Reviewed on 2025/03/07 - Version 1.0 (Chapter 13)
Notes:
Adult:
While this AVN has many lewd scenes, they're mostly all the same. Scenes in a bed can look very similar, as do scenes in the shower.
The lewds are also very vanilla; handjobs, blowjobs, cunnilingus, vaginal penetration. There's one MFF threesome and one deflowering (even though two LI had their first time with Rob). At least one scene features anal, and some feature some kind of kinky roleplay.
These scenes are repetitive because they all follow the same format:
Visual:
Models: "The List" has a wide variety of models with different body types. A lot of attention was paid to scars, wounds, dirt and grime, and is something this AVN shines at.
Posing: Posing is generally fine, but doesn't get a chance to shine due to the cinematography. Models are often posed with weird expressions. For instance; everyone sticks their index finger in the air whenever they're talking. I don't know anyone in real life who does this, unless in school when asking permission, or as a gesture when someone has to wait or be careful.
Renders: Environments are generally fine, though some locations seem out of place. The biggest issue with renders is their lighting. Indoor locations are very bright, and I'd like to suggest that the dev lowers the amount of blue (and some green) to make these lights more natural.
Cinematography: This is the biggest visual issue for me. Conversations usually happen between a closeup of two people, each appearing with their lines. In other places, the cause and effect isn't shown. For instance, in a trap-filled location, we read a "*click*" of Rob triggering a trap, but get no visual indication of what he triggered or how. Together with the actual trap (barrels falling from the ceiling), this makes it difficult for players to get immersed with what's happening. The barrels literally come out of nowhere.
My suggestion here is to use more wide shots. When two people are talking, show them both on the render, and adjust their body language, gestures and mouth based on their lines.
Novel:
While, on paper, this story has everything it needs, I think it lacks soul.
It has challenges, danger, a capable antagonist, an interesting setting, and characters with tons of potential... But all of this potential is used and combined in the wrong ways.
Rob, our MC, almost gets killed when an assassin kills his family. He lands in a coma for 6 months and wakes up with Alexis next to him. She has taken an interest in him because of Rob's parents once saving her.
Alexis takes him in, and (unless the player opt-out and gets a game-over) starts training him to work for her. She entices Madison (a friend of hers) to sleep with him to "prepare him" for her (yuck). A bit later, without real build-up, Rob informs us that he's deeply in love with Alexis, and Madison, and Kelly, and ...
And this is what's wrong with the story in general. We are told so many things, but it often lacks build-up, context, or consequences.
LI are quick to proposition Rob, and Rob will immediately consider them his girlfriends. He'll suddenly say that he loves Madison and Kelly, but all we've seen them do was fuck. How can I believe that he's madly in love with all of these women, when I'd barely consider them FWB?
A few LI have very interesting backstories. Diamonds/Ellie dealt with sexual assault, and Sylvia lived in the streets for three years. Sadly, the same symptom appears here. We're told their backstories, but it doesn't play any part in the story. Ellie propositions the MC immediately after discussing her sexual assault, and Sylvia apparently never had anything bad happen to her while living on the street between the ages of 15 and 18, we're even shown her virginal blood to prove this. Even better, Sylvia immediately becomes an expert in computers, surveillance, and even learned how to drive in a few short days. Why not give this surveillance job to one of the many other LI, and make her the street-smart one?
Meanwhile, a voice in Rob's head is telling him what to do and how to feel. It's not compelling, nor interesting... The player doesn't get the opportunity to get emotionally invested, which makes the lewd scenes even more bland and unearned than they already are, and undermines the few dramatic moments the story offers.
I felt more sadness when saying goodbye to BB and SB than when a main character was killed. BB and SB are great characters with an over-the-top personality and undying loyalty toward TKA. They're great in small doses, and that's precisely what we got. Though, we arguably spent more time with them than some LI. The only person in the "harem" with an over-the-top personality is Kelly, but for all the wrong reasons. She's just the sex-craving girl who has to make everything about herself.
About the Harem; I'm convinced that the only reason why some LI are mandatory is to save the dev on work. With two exceptions, there is no reason why Rob had to be intimate with any of them. And these two are, in my opinion, the worst characters this story has to offer (Kelly & Madison). But giving the player an actual choice would mean that a few more renders need to be made, and that scenes have to be written to work with an LI as a lover or a friend.
Notes:
- The MC isn't renamable.
- There is no gallery.
- There are no music, sound effects or ambient sounds.
- This game is story-first. If you prefer titillating/horny games, this one isn't for you.
- This is a story about "the chosen one". He's being guided to fulfil his destiny, and has little agency because of that.
- Not all LI are optional. Don't like one of the mandatory ones? Too bad.
