VN - Ren'Py - 4 Kingdoms Supremacy [v0.32] [Piggy Nose Games]

Fantasy game about the long lost hero going to reclaim his birthright and unite the kingdom in the face of an ancient evil. Not the most original premise but it's the implementation that counts.
So what is there?
The good:
- Better graphics and animations than the other game
- No grind - this is a strict VN with a few choices. No open world
- Cleaner english - very few typos and grammar error. The storytelling is clean
The bad:
- Sex scene execution is still hit or miss. Some have proper set-up but others do not which makes the lack of communication during the scenes even more apparent. 2 of the girls already took it up the ass without much reaction
- Story feels a bit rushed. We sprint through the hero's journey and the MC goes from prison to being knighted and saving a minotaur village all in 2 days. You don't get to be attached or invested in anything happening or even the girls that much because there is not enough normal human interaction.

All in all a good first 2 chapters - better definitely than how Brooks started but still has some of that game's issues.
P.S: where are the gapes? The aftermath of a good fuck needs to be witnessed!

Just outstanding. Unlike most other games /stories, this one captured me from first moment. Looking so much forward.

Ofc, there might be flaws and weak points, but this doesnt bother me as long as it draws me in, enjoys me and I have lot of fun. Graphics are to my liking, writing as well, and with all other points one could list, nothing disturbed my fantastic experience.

Has potential for way more with good models, a fantasy/medieval setting, potential harem, potential two moms, and the classic hero story. Unfortunately there is bad lighting, the English needs more work, and mini-games need to be a little more engaging. Good thing is that most of the problems can be resolved. Luckily most of the problem can be resolved in the future.

I played version 0.32.

The art is mediocre. In an otherwise good game, it would be good enough for me. But this game is not good. The writing is actually very bad. And that includes the language itself (just very basic english), as well as the story. Story is really going forward way to fast, from zero to hero with half a day of training.

There is potential, but the things happening in 0.32 need actually 3-10x more room to be good.

REVIEW VERSION: v0.30
SUMMARY: Ok, but not worth 4 stars IMO

PROS:

1. Models are attractive, but (see cons)
2. Setting is medieval fantasy which is usually a good way to go
3. Story is not complete drivel but nothing earth shattering
4. Written and structured fairly OK, not best though.
5. Pacing is fine, has a decent build up and at least you get some lewd action.

CONS:

1. Small updates with no real interesting content, what is there is not really good, the general quality is mediocre at best;
   • Models are attractive but quality is so low, its like playing a game from the 90s. The lighting is poor so you kinda more looking at the idea of lewd more than actually getting good quality of it. Now sure you can just opt for watching porn, but still, im of the mind if you gonna make a adult game with porn then do it properly or dont bother, as with anything in life IMO.
   • Story is OK, but really, its just cliches on top of cliches and the "quests" e.g., saving blacksmith from Minotaur City, the puzzles are BS, the action is BS, the stakes are supposed to be high but its all really bland and dull. Don't get me wrong, i believe its hard work to build a game let alone a good one, but this game feels like its a few years old when its a more recent release.
   • Per above-mentioned point, more detail is needed, the ideas are fine, its the details of how its done and how the events take place. e.g.,
     Spoiler: Example

     You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
     Hopefully you see where I am going with this...
2. Animations are actually not bad, but that is if you compare and take into account the poor quality renders. On that level its not bad, but its really at best average.
3. Story writing is as I said, not great, filled with cliches and feels like a fantasy movie from 80s or even before. Those were great back then, but now...the articulation and general writing quality is sub optimal and does not really read and by implication feel/convey the scene, atmosphere and stakes you would expect.
4. As far as lewd goes, this game almost seems a bit more on the old school traditional fantasy story filled with cliches. So don't expect any kinky lewds, there simply are none and the MC is limited to anal sex only, which is actually weird since thats less normal and more kink...go figure???

TLDR: The game lacks quality and effort is lacking in every department, I am not saying the story is bad, but I would say that it needs more refinement (MUCH MORE) Renders are grainy and dull, if any game required a remaster its this one.

I am not sure why this game is rated so high, its not bad but not nearly to the quality that is out there. All in all its OK at best but not nearly good enough to give 4 starts lets alone 5, thats for people who don't know how to critique and have low standards.

It's a decent game. Renders are good it's not in par with renders of many games that are releasing now but it's okay. I love this kind of settings and story seems good. But it's earlier to say now. There is only Little content for now. I remember playing Dev's other game when it's released first but I didn't like it even though I loves western settings. It's renders poor seems like it got a revamp so gonna try it later.

Reason for 3 star there is only Little content now


This one's good if you like Fantasy setting games with wars. Only Little content for now. Will wait for this keep up the good work dev.

Tis shit good, the plot is kinda funny and the prologue looks hasted. With the meditation scene I was just "Eeh?" like what was I watching and reading. Would have been funny if the protag gets a ghost of a knight who follows him around and acts like some sort of counter to the woman in purple.

Great game, this medieval feel enchants me. It's still too early to claim victory, but if it continues on this same path, it has everything it needs to be one of the best in the genre!! The story encourages you to continue, I just missed everything being told less quickly. The images are beautiful, but there is always room for improvement.