I feel like people are being pretty harsh on this. My thought is that, now that it more or less has the production quality of a legit studio mainstream game, people are now rating it on that scale. The reality is that the overwhelming majority of dirty games aren't anywhere near that, so I'm going to rate it on the scale that I would rate its peers:
Presentation: 10/10. Menus are well presented, scene changes are fluid, characters are voiced for all dialogue, UI's generally make sense. Honestly a rarity for this genre outside of VN's
Porn: 8/10. Smooth animations, attractive characters, reasonably varied content, and there's a decent amount of it. Definitely a cut below something like insult order or illusion in the metric of quantity though. Then again, the game isn't done yet! Also worth noting that in those titles, the sex is the gameplay, whereas this has other things going on. The big thing I'd say here is that I'd really like a free camera. I also wish there was more body type variety, but I know that's a steam thing. It's wild to me that a reasonably proportioned athletic adult woman would be flagged by steam if it's presented in this style simply because the fact that her tits aren't massive means she looks too young, but I digress.
Gameplay: 9/10. Yeah, it's a little repetitive and yeah it gets grindy, but I've yet to find an adult game here with genuinely enjoyable gameplay that doesn't get a least a bit grindy. The controls are responsive and fun, so better than most, and there's a fail catch where if you lose three times, it'll just put you past the mission, which I think is a great idea in the genre.
Story/storytelling: 9/10. I see a lot of complaints that the story is kinda inconsequential and that the humor is crude and forced. Maybe I'm just immature and easily entertained, but I was laughing my ass off at most of the jokes, and the story was good enough to keep me interested. In my opinion, it has the right amount of weight. Not so little going on that I don't care, but not so crazy and dark that I feel guilty wanking to the characters (looking at you, Ricca....)
All in all, 5/5 for this genre for sure. A fantastic first attempt to make a game, and I hope it proves profitable for them!
Presentation: 10/10. Menus are well presented, scene changes are fluid, characters are voiced for all dialogue, UI's generally make sense. Honestly a rarity for this genre outside of VN's
Porn: 8/10. Smooth animations, attractive characters, reasonably varied content, and there's a decent amount of it. Definitely a cut below something like insult order or illusion in the metric of quantity though. Then again, the game isn't done yet! Also worth noting that in those titles, the sex is the gameplay, whereas this has other things going on. The big thing I'd say here is that I'd really like a free camera. I also wish there was more body type variety, but I know that's a steam thing. It's wild to me that a reasonably proportioned athletic adult woman would be flagged by steam if it's presented in this style simply because the fact that her tits aren't massive means she looks too young, but I digress.
Gameplay: 9/10. Yeah, it's a little repetitive and yeah it gets grindy, but I've yet to find an adult game here with genuinely enjoyable gameplay that doesn't get a least a bit grindy. The controls are responsive and fun, so better than most, and there's a fail catch where if you lose three times, it'll just put you past the mission, which I think is a great idea in the genre.
Story/storytelling: 9/10. I see a lot of complaints that the story is kinda inconsequential and that the humor is crude and forced. Maybe I'm just immature and easily entertained, but I was laughing my ass off at most of the jokes, and the story was good enough to keep me interested. In my opinion, it has the right amount of weight. Not so little going on that I don't care, but not so crazy and dark that I feel guilty wanking to the characters (looking at you, Ricca....)
All in all, 5/5 for this genre for sure. A fantastic first attempt to make a game, and I hope it proves profitable for them!