- "The List" is not a real harem game. There isn't much romance or relationship-building besides with the main LI. Most girls disappear for most of the game, with only 2/3 mandatory LI having scenes in later chapters.
Adult:
While this AVN has many lewd scenes, they're mostly all the same. Scenes in a bed can look very similar, as do scenes in the shower.
The lewds are also very vanilla; handjobs, blowjobs, cunnilingus, vaginal penetration. There's one MFF threesome and one deflowering (even though two LI had their first time with Rob). At least one scene features anal, and some feature some kind of kinky roleplay.
These scenes are repetitive because they all follow the same format:
- LI: Rob, you DTF?
- Rob: Always!
- They perform some oral on each other
- Penetration happens
- Rob is shown going full bore
- Cumshot is shown, usually with a choice, unless Rob has to cum inside for plot reasons.
Visual:
Models: "The List" has a wide variety of models with different body types. A lot of attention was paid to scars, wounds, dirt and grime, and is something this AVN shines at.
Posing: Posing is generally fine, but doesn't get a chance to shine due to the cinematography. Models are often posed with weird expressions. For instance; everyone sticks their index finger in the air whenever they're talking. I don't know anyone in real life who does this, unless in school when asking permission, or as a gesture when someone has to wait or be careful.
Renders: Environments are generally fine, though some locations seem out of place. The biggest issue with renders is their lighting. Indoor locations are very bright, and I'd like to suggest that the dev lowers the amount of blue (and some green) to make these lights more natural.
Cinematography: This is the biggest visual issue for me. Conversations usually happen between a closeup of two people, each appearing with their lines. In other places, the cause and effect isn't shown. For instance, in a trap-filled location, we read a "*click*" of Rob triggering a trap, but get no visual indication of what he triggered or how. Together with the actual trap (barrels falling from the ceiling), this makes it difficult for players to get immersed with what's happening. The barrels literally come out of nowhere.
My suggestion here is to use more wide shots. When two people are talking, show them both on the render, and adjust their body language, gestures and mouth based on their lines.
Novel:
While, on paper, this story has everything it needs, I think it lacks soul.
It has challenges, danger, a capable antagonist, an interesting setting, and characters with tons of potential... But all of this potential is used and combined in the wrong ways.
Rob, our MC, almost gets killed when an assassin kills his family. He lands in a coma for 6 months and wakes up with Alexis next to him. She has taken an interest in him because of Rob's parents once saving her.
Alexis takes him in, and (unless the player opt-out and gets a game-over) starts training him to work for her. She entices Madison (a friend of hers) to sleep with him to "prepare him" for her (yuck). A bit later, without real build-up, Rob informs us that he's deeply in love with Alexis, and Madison, and Kelly, and ...
And this is what's wrong with the story in general. We are told so many things, but it often lacks build-up, context, or consequences.
LI are quick to proposition Rob, and Rob will immediately consider them his girlfriends. He'll suddenly say that he loves Madison and Kelly, but all we've seen them do was fuck. How can I believe that he's madly in love with all of these women, when I'd barely consider them FWB?
A few LI have very interesting backstories. Diamonds/Ellie dealt with sexual assault, and Sylvia lived in the streets for three years. Sadly, the same symptom appears here. We're told their backstories, but it doesn't play any part in the story. Ellie propositions the MC immediately after discussing her sexual assault, and Sylvia apparently never had anything bad happen to her while living on the street between the ages of 15 and 18, we're even shown her virginal blood to prove this. Even better, Sylvia immediately becomes an expert in computers, surveillance, and even learned how to drive in a few short days. Why not give this surveillance job to one of the many other LI, and make her the street-smart one?
Meanwhile, a voice in Rob's head is telling him what to do and how to feel. It's not compelling, nor interesting... The player doesn't get the opportunity to get emotionally invested, which makes the lewd scenes even more bland and unearned than they already are, and undermines the few dramatic moments the story offers.
I felt more sadness when saying goodbye to BB and SB than when a main character was killed. BB and SB are great characters with an over-the-top personality and undying loyalty toward TKA. They're great in small doses, and that's precisely what we got. Though, we arguably spent more time with them than some LI. The only person in the "harem" with an over-the-top personality is Kelly, but for all the wrong reasons. She's just the sex-craving girl who has to make everything about herself.
About the Harem; I'm convinced that the only reason why some LI are mandatory is to save the dev on work. With two exceptions, there is no reason why Rob had to be intimate with any of them. And these two are, in my opinion, the worst characters this story has to offer (Kelly & Madison). But giving the player an actual choice would mean that a few more renders need to be made, and that scenes have to be written to work with an LI as a lover or a friend.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.