This is gonna be a highly controversial review, as the AVN is a cult classic, but this is my opinion and I stand by it.
Pros:
1) The best lighting work in the genre. When the MC closed the curtains on his window and said that he wasn't ready, it was high art.
2) Very good camera work to complement the above.
3) The premise is quite interesting and mysterious. I got really curious what exactly happened to Summer and expected the MC to feel the same.
Cons:
1) The MC. Damn, I hate this guy. When his attempt to save Vic from her accident turned out rather lame, I was okay. I was like, he's going through some stuff, no wonder he lacks resolve. When he took her wallet and left the scene I was like, what the hell are you doing, man? The cops need your info! The victim needs her ID! Then Nami made him do the sensible thing and return the stuff he took. During the visit, he was a complete A-hole, and the only options were: a) to be a moron, b) to be a c***, c) be silent. I chose the last one, despite the walkthrough mod telling me to do otherwise. I purposefully failed my MC. Then, at school, he abandoned his friends for no reason, yet later those people tried to tell him how much they understand him and want to help him. The guy who they barely met. This was where I understood that the whole plot would go pandering to this ba***rd's moody edgelord persona and dropped the game. I mean, yeah, he's going through some shit, but we all have some shit in us, yet the rule is simple: whatever eats you from the inside, you don't let others suffer because of it. The opposite is how monsters are born. And the MC is a burden to poor Nami, I don't understand how she puts up with him. I'm supposed to like the person I'm playing as, and when I want to kick him in the ribs instead, that's a no-go for any game, and especially for an AVN.
2) The awesome premise is underused. As above; I wanted the MC to investigate Summer's disappearance, but he… doesn't do a thing, just moans about it every time. Pretty annoying.
3) Other characters. As mentioned above, these super nice people really want to get into the MC's problems and be his personal free physicians despite knowing him for a day and him never giving them any motivation to do so. Artificial tools for the plotline.
4) LIs. Before I played I'd heard that there were tons of girls, and, true enough, they looked very hot on the screenshots, even though I'm not a fan of such body proportions. As I was contemplating whether to drop the game, I Iooked through some spoilers to find out if I should give the game another chance for the girls. It turned out that half of the current content was given to Bella (who I'd never choose as she is a bully who bullied Nami), and another half was divided between Nami and Mila, with all the other LIs being basically extras. That's just… sad.
5) MC being impotent. Yet another interesting fact I learned from spoilers after playing. Well, I just don't see how the girlfriend's disappearance (many years ago, when they were kids!) made his condition this bad for this many years. Well, it would make sense if someone raped and ate her alive in front of him, but we don't have any info on anything of the sort happening. She just… disappeared. While that's a tragedy, it isn't monstrous enough to damage an individual this much. Something mystical taking place would further stimulate his curiosity to try and find out what really happened. This many years later, I fully expect the MC to have recovered and to be actively researching the reasons behind her disappearance, not letting his angst completely absorb him, doing nothing to find her, and becoming a nuisance to everybody around him.
So, we have an MC whom I hate, a bully with a ton of screentime, an interesting premise that the dev failed to use to keep me involved, side characters who all want to please the MC, and no actual sex to motivate me to soldier through all of it.
2 stars - one for the lighting, and one for the premise.