolized her real father, but even still, the MC hasn't done anything to warrant the shit he takes from her.
Despite that, however, the rest of her character is really well done, and I enjoy seeing her on screen.
Of the three sisters, Becca is my favourite. I mean, what's not to like about her? She's a little vixen, which makes her interactions incredibly fun. And I love that she tries so hard for those around her, helping Lilith with her confidence – even if it makes them argue – and then with the MC, helping Lilith warm up to him. She's just a really sweet girl.
Hiro, Tomo and Meiko are okay. The author went pretty hard on the Asian cliché's, but it's not too big of a deal.
Vanessa and Beth are great, a couple of fun-loving women and a nice addition to the story.
Anyways, those are my thoughts on the game. Hope it helps someone!