RPGM - A Struggle with Sin [v0.6.0.5d] [Chyos]

Pro:
-Tons of content, took me 20 hours to go through everything using the walkthrough.
-Great writing, there is noticeable attention to detail with characters reacting depending on order of quests done, party members with you, corruption levels, etc.. all in all plenty of variation to keep you saving and loading to see the different branches
-Gameplay has depth with plenty of room for further development/expansion. Also comes with a cheat mode if you don't care for gameplay.
-Large variety of girls with distinct personalities.
Cons:
-Saving can take as much as 15 seconds versus the near instant of most other RPGM games.
-Renders could be better, they can feel low-res lacking anti-aliasing.
-Some characters need reworks or at least some touch-ups.: Lydia is plain ugly, Penny could is use a nose job. And the MILFs (outside of Katherine) are closer to GILFs.
-Due to its branching nature, this is hard (at least without frequest save scumming and spending significant time replaying sections) to do guideless especially when aiming for optimal outcomes.
-Lacks a skip button for conversations

4 stars seems fair and overall definitely worth the time despite it's faults. Definitely in my Top 5 RPGM (and will probably be in yours as well). The only reason it's not a 5 is due to render quality (which is a downgrade when coming from Peasant Quest, and other Ren'Py titles).

This is definitely a porn game, and it is filled to the brim with fucking. How much fucking, how far that fucking goes, how you get to it, and the types of fucking, are all up to the player, which is among the many reasons I love this game.

Every choice you make has an impact. You can do what every game protagonist does and play a complete douchebag, or a manwhore with a heart of gold. You could also play anything in between, based on your preference.


The gameplay is secondary to the epic story that the player can participate in through their choices, but it, too, is implemented well enough to say that this is the best porn RPG I have ever played.

It'll make you think at certain points, but if you're feeling sluggish, it's damn near impossible to miss with the walkthrough.

Chyos pours their heart and soul into this game, and it shows. If you want fantastic story and gameplay with your porn, try this game, it will not disappoint you.

This one has excellent content, the flow makes it difficult to see all the Time sensitive events without cheating (Mia). In the current version, neither the in game guide or the provided walkthrough provide enough information fulfill several of the quests or to pick the order the quests need to be performed in after the first few.

All that said, the game has excellent content and a decent storyline.

Edited II. Adjusted to 3 stars due to several new issues encountered.

Like the rpg system in this one the best. Very intuitive and the grind is rewarding unlike many other similar rpgs out there. Lots of options and the branching story is simple yet engaging. Probably one of the few that actually does the ntr and vanilla routes correctly.

Top story. Top amount of content. Top everything.
Its just a superb game. To see all content so far (0.4.4.0a) you need, if you play without cheats, around 30+ hours.

The only bad thing about the game are the animations and character designs. They could be better.

A surprisingly good life simulator with well written characters, world, and plot. You start off as an effectively homeless rookie hunter just trying to earn a place to sleep and a meal to eat. But after a few hours, I started dealing with bandits who tried to kidnap the MC's friend's Mom, helping the THICC wood cutter reconnect with her heritage, and plowing the field of a very lonely woman (while also working my way into her heart). I ended up as invested in these women's stories as I was in getting in bed with them.

My only complaint is that it's a bit of a grind to your first proper make out session with any of the romanceable woman. Except with around a dozen love interests, a corruption mechanic, both a love and NTR route for many of the women, and constantly expanding arcs for plot and characters, the wait was often worth it. If you need to speed through the game then there's already a cheat book and very helpful walk-through.

Wow, what a great game! I've must've played nearly 50 hours already.
Engaging story, decent animations, great characters, many ways to interact with and corrupt those characters... what else could you ask for?.

A Struggle with Sin is without a doubt one of the best h-games I've had the luck to play.

Visuals are not the best, but the gameplay, story, dialogues are one of my favourites in this genre.

The walktrough is a must have thing, since some quests are not that straightforward. Or at least not for me.
The walktrough is well written, and easy to use.

