How can you not be a Jenna fan, she's the 2nd best girl in the game!
Which is #1 for you? Katie?
There is probably (definitely) something wrong with me, but I always have a thing for nerdy girls, so Jenna is pretty much at the top for me. I can't decide between Elaine, Debbie, and Bella, for number 2, depends on who is on the screen when I am playing, haha. I am completely suspicious of Bella, however, so it is probably a big mistake to get too close.
Lilly is a total fox, obviously, but her interest in the MC just doesn't seem authentic for some reason to me. It seems a little forced, for some reason I am just not buying it.
Katie is super sweet, quite funny, and she obviously loves and is devoted to the MC, probably more than anyone, and it's great to see her vulnerable side show through occasionally, but her character just doesn't quite grab me as much as some of the others. If Jenna, Elaine, and Debbie weren't so appealing, Katie would be number 1.
Zarah has grown on me a lot with later updates. I think I like her more than Monica these days, although she gets very little screen time.
Monica is great, but more on friendly terms for me.
Jolina is pretty cute, but her character doesn't really grab me much either, compared to most of the others.
Angel is fine. If she had more screen time, I would probably like her more. I don't care about Wanda particularly.
Theresa I can't stand, and I wish she would go away. Even played as a joke here, religious fundamentalists rub me the wrong way, especially as a LI.
The fact that there are so many appealing characters with real personality, so we can all debate our favorites, is really a testament to the dev team's writing. Great job. I can't think of any other games here with this number of great characters, where each has a convincing and unique personality and style.