Recommending Anal-Only Games: The ultimate list

Create sections for games value on quality or keep the list as a compendium?


  • Total voters
    44
  • Poll closed .

ViviX12

Engaged Member
Jan 5, 2019
2,419
3,289
I'm conscious about this, for my current project I just created a story multiple options and a main character with a ton of dynamic dialogues but without appearance customization and a define personality. I know my limits, I know how much people ask for the sake of roleplay but I can't pull it out, at least I try to put some extra effort on dynamic dialogues.

My second project will be kinda similar but with more dialogue options, however, for my third project I'm planning something... big in relation a roleplay, which will be present in my fourth project (an AA game).
Personally I actually prefer to be given a character to follow in the story than a blank that's supposed to be 'me'. I prefer steering/playing out a character who already has something going on, and I find self-inserts rly weird tbh.
 

randomname2243

Active Member
Oct 26, 2017
513
532
In my opinion, Japanese games are the best of the best and the worst of the worst. Karryn's Prison, Violated Heroine, Artificial Academy, Custom Order Maid, Artificial Girl 3, Teaching a Feeling and many more, there are a lot of games that are great and come from Japan, but they also trow to the market a ton of trash, RPGs that are extremely lineal, Visual Novels that could perfectly be a manga or a pack of CG images, everything seems like a mess in quality.

I feel like the reason is the Japanese eroge market being outdated and crowded, a Visual Novel with just few choices is no longer enough neither an RPG that is just collecting CGs, western porn games are more experimental, yes, there is also a ton of trash games but most are average or just good enough, which is more that can be said about Japanese eroges in the current era.

By the way, I will implement a way to rate all the games on the list and sort them out, lets see if next time I'm able to add it.
Ah yes, the cute artificial academy 1 and 2. Which made NPCs have the most life of any game, that game is extremely funny if you make bullies vs white knights/Jailers. It is a war in there. And then, if you make everybody like you or most people liking a single character, the moment you start talking with them, everybody gets jealous and interrupts you especially if you get intimate mode. No game has ever reached this kind of level, and probably never will. The graphics style, the concept.
The only terrible thing to it, as most Illusion games, is the abysmal Optimization especially when they are many characters. Yes, it is understandable to have delays if many characters but if you design a game with a limit of 25, you better make sure that it is optimized well.
 

randomname2243

Active Member
Oct 26, 2017
513
532
I don't know, I often find it quite easy to relate to many characters, male or female. Other times, relating does not feel necessary, it depends on the game.

I think I specifically dislike Japanese NSFW games, because a good chunk of them are pixelated and / or have those childish anime faces, even if they otherwise have large breasts and whatnot. Not all of them look that way, of course, but a good chunk do. I tried a few games, but I have never finished a single one. I think they are better off sticking to SFW games lol. They're great at making those, nor are there any laws sabotaging them.
You know, for a game that has "deep" story like and many branches, The Survival of Rose, made me dislike(the most of any character in here)the female protagonist and its genre; and l love female protagonists. It gives a different touch since a female touch gaves a whole new experience to it. Now many games and l say many, have your male and female protagonist act exactly the same, as if both are "non-binary". Do remember, at times,.it can be acceptable. But other times, when you expect it but it isn't done, then maybe, you get slightly disappointed.
 
Last edited:

madchef

Well-Known Member
Jan 10, 2020
1,098
1,923
In my opinion, Japanese games are the best of the best and the worst of the worst. Karryn's Prison...
Remtairy, Karryn's Prison's dev is American, heavily inspired by Japanese H-games and working in tandem with Sachinama, a Japanese graphic artist, but an American nonetheless. And it shows in several aspects, the main being the consistent, albeit twisted logic of the in-game world, as well as specific shift in sexual fetishes and taboos compared to your typical hentai tropes, which makes a Western player feel more at home jerking off to all those NSFW scenes.

Anyway, off to Danzig I go!
 

Anon2298

Member
Nov 24, 2023
147
215
Remtairy, Karryn's Prison's dev is American, heavily inspired by Japanese H-games and working in tandem with Sachinama, a Japanese graphic artist, but an American nonetheless. And it shows in several aspects, the main being the consistent, albeit twisted logic of the in-game world, as well as specific shift in sexual fetishes and taboos compared to your typical hentai tropes, which makes a Western player feel more at home jerking off to all those NSFW scenes.

Anyway, off to Danzig I go!
Oh, that explain a lot even the art-direction of the game. Still, my opinion remains the same, Japan has the best of the best and the worst of the worst, a saturated market and what is left is a lot of nostalgia.
 

Studio 781

Member
Game Developer
Aug 3, 2020
341
1,669
Personally I actually prefer to be given a character to follow in the story than a blank that's supposed to be 'me'. I prefer steering/playing out a character who already has something going on, and I find self-inserts rly weird tbh.
Personally?, for me it depends of the game, there are games where I like a pre-stablished character when the plot is somewhat lineal, but when the game is a deep RPG from the getgo, I prefer having a heavy customizable character.

However, a lot of people really wants to insert themselves in the MC when we talk about eroges, which as I mentioned, is hard as balls to pull out most of the time.
 
Last edited:

randomname2243

Active Member
Oct 26, 2017
513
532
Would
Road of a Goddess
count for your list? It does contain anal and actually lets you choose which positions you want. But there is no virginity.
Other than that, it is an actual game, very, very rare to see it in here. And you piss at will, reminds me of Postal 2. Even more rare to see pissing at will.
 

Anon2298

Member
Nov 24, 2023
147
215
I move the game from the abandoned section to the main list, good luck with the development <3

Would
Road of a Goddess
count for your list? It does contain anal and actually lets you choose which positions you want. But there is no virginity.
Other than that, it is an actual game, very, very rare to see it in here. And you piss at will, reminds me of Postal 2. Even more rare to see pissing at will.
We have a section called "Corruption Anal-only games" for those games that doesn't involve virginity, however, still requires the game having some sort of corruption, mainly a girl changing her mind about preferring anal over vaginal.