There are in-game cheats so you don't have to grind, or spend a lot of time to complete some quests if you only want to experience the story.

So far with its current content it looks promising. Hope dev.team keeps going this direction their going.
I cant really add anything more than just my thanks and good luck wishes.
As far as gameplay itself, well it has some intresting events based on your choices and option preferences. Dont wana spoil something just play it as far as you can get and thats it.

1/5 - DNF; Didn't get me off

Gameplay is mostly sandbox style managing your stats and grinding points with girls. The grind doesn't feel that bad because you are always getting a little different dialogue to grind. Occasionally you get quests to go on. Combat is simple and easy.
Porn scenes consist of a few renders and an animation or two. The renders are bad, the animations are hideous. They look like something out of Fallout 1 (not exaggerating). Descriptions are fine, but don't make up for it. The worst part here is how long it takes to start getting scenes - I played for 3 hours and only got the two scenes from the prologue.

Even if you're the type of player who enjoys these sandbox grinding games, I'm sure you can find one where the graphics aren't from the last century.


+ What story there is isn't bad. Same goes for the writing.

Really nice game. It has lots of action and game to it, it is not just a good porn game but it is also a good game. Lots of different characters to play with and full of interesting side stories. I did not experience many bugs and there is a bit of grinding involved, but it is ultimately a fun experience

Excellent Game, so much fun to play and can't stop playing it. Can wait to See more interesting Story in the Future. And by the way gonna love the Story, it also have a wonderful adventure.

Game Version: v0.4.2.0b

I played the game for about 30 hours. The game includes grinding but not much. Has a good story, excellent sex scenes, well written female characters and good romance. NTR can be avoided (I think one of the important points). There is not much innovation in combat, but I liked the mechanics very much. And if you ask me, I would expect more kinks in this kind of game. but I think it will come in the future. To sum it up, it's a great game.

Update, Game Version: v0.5.9.5

After almost three and a half years, I decided to play this wonderful game again. I can say that it was definitely worth the wait. There is so much newly added content that I have been playing the game for over a month now. I played for about 75 hours, doing everything without resorting to any cheats or shortcuts. And I enjoyed every minute of it. This game... its like one of the main stones of 3D RPGM games. I don't know what to say. A beautiful and progressive story, gorgeous and sexy characters, hot animated sex scenes, different gameplay elements... I'm literally lost in the game. I think I will have to be patient for at least 2 more years to play this amazing game again with the same pleasure and different content. Because at this rate, it doesn't look like the game will be completed anytime soon.

Anyways, must play.

Excelent RPG adventure game like actual game where you can play, not like those other game like watching a movie ,

NPC image Has improve in newer version lot still need to improve .

has some interesting super natural story , and a potential beautiful world looking forward to it .

A lot of dedication goes into this game and it shows. Its so fking good.
This is an actual RPG with a lot of adult content. Its also very long, we are talking about 40+ hours of gameplay.

- The story is well put together
The overall plot of the game is actually good. It makes sense.
At the start of the game, you will get the feeling that this will be a simple story, but it evolves into an adventure with a lot of twists.

- The female characters are the heart of this game
An amazing cast of female characters. Most of the them are busty with big ass and tits <3 I love it
My favourite ones have to be Tia and Kate, just for their amazing romance moments.
Not that the rest dont have theirs lol. The childhood friend is a swetheart too.
But If im being honest the best female characters are for sure the MILFs (the moms and the wives). All of them are written so well, its just something else. They have also very nice romance moments but their attitudes, perverted moment and overall character is just something else. Of this milf cast my favourites are the mayoers wive, the child hood friends mom and Tia's mom.

- The romance in this game is god tier
This is without a doubt the best part of the game in my opinion.
Its not just love talk, its straight up hand golding, hugs, cuddles, kisses etc...
Incredible sweet moments with the love interests. It makes the relationships deeper and meaningful.
The relationship progression is done so well too. Some of the love interest can be rather cold or rude, or uninterested. But they can get very affectionate and sweet <3
BUT some of the characters are not developed all that much... you will notice this as you play that some of the female characters simply have way more content than the rest, plus their relationship progress much better than some others.
This is sadly due to patreon polls the dev does. We can only hope he develops them all eventually.
Not gonna give a name, but there is a love interest that can potentially be Best Waifu if she actually got content updates and we had more progression with her IMO.

