Frankly, I do not quite get why so many people rave about this game.
It's not bad, Alison is sweet and the story is halfway original.
The sex scenes and the renders are alright, but nothing special tbh.
Nothing you don't see in dozens of other games.
A major plus point for the game are the three very distinct paths, it's practically 3 VN's in one, I mean, the chars even look different.
Now to the reasons this can only get three stars from me.
It's verbose.... it's sooooo verbose. Everybody is constantly talking or thinking (often out loud) and they all love to hear themselves talk (or think).
The MC constantly, constantly acts like a horny schoolkid, whenever he sees a butt or tits.
I mean, I love to see TnA, you probably love to see TnA, but every time you see them do you go "Damn, she's killing me!" Or "my boner is killing me."
This is not verbatim, but it's the type of comment the MC constantly spouts out.
It's all very cringe-worthy, more often than not.
The MC is a complete MarySue. He can do everything, he can shoot, fight, fuck and kill like there's no tomorrow, kind of like Jensen, but without any real explanation as to why, he is practically superhuman.
Also, many clichés like a corrupt mayor and chief of police, all cops but two either crooked or incompetent... etc..
Both the MC and Melissa talk like really bad 80s action heroes.
And what others mentioned, this is practically a kinetic novel, not a game.
You have very little decisions to make to really influence the story, apart from the branching early on.
All of this can be overlooked, but not all in one game.
Despite the positive aspects, I just can't get past the not so great stuff and tbh, considering the quality of some of the games here, anything more than 3 stars would do a great disservice to those better games.
Edited to add at version 0.5.5:
I've decided to change my review score from 3 to 2 stars, here's why
1. The overenthusiastic reviews by many here, completely disregarding the many weaknesses the game has, in favour of it's few strengths, bend the review score so unrealistically that you have to do something to change that.
In all honesty, I feel bad for people coming here expecting a game worthy of so many 5 star ratings.
2. The wasted potential.
This game needs an editor, who is willing to actually reign in the writing and make the necessary cuts, as long as that doesn't happen the situation won't change.
Chapter after chapter hits and the weaknesses seem to become worse, it reaches a point were you become so frustrated over the teenage mentality of the MC, the repetitiveness of dialogue and inner monologue, the awkwardness in the dialogue, the incredible MarySue of an MC we have etc..) that you don't want to play anymore.
I couldn't come back to the game after update 0.5.5, since it became a chore to play through, not fun.