Would you prefer the only 18 year old female sex option be the sister or not?

[hakarlman]

If an adult virtual novel had only one eighteen year old female, would you prefer her to be the main male protagonists sister, where she can be romanced and sexed, or not? The game would allow the main male protagonist to romance their mother.

Feel free to add ideas or scenarios you want to see in game around the theme of the poll question.

 

[Ennoch]

For once in the indie porn game history it would be nice that the "petite innocent pure younger girl" template would befit someone else, even if she would be the only one who is younger than the mc. So many interesting possibilities there, depending on the VN's setup, it doesn't have to be the sister all the time. I kinda miss a Romeo and Juliette story. Where its the antagonist's younger sister we can romance and lewd for example.

 

[desmosome]

I don't know why, but romance incest does nothing for me. If its incest, I want to dominate/MC/hypno/mindbreak them.. Romance in general is too vanilla for me.. Oh.. how far I have fallen.

 

[anne O'nymous]

I kinda miss a Romeo and Juliette story.

Well, personally I would prefer if it could last more than one week and not end with MC death, but else I agree with you.

 

[DarthSeduction]

If an adult virtual novel had only one eighteen year old female, would you prefer her to be the main male protagonists sister, where she can be romanced and sexed, or not? The game would allow the main male protagonist to romance their mother.

Feel free to add ideas or scenarios you want to see in game around the theme of the poll question.

If I'm honest, there are too many mommy/daddy games, and not enough games where the sister feels like she matters. My vote is for sister, but don't do it if you're not really into it. Too many little sisters in games are treated like the training wheels, the easy mode character, even ones I genuinely like, such as Sara from Milfy City, or Mia from View of Family, are the easier character by far. Older sister's will sometimes replace this route by being sexual with you for selfish reasons, but more often end up being another mommy, because all they can see is the little boy and they refuse to see you as a man.

If you do make her a sister, commit to making her a worthwhile thing to pursue. Make the content with her something that people will not only enjoy, but talk about. There's nothing I hate more than a game that promises me a relationship with a sister only for that relationship to be my least favorite in the game. I'm a siscon first, everything else, much of which I am into, comes second

 

[Ennoch]

Noone cares about your sisconning ways, you perv! Mommy always comes first! :relievedface:

But its true, if we are talking about said girl as love interest it is advisable to make it on par with any other love interests. So if mom would be romancable and the girl too, they should be equally satisfying in terms of story, character- and relationship developement. I'd say its quite a challenge though if the Dev is biased. But thats the reason why it is always important to develop a game along his own kinks, at least at first, because that way fake choices are avoidable. Its bad when a Dev advertizes two routes that are supposedly equal and then end up favouring one heavily over the other.

And i definitely agree that make the girl pretty please, interesting! And have a personality that befits a 18 years old.. Oh how i wish to see young adults being.. young adults. Actually i'm into underaged but when we are talking about a 18 yrs. old one who is (i'd assume) starting university this whole 10yrs. old attitude isn't all that appealing i so often see.

A pretty girl at that age will surely have a boyfriend too. Or girlfriend. So all this "i never had a boyfriend" thing is.. meh. I'm pretty much on the same page as the vile sisconner above that this doesn't have to be supereasy with the girl, whether she is a sis or not. Especially not in case of a main love interest. Of course its all depends on the setup. In a harem game, things shouldn't focus on a single girl too much. But in a game that has only two love interest, well, those should be a tad bit more interesting, intriguing and hard to get than the rest. But this can happen in different ways.

Sex for example can happen early on. A relationship doesn't have to develop in a linear fashion. Girl can change her mind. Catch MC with someone else and absolution can come at a price or only after quite a while. It all depends whether you wish to do a light hearted rompy story or something with more shades of grey.

 

[GuyFreely]

As others have said, incest is sort of being done to death right now. If you make it the sister, try to take a new approach to it. Look at little sisters from other games and try to do something else.

I would say if you aren't going to make her the little sister, but the little sister still exists, one way would be to make it the little sister's friend. People often develop crushes on the older siblings of their friends, it adds more believably to the character. You can have a lot of the same attributes of a sister character, but without the incest. If she's your sister's best friend, she can still be around a lot and even sleep over. You can have some of the same scenarios: late night visits, shower scenes, walking around in her underwear/bikini, etc. Just a thought.