- The sex scenes are very good
Scenes are pretty darn good. Renders are good. The animations are mostly amazing.
We get control in some of the scenes, like changes view points , camera angles, poses etc...
But overall , we get some pretty good angles during the poses. But in my opinion, we need more focus on the girls butts. But we also get some nice angles during doggy style <3
The blowjob scenes are super good, its mostly with good side angles where we clearly see the girl taking it and her tits and/or ass is in the frame <3
Animations are smooth and clean for the most part.
BUT there are some scenes that are very laggy and stutter. Its a hit or miss.

I suggest you make saves before each scene, because some of them are not repeatable and only happen 1 time. But most of the sex scenes can be repeated whenever you want

- The NTR is completely avoidable/preventable
The NTR in the game is avoidable. It does not happen in the background.
It can be turned off at the start of the game, so we do not have to worry about it all.
The NTR in the game is mostly if we fail objectives or lose fights.
I suggest turning the NTR off at the start because the game can be difficult and IMO not worth the risk.
But even if you do not turn it off, it will not happen in the background, its more of a consequence of your failure type of situation.
And do NOT worry, MC is pretty much doing all the fucking in the game <3
BUT I suggest you play carefully if you have NTR ON... there is a corruption system in the game. And reading the walkthrough the girls can be turned into sluts. If you have NTR OFF and corrupt the girls, they are YOUR sluts and will be fucking only you. But if you have NTR ON, there are some situations that they might fuck others, at least thats what Im getting from reading the walkthrough.

- The combat and survival mechanics can cause trouble at the start
Combat is not rly hard when you get a few levels. But you will feel worhtless at the start xd
It has some unique features like insta swaping your weapons mid combat with the arrow keys <3
I did not like the survival mechanics tho... The Lust, Hunger, Energy management is very tedious and can get in the way. Especially the Lust management. Some of the scenes are locked behind certain amounts of Lust.
But it gets better after a few hours. Its just the start that is atrocious while you are getting your bearings.
Do not give up because of these mechanics

Overall an amazing and ambitious game.
Its filled with beautiful and loveable love interests , hot sex scenes , and a lot of choices on how to do things.
Some of the animations are rough, but I have no doubt they will be looked over in time.
The grind is not that horrible. You will not have to wait hours to progress with a love interest or see a sex scene.
The Walkthrough is a must. Game is rly not playable without it. The ingame quest log does not give too much info most of the time and you can get lost if you do not use the walkthrough.
I loved the game and I cant wait for more.
Good job dev, you have made something special here.

I wanted to like this game since it appeared to combine a real gaming experience with a porn game.

The problem is with the execution.

The good:
--A sophisticated story
--rpg elements that allow for a meaningful progression in stats

The bad:
--the game interface
--the reliance on walkthroughs
--energy and lust management

the meh:
--the porn

It shouldn't take multiple tries to get through doors or interact w/ characters. Though you have some measure of control over core stats, such as dex, str, and hunting by leveling up your character, energy, and lust are really hard to manage. Not a little hard, but nigh impossible. Sleeping controls energy, but raises lust significantly and undermines your ability to succeed at quests if you sleep, in what the game believes, is the wrong place.

You shouldn't have to rely on walkthroughs or trial and error to figure out how to interact with ppl. You're told you can disrupt a date for Frisa, but only briefly told you can infiltrate the mayor's house and never told how that is even possible. The person you learn lockpick from is only accessible between midnight and 6 am. Do you know how I know that? The walkthrough. When is a hole a firepit containing charcoal? When the walkthrough tells you. How do you manage lust? Read the walkthrough. How do I get Mira's first quest? Well first you have to figure out how to get through her door, and then know that you will only get the dialogue you need if your lust is <80. How do I know this? The walkthrough. How can I manage lust early on? Sleep with the witch. Is that the only way? No, you can defeat and sleep with the Orc woman, but that interaction is randomized. You can turn the tables on the witch, but only if you know how to by reading the walkthrough or through trial and error.

