About animations quantity: In terms of animations, Wild Life has an enormous amount of seggs compared to other games. I'm nearly certain it has as of its recent build more animations than all the games in your list combined. Not sure though but I feel like the number would be pretty close.
About animations quality: The best part about WL is that their animations are excellent across the board with some variations offered on top. The consistency across such a large offering is unique.
About WL gameplay: Have you played earlier versions, for example the UE4 version? WL has the systems and mechanics in place for great gameplay already. Combat is good, there's stealth, and you can fly with Maya which is mesmerizing imo and works without bugs. The flying mechanic is the first thing that stuck with me since the first time I played the game tbh. So yeah, guessing it's a matter of time before quest lines will require you to use those already worked on systems.
Before I delve into your list, I reiterate that I am not invalidating your criticism but Wild Life devs are not lazy. It's just not factual.
Anyways. Dissing on other game devs is not ok and I do not appreciate that I am dragged into having to do this but here goes. Colors from Red to Blue represent bad (red/orange) to good (green) to great (blue). Let's see those "proper" complete games.
1. Seed Of The Dead 2: A 2 year project which is a somewhat nice L4D clone with mediocre amateurish seggs scenes and bad models. Currently sitting at mixed reviews. That studio's project which would be comparable to WL is currently in dev and will take YEARS before seeing the light. Boy they're not ready to be called lazy on a piracy thread.
2. Delta Zone: Nice graphics, atrocious perfomance. Gameplay loop gets boring pretty quickly. Next to zero story. Although I can't be harsh on this one as it's one bro taking the project head on so good luck to him.
3. The Last Barbarian: outdated af compared to WL.
4. Carnal Instinct: first really good suggestion from you thus far in terms of matching with WL. It's an interesting comparison too because CI is focusing on creating the game first befor creating the sex/anim part which may or may not be a mistake. In my opinion, it is a mistake as it's a h game first and foremost and the fact that it is lacking in seggs makes it meh for me. Good eye candy for sure.
5. The Fairy and the Holy Knight: Great game for sure but not comparable with WL for obvious reasons. Small in scale side scroller with limited amount of animations. Overall nice gameplay and customization.
6. House Party: I like this project but it's way too early. Nice models but animations are weaker than WL's and it's small in scale. Who knows if the project won't be abandoned since it's still early in its life cycle.
7. Subverse: nice story in my opinion and great seggs animations but the gameplay sucks and plays like an RPGM or a VN. Professional production thanks to the massive donations. Worth noting that this game is getting a ton of hate over the fact that it did not live up to the expectations of fans and their donations and is thus sitting at mixed scores.
8. Last Hope: aye that's a rare W in the h scene.
9. The Villain Sim: giving it an orange score because it barely has any content and animations. Too limited in my opinion.
10. Captain Hardcore: buggy mess tbh. Good models though.
11. Kinky Fight Club 2: good game. Obviously has smaller content than WL.
12. Stationmaster: buggy mess and broken animations and some mediocre graphics even without bugs but huge potential. Sequel will definitely be amazing.
Shut up, Krillin.
I don't see the scale, content or gameplay in this "game" you keep talking about. You mentioned UE4 version which had a little bit of gameplay but it is not relavant anymore since that version is abandoned at this point. Also, combat was far from good. For example, if I had to choose between shooting mechanics of Seed Of The Dead 2 and WL I'd definitely pick former because its combat is waaay more satisfying and complete DESPITE still being clunky compared to other fps games I've played. The only thing WL has is it has
decent graphics and animations but even that area is heavily contested by other Unreal Engine games which are ALSO in development, such as Home Together and Carnal Instinct. I'm not bringing up performance because porn games including WL tend to be shit in that regard.
You seem to be graphics>gameplay kind of person. Surely you can still recognize the fact that a game needs to be a game first and foremost, right? I mean, if graphics is all you care about there is actual porn, not to mention non-porn indie games that have either comparable or better graphics quality, such as Bright Memory Infinite, SpaceBourne 2 or even BG3(btw these guys created their own engine while staying indie).
but Wild Life devs are not lazy
You simply can't claim to be developing a GAME for 7+ years and STILL not have a GAME despite being supported & funded for years. It is either that or they are scammers milking patreon cows for years. There is nothing in between, pick your poison.
EDIT: House Party can't be abandoned because it is a finished game that still receives bugfixes and dlc's just like any other game. It is not in early access. It is pretty close to end of life instead of "early life cycle". They're probably going to wrap it up after incoming dlc but who knows.