WVM has a lot of heart -- and there are many positives. Earlier in its development, the game seemed fresh and brimming with potential, but it has lost its way more recently as the character set expanded and the story got diluted. It's good but not one of the top games in the genre.
The Good
The Not-So-Good
The Good
- Huge diversity of girls with different personalities, body types and overall looks
- Main characters (including MC) are nice and easy to root for
- Well-done renders and environments -- some I haven't seen in any games before
- The sports emphasis makes the basic premise ("guy goes off to college") feel differentiated and more enjoyable
- Prior to the recent delay, updates were provided quickly and regularly
- OK animations
The Not-So-Good
- The story has made less and less sense over time. The MC is being dragged into diluted conversation after diluted conversation with an increasingly large cast of characters that is hard to keep track of
- The story began (generally) grounded in realism but has devolved into messy threads that are mostly implausible
- The story re-uses the same angles, framing and character expressions over and over -- although there are no "grind" elements, the conversations feel like a grind
- The girls are all good looking but few are ... sexy. There is little seduction or intrigue -- the H-scenes are almost rote in how predictably they play out.