AA2 vs Koikatsu

Koikatsu or AA2?

  • Koikatsu

    Votes: 274 38.2%
  • Artificial Academy 2

    Votes: 444 61.8%

  • Total voters
    718

Gambitf95

Member
Jul 11, 2017
236
295
AA2 offers older graphism but with decent and numerous sex scenes and animations and more gameplay :
- You can play male or female, student or teacher.
- You can swap the main character at begin of the day.
- You can fight, invites peoples in activity/fun etc...
- NTR (You may have to compete for your love one(s) with other student, you can cheat with other people too)

I strongly recommend using AA2Mini.

Koikatsu has more modern graphism, more way to customize your Waifu but less sex animation and less gameplay. Your are the only dude of the school.
 

Jofur

Member
May 22, 2018
251
272
AA2.
Koikatsu isn't really a game. More a "virtual showroom" similar to Honey Select, only instead of buttons you walk around a world. I love the graphics and the characters you can create with it. Man, they could have made such an amazing sequel to AA2 instead using this tech if they just tried a bit instead of giving up halfway through development like usual. Making characters is fun, but it loses a lot of it's appeal fast since you can't really do anything with those characters.
 

Girm Ork

Member
Game Developer
Aug 15, 2019
191
184
In terms of gameplay, AA2 is better.
BUT AA2 character models are considerably worse than Koikatsu models, that game is just too old.
Take a look at all those indie VN games made with Koikatsu, they look amazing. And almost nobody is using AA2 for this purpose.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fibbers

Gambitf95

Member
Jul 11, 2017
236
295
KKS add not so much into gameplay. You have to collect "discussion topic" randomly and use them to gain affection on the girl. There are events like playing game, tourism, eating with the girl, but just the conversation part before and after is shown.
 

Nisshin87

Newbie
May 17, 2019
56
153
Koikatsu has excellent model customization while AA2 offers great gameplay, interactions. I do miss AA2 but it's just too old to run so my vote for KK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LonelyGuy561

thewaterdrinker

New Member
Jun 23, 2024
11
17
It's not even a competition. HoneyCome was a steaming pile of crap. It's like progression backwards.
the gameplay outside of H scenes in honeycome is nonexistent but the engine, optimization and artstyle imo is great. i wish the game had more gameplay to it and it would have been a banger...
 

kaido12

Newbie
Jan 27, 2019
35
20
the gameplay outside of H scenes in honeycome is nonexistent but the engine, optimization and artstyle imo is great. i wish the game had more gameplay to it and it would have been a banger...
It seems that your prayers were answered, because it looks like that the new game uses the same engine version that honeycome had, plus it has a lot in common with AA2. I really hope that the game will pull through and will be something more than another H scene viewer.
Core foundation of AA2 with some koikatsu gameplay mechanics sprinckled in, would be absolute GOAT.
 

Fibbers

Member
Jul 28, 2020
404
247
It seems that your prayers were answered, because it looks like that the new game uses the same engine version that honeycome had, plus it has a lot in common with AA2. I really hope that the game will pull through and will be something more than another H scene viewer.
Core foundation of AA2 with some koikatsu gameplay mechanics sprinckled in, would be absolute GOAT.
The new game?