Don't ask people on a 'pirate' forum where 95%+ of us have never and will never subscribe. Also, very few people even post in the forum (the average is fewer than 2 post per person --- and look how many posts I and the others on in this thread alone have posted -- I have posted enough for about 5,000 who have never posted). We're very opinionated and are wholly not a proper representative sample of the people you are attempting to attract as subscribers. In fact, I have found the "pirates" on this site to be even more needy, demanding, and critical than the average person who has/does/will subscribe.
You should be making the game you have always wanted to play.
You should be making the game which has the content you enjoy.
You should be making the game that no one else is making - because if they did, you wouldn't need to spend hundreds and maybe thousands (and maybe 10s of thousands of hours) futzing over storyline, dialogue, artwork, code, bugfixes, marketing, customer complaints, etc --- all for no more than $100 per month even after three years of work (that's the mean adult game developer on Patreon ... about 3 in 5 make less than $100 per month).
You may get lucky and score big, making $2000 per month (about 1 in 10) or even $4000 per month (1 in 20) after 3 years.
Best of luck