I like the story and for me that's the bare minimum for me to read a VN. From there, there are a checklist of things that can ruin it, so here's my relatively short but important check list of things that drive this games rating down.
1. Repetitive dialogue in sex scenes. I don't mean the same sex scene is repetitive, I mean every scene is written almost carbon copy to each other with a small bit in the middle that is unique to the current scene. There's all this talk of saliva and shit, like bro, do that occasionally, not every time. You don't need the same 10 sentences in every sex scene, we got it. Your saliva filled her mouth, your swapped saliva, your saliva this your saliva that. Okay well we know the dev's kink at least. That little bit of unique dialogue to the current scene in the middle? That's the only good part, cut the rest out and expand on that. Generic sex talk is for generic porn, you're writing a story so write about the current situation. Make your characters react to each other instead of focusing on the obvious body shit that always happens.
2. I hate when sex scenes can't walk and chew bubblegum at the same time. I don't know why some devs separate dialogue and animations, it's both jarring and reduces how hot the scene is. I don't mind you breaking up the animations with specific shots to show transitions or to pair with detailed dialogue that ties the scene together, but why can't words be on the screen at the same time as the fap material? They're both what makes the situation erotic, taking away half the puzzle is substantially reducing the sexiness of the scene. I had one dev tell me it's because they don't like stuff on screen when they're fapping, well that's fine and well, there's literally a goddamn button to hide the UI if that's your thing. The dev can even highlight that button in the ui if they're so inclined. However, there is no button to include dialogue with animations.
I know I focused on what's wrong instead of what's right, but honestly the list of what's right is pretty long. So, in short, the build up is 5/5 but the payoff is 2/5. Since 95% of the game isn't sex scenes and is fairly well written it's getting a total 4/5 overall.
1. Repetitive dialogue in sex scenes. I don't mean the same sex scene is repetitive, I mean every scene is written almost carbon copy to each other with a small bit in the middle that is unique to the current scene. There's all this talk of saliva and shit, like bro, do that occasionally, not every time. You don't need the same 10 sentences in every sex scene, we got it. Your saliva filled her mouth, your swapped saliva, your saliva this your saliva that. Okay well we know the dev's kink at least. That little bit of unique dialogue to the current scene in the middle? That's the only good part, cut the rest out and expand on that. Generic sex talk is for generic porn, you're writing a story so write about the current situation. Make your characters react to each other instead of focusing on the obvious body shit that always happens.
2. I hate when sex scenes can't walk and chew bubblegum at the same time. I don't know why some devs separate dialogue and animations, it's both jarring and reduces how hot the scene is. I don't mind you breaking up the animations with specific shots to show transitions or to pair with detailed dialogue that ties the scene together, but why can't words be on the screen at the same time as the fap material? They're both what makes the situation erotic, taking away half the puzzle is substantially reducing the sexiness of the scene. I had one dev tell me it's because they don't like stuff on screen when they're fapping, well that's fine and well, there's literally a goddamn button to hide the UI if that's your thing. The dev can even highlight that button in the ui if they're so inclined. However, there is no button to include dialogue with animations.
I know I focused on what's wrong instead of what's right, but honestly the list of what's right is pretty long. So, in short, the build up is 5/5 but the payoff is 2/5. Since 95% of the game isn't sex scenes and is fairly well written it's getting a total 4/5 overall.