I have quite the opposite problem. Maybe i'm too picky, but i can't find a similar game to play that hooks me like this one. So far the few ones i liked are Makina and Good Girl Gone Bad, but I will gladly take any advice!
Well, I could give you my favorite titles but it probably doesn't make much sense - because everyone has a different taste.
It's best to just use the filter, set from the rating or the number of ratings and according to "genres" which you like, browse through pictures from games, read a short description and titles that have a chance to interest you to download to evaluate it from a closer contact.
Currently, I have about 800 xD titles on the disk and I haven't downloaded everything, but only those that have a chance to interest me at least a bit. Well, but it is known, maybe every fifth or eighth is worth a high rating. And even weaker titles are a nice stepping stone for a few free hours. After that, closing ourselves to too iron frames, we close ourselves to the opportunity to learn something else, after all our tastes are constantly changing, and how do we get to know them and develop when we do not allow something new, right?