Honestly, this is pretty fantastic.
There were a few "first-time" HS2 games this year that people were touting as amazing; that I thought were pretty damn mediocre.
This is way above them in the writing department. There's an interesting, coherent story here, a wide-range of characters, all dealing with something that sets them apart as interesting.
My only negative about the writing is a taste thing. I don't like in depth explanations of magic or imagined-science. I like to get the basic idea, and then to move the fuck on. This AVN goes to town on the intricate details, and that's going to be great for you autists and engineers out there, but for me, it's pretty boring and brings the pace to a stutter.
Having said that, I was fully immersed at all other times, and constantly interested in what might happen next. The same can't be said of other, highly-praised, titles that manage to look good-to-great, but read like a first-grader's "learn-to-read" book.
An objective negative is that it is well below standard for HS2 visuals. I assume this is the fault of the dev not having a decent GPU because they show some decent lighting in some scenes where things aren't too taxing, but others just look like they didn't bother with anything except the shitty cam light for real time rendering in HS2.
Some subjective drawnbacks:
I don't really like urban fantasy, so I'm not into the genre. However this is also a subjective plus because the fact that it has me invested despite being a genre I dislike is an incredibly strong argument for its quality.
The girls... Not my type. Bael has the body, but, for some reason, has an old lady's face. Cerys has comically large breasts that I really hate looking at. Same with most of the other girls. I don't like tits so big that the person would have to have a birth defect to possess them. Elephantitis of the mammaries. Some of the faces are ugly too - the developer's character creation is not my speed at all.
However, they all have interesting personalities, and that holds greater overall weight for me.
You're also given a lot of information in this first chapter. It's unavoidable with such complicated lore, but I can't help but wonder if the developer could have offloaded some of it to episodes 2 and 3 . It's going to be impossible to remember some of the things revealed here because it was so dense.
Also, a lot of it is "told" through conversation, rather than dramatised through conflict, scene, and action. Obviously the latter requires many more renders, but might take this to the next level; and I think the developer is capable enough.
In a sea of shit where people write in English, despite being completely incapable of forming simple sentences without the help of ChatGPT - this AVN has the elusive quality factor when it comes to story and writing.
If they can make the small jump higher, this is going to be really special...
... And hopefully get a better PC so they can render images of a quality that the story deserves.