If the little sister only exists if she's a romance option, then you'll have to find another way to introduce this character. I don't know the age of the MC or the situation. So random scenarios involving younger women:
She works somewhere you frequent. She frequents where you work. She works where you work. (noticing a pattern)
She's a nearby neighbor (girl next door?).
A relative of another major character.
Then you have teacher/tutor/mentor roles.
Then more involved introductions like saving her from a mugging or something.

 

[gunderson]

Damn straight I would like one of the love interests in any porn game to be the protagonist's sister. Incest is awesome. Can't have too many incest games.

 

[おい！]

How about a Sister?

 

[DarthSeduction]

How about a Sister?

Not quite the taboo I'm looking for, but definitely one that's fun. Too bad the nuns in western games are usually already sluts.

 

[zerozip0]

I personally would prefer them not to be related by blood.

 

[hakarlman]

The votes are split right down the middle. Is there a clever way to tackle this problem to satisfy both parties?

 

[GuyFreely]

The votes are split right down the middle. Is there a clever way to tackle this problem to satisfy both parties?

First thing you need to know is that you can't please everyone. Whatever you do some people will like it and some won't, so don't worry about it. If you personally have a preference, then do it that way.

If you want an answer, you could do a scenario where she's your sister, but not your sister. Like a step-sister or adopted or some slight variation. I would still suggest just doing whatever interests you more.

 

[Milvidi]

Not really? Not because I don't like that role. In fact, if your game have that route, it will probably be the first one that I pursue. However, the sister role is fairly restricting, and has been done to dead.

Still, there's chance for something really good to come out of it, can't know for sure until we see the game itself. So if you enjoy it, then just do it. Please yourself first. If the content is good then you'll have an audience.

 

[Edgame]

IMO, speaking of fantasy, or just plain imagination, idk why we can't protrait younger girls. 18 or 21 it's just US standards, though in the rest of the world consent comes as far as 12yo in some areas, i'm not saying that i'm an child abuser or anything like that, ffs, but just for the sake of FANTASY, we should be allowed to use younger ages for girls in the games. In the end it's just a game, not hurting anyone, and it's arousing for a certain group of people. Maybe i'm wrong, but this is in my head atm.
EDIT: fuck, last post was made in 2018, just saw it ... fuck ...

 

[Hadley]

IMO, speaking of fantasy, or just plain imagination, idk why we can't protrait younger girls. 18 or 21 it's just US standards, though in the rest of the world consent comes as far as 12yo in some areas, i'm not saying that i'm an child abuser or anything like that, ffs, but just for the sake of FANTASY, we should be allowed to use younger ages for girls in the games. In the end it's just a game, not hurting anyone, and it's arousing for a certain group of people. Maybe i'm wrong, but this is in my head atm.
EDIT: fuck, last post was made in 2018, just saw it ... fuck ...

The 18 is just a number. Most are not meant to be 18. And since they are not telling you in every sentence "Hey, my Name is XY and I'm 18" you can just think of them as younger.

In some Games you can set the Ages yourself which helps with Immersion.

 

[215303j]

IMO, speaking of fantasy, or just plain imagination, idk why we can't protrait younger girls. 18 or 21 it's just US standards, though in the rest of the world consent comes as far as 12yo in some areas

Problem with that would be that although a game might be legal in the jurisdiction of the creator, but not in the jurisdiction of the player. It's pretty complicated legally, so better to stick to an age that's universally acceptable.

And like Hadley said, it's not like you are reminded every second sentence...

 

[vir_cotto]

If you are trying to make a romance game, you should avoid incest.
If you are trying to make fuckfest, yeah, go with incest.

As someone who likes romance, I can tell you that incest romance is something I really don't care about and I think most romance fans think the same.

 

[Hadley]

If you are trying to make a romance game, you should avoid incest.
If you are trying to make fuckfest, yeah, go with incest.

As someone who likes romance, I can tell you that incest romance is something I really don't care about and I think most romance fans think the same.

I think Romance is the best if its with someone who you know for a very long time. Best if like mother or father died and the MC had become the fatherfigure of his sister and she is kinda clingy.

Could be a Childhood-Friend too, but little Sister always works. It adds some spice into it.

 

[freedom.call]

I'd like more games where women are chasing the protag, I'm sure there are countless scenarios that could keep that interesting for a few updates.

Incest romance just doesn't seem feasible to me, unless they set up house on the moon. The only upside to step, adopted, whatever scenario is you have easy access to the women. Doesn't do anything for me tbh, prefer to go outside the family in those cases.