What size penis do you prefer for your main character?

[Fatalmasterpiece]

Okay, after much debate, let's get some actual data on the ever burning question!
When it comes to watching a porn scene or for your own main character in a game, how big should their member be?
Or do you not really care?

 

[fitgirlbestgirl]

In general I abhor the comically large dicks a lot of games use. I'm fine with a MC who has a big dick, even a huge one, just don't make it comically retarded. But it also depends what kind of game it is and what kind of MC you're playing. The disconnect between being a 16 year old metrosexual twink who wants to fuck his mommy but also has a horse cock never worked for me. Then you have stuff like femdom or cuckolding games, where having a big dick is actually kind of a negative. It all depends.

 

[Pretentious Goblin]

Most types of games - don't care outside of extremes (and many games go with extremely large).
NTR - cuckold should have smaller one, though focusing mainly on that is bad writing.

 

[Meaning Less]

Depends on the pussy size also imo.

I find it a bit silly when they do "orc cock" on a loli, there is only so much I can suspend my disbelief, after a point it just becomes silly.

 

[Jofur]

I definitely prefer them large overall since I find they work better visually. More surface area to manipulate in animations and poses and all that. Especially in still images where showing actions require a fair amount of exaggeration to feel like the images have momentum.

 

[PochitaTheChainsaw]

planet buster

 

[Yngling]

Then you have stuff like femdom or cuckolding games, where having a big dick is actually kind of a negative. It all depends.

NTR - cuckold should have smaller one, though focusing mainly on that is bad writing.

Actually I think it would be funny to reverse this trope.

For example: an extremely wealthy and powerful business man with a small dick but an aggressive and dominating mentality to compensate. Kind of a Napoleon complex. Bonus points if he's black.

For the poll, I voted "big". Huge tends to be ridiculous, small just makes it harder to see what's going on.

 

[freedom.call]

I voted big. I only notice if it's tiny or massive tbh, don't like that.

 

[zenshiny]

I say it doesn't really matter that much. But also, I guess it depends. If the game has a more cartoony style, ridiculously huge schlongs aren't out of place. If the art is attempting to be more realistic, then dial it back.

 

[RibesNigrum]

When it is inserted, it is lost. XD

But if the team is generous enough to create an x ray scene, the size I prefer is the one where mc can pound the womb. As it is a cartoony expression, kinda hard to use real scale.

 

[SpoiledPrince]

Where is the option for "normal, 15 to 20 cm"?

 

[baneini]

I don't like the idea of vagina walls/anus rupturing into a bloody mess and the girl perishing from sex in agony so I kinda prefer regular human sizes.

 

[fidless]

Where is the option for "normal, 15 to 20 cm"?

That's normal for you?
Aqua is not impressed.

 

[Loganfin]

I always, always prefer a porn star sized cock to one that's comically large. Ones that defy reality can detract from the game, and ones that are too small are a huge turnoff for me too. While I don't typically think of inserting myself into a game, playing as a character who's cock is a lot smaller than my own IRL is off putting. I've quit a few games in recent months over that issue.

So, the 7-10 range is ideal, and thick not skinny. The balls are important too, because poorly done ones can be a weird distraction, and I personally love a good creampie finish when you watch the dude's balls as he fills her with cum.

 

[Banality]

can anything shorter than 20 cm be considered as Penis?

 

[Gone405]

I'm cool with pretty much any size really just depends on the game I'm playing. Example NTR average or small. With harem VNs I would say bigger size or average once again. Imo of course.

 

[Hadley]

As Average as possible.

 

[Stalker Seducer]

Okay, after much debate, let's get some actual data on the ever burning question!
When it comes to watching a porn scene or for your own main character in a game, how big should their member be?
Or do you not really care?

Average, too small feels insulting, too big feels stupid and unrealistic.