Personally, the sex images were not so great as to warrant going through all of the hassle of "playing" the game. I'm done with porn games where it necessitates me having the time to do hours of trial and error or a walkthrough to be successful.

Ultimately the good ideas just aren't worth the hassle.

The best game I have played in the past few years.

There is a good story, each character has a different love, ntr route. Fighting is not boring, and there is very little time wasted moving on the map, which is very precious in RPGM.

The disadvantage is the graphics quality, very bad shadow effect, I think many people miss this gem for this reason. The secondary girls have very few animation types, lacking group sex and gangbang scenes. And... As an ntr fan, I think the stories of the supporting characters are not good enough, or too peaceful?

Sorry for my bad English.

One of the best rpg games to date! Very entertaining I love the loot aspect, there's crafting in the game. The story is very involved I love all the options and scenarios for each one of the characters. I really looking forward to the updates. keep up the good work

I gotta say this truly is one of my favorite games I found here and I really hope it continues development, the overall story has me intrigued but I am also looking forward to what kind of more ntr or vanilla corrupted shenanigans our hero gets into.

Review of version 0.3.0.9, played for about 10 hours with 2 separate save routes (love/harem and NTR/coruption route).

Overall PROS:
- PLENTIFUL CAST OF CHARACTERS. From blonde cutey village girl to tall halforc woman crush me with your thighs to thicc dwarves and stuff.

- ANIMATIONS, yo. Not a masterpiece by any means, but they add that ~something~ you know you need in a scene.

- AMOUNT OF CONTENT. With each girl/woman having their route (2 most of the times) you wont be finishing the whole game in the first hour, trust me.

- ROUTES. Almost each girl has basically 2 routes : The Hero/Love path and the Corruption/NTR path. You can toogle NTR off if you will, and you can mix and match some routes, but I recomend always seeing both routes and then stick with one with your main save (corruption levels play a big factor in dialogues as well!)


Overall CONS:
- The RPG ASPECT. Hear me out: While the story is okay (typical power fantasy stuff), the combat and grind are definitely not the strong points of the game. It has some mechanics but to me feels basic and takes time (in a game where you have over like 20 characters routes to do)

- Animation BUGS/Technical issues. Although animations are good, it has a little bad side. Sometimes you are going to see weird eyes or a frame drop/freeze in some scenes. Nothing major, but its there.

RECOMENDATIONS BEFORE OR WHILE PLAYING:
- Dont be afraid to use the walkthrough. I used it the whole time and the game still felt fresh even after "spoilers" because you can't really see the thoughts or reactions of the characters in the walkthrough

- Cheat IF you dont have much time to spare. My reasoning is that combat/grind can be time consuming and this game has a lot of characters to offer and to meet, so if you want to check both of their routes and still have time to sleep, cheat a bit.

- The NTR dilemma: If you REALLY dislike it, then turn off and be done it. But playing with ON and still going with the hero/love path feels wayy more rewarding of your time than having it turned off. It adds that tension to "protect" your girls and keep the combat side of the game interesting. Trust me, even with it ON you need to f*ck up really bad to get NTR'ed (like dying to orc boss or neglecting to help ya girl in her whole quest)

CLOSING THOUGHTS:
Gonna start saying that this is one of my favorite H-games to date. Not because of 10/10 renders or insane combat mechanics, its just because I liked the characters and the situations/routes they are put in. The girls react differently according to corruption and/or previous situations (like if you done X quest before Y quest, or like losing virginity to anyone other than MC before for example)

Also saw a lot of critics in regards of female designs and such, and I disagree with then. I found most of the characters decent enough for a game where you are in a medieval village. It feels a bit dated render wise? Yes, but all of them have animations to keep the things spicy enough

In a sea of games with godlike models and renders alongside a 0.1 or [Abandoned] tag, this game keeps things going with enough updates to keep ya interested.