Seeing the game description I don't think it qualifies but I'm all ears about why should be put on the list. If not, then it can be place in the honorable mentions.
 

randomname2243

Active Member
Oct 26, 2017
513
532
Is like 50/50.

The Knight gets raped on her scenes, I was unable to find alternative scenes so I don't know if all the scenes is just rape, but in said scenes you can choose anal-only, I found just one that had just vaginal but it was avoidable.

The Princess gets pressure into being trained, her training scenes happen once at the end of each chapter and are more consensual, she also has her own stats and training progress, because there are only four chapters, this training is far in between.

Both characters have alternative scenes and extra content but I was unable to unlock them and I don't know if all the scenes have anal-only but overall, following the main story and main content the game is kinda short but it is anal-only, half training and half rape.


Thank you for your contribution, that is a game that would definitely would benefit from anal scenes in the main story, after all the training scenes allow anal-only.
You have the anal dedicated check, you mean, the player has choice to do scenes or the training anal only? Or the scenes themselves are anal only?
 

Anon2298

Member
Nov 24, 2023
147
215
You have the anal dedicated check, you mean, the player has choice to do scenes or the training anal only? Or the scenes themselves are anal only?
The player can choose in almost all the scenes I got there was the option to choose anal-only during either rape or training. But as I mention, keep in mind there is not much training content because there are only four training phases.

This game in general is short, even with the side content. It was a pleasant surprise but not a masterpiece.
 

Anon2298

Member
Nov 24, 2023
147
215
New section added "Anal-only games in development", these are games that have mechanics which could lead to anal only or said content is confirmed by the developer, this section is simple and separated due to being subject to changes in the future, these aren't going to be added to the main list until they get confirmed. For now there are only four games:

Ethereal Sunder [EtherealSunderDev] (RPGM): So far the game has some sexual interactions, all scenes are avoidable and have different levels depending on lewdness and experience, so, it could probably contain anal-only in the future but that is not confirmed.
Squid Massage 3D [Squidrump Enthusiasts] (Unity): From the same dev of Inkling Heroes vs Tentacle, (Which is on the list) the dev told me that anal only for all the girls will be posible. Is apparently the ultimate game from the dev with all the content, female characters and scenarios from all their previous games.
The Demon's Stele & The Dog Princess [HappyLambBarn] (Others): The dev confirmed anal-only in future updates with exclusive story paths for it. In general the game will be more depth taking in account multiple situations and scenarios.
The Null Hypothesis [Ron Chon] (Ren'Py): The developer confirmed anal-only in the future although it will be just for some characters, so, when the update arrives the game will be placed in the Limited anal-only section.

If you guys know about other games that are in development with either confirmed anal-only or potential, let me know to add them to this new section. About the voting system for the games on the list, I'm working on it, that will be the next big update.
Pretty cool list actually. I'm going to try some of them.
Thank you so much for the list.
You welcome <3
 

randomname2243

Active Member
Oct 26, 2017
513
532
New section added "Anal-only games in development", these are games that have mechanics which could lead to anal only or said content is confirmed by the developer, this section is simple and separated due to being subject to changes in the future, these aren't going to be added to the main list until they get confirmed. For now there are only four games:

Ethereal Sunder [EtherealSunderDev] (RPGM): So far the game has some sexual interactions, all scenes are avoidable and have different levels depending on lewdness and experience, so, it could probably contain anal-only in the future but that is not confirmed.
Squid Massage 3D [Squidrump Enthusiasts] (Unity): From the same dev of Inkling Heroes vs Tentacle, (Which is on the list) the dev told me that anal only for all the girls will be posible. Is apparently the ultimate game from the dev with all the content, female characters and scenarios from all their previous games.
The Demon's Stele & The Dog Princess [HappyLambBarn] (Others): The dev confirmed anal-only in future updates with exclusive story paths for it. In general the game will be more depth taking in account multiple situations and scenarios.
The Null Hypothesis [Ron Chon] (Ren'Py): The developer confirmed anal-only in the future although it will be just for some characters, so, when the update arrives the game will be placed in the Limited anal-only section.

If you guys know about other games that are in development with either confirmed anal-only or potential, let me know to add them to this new section. About the voting system for the games on the list, I'm working on it, that will be the next big update.

You welcome <3
Hopefully, the anal-only content they promise, is also anal dedicated dialogue; ergo, actual consequences/dialogue if you choose the anal only path.
 

Anon2298

Member
Nov 24, 2023
147
215
Vesper - Lust & Hunger [Starhound Studios] added to the Anal-only games in development section, the game has a ton of scenes, all are optional and there are multiple routes and stats for anal development and keep track of virginity, there is not much content in the game at the moment, not even vaginal sex, however there are scenes with lesbian anal and anal masturbation.

also added to the development section, it was mention before on the thread.

LOVE IS UNDEAD posted on the request section, is an anal only game from beginning to end, some scenes are just for vaginal but most of them have anal, the game has stats and progression through training, but despite the girl being a virgin, there is no hymen breaking or something like that. I added a link to the game on English for anyone who wants to try.
Hopefully, the anal-only content they promise, is also anal dedicated dialogue; ergo, actual consequences/dialogue if you choose the anal only path.
I personally asked some months ago the dev of Squid Massage 3D [Squidrump Enthusiasts] about anal only and they told me that dialogue and special routes will be there but that was some months ago... the most recent update didn't had anal but he told me that is in the works, lets cross fingers, the previous game was quite decent and has anal-only.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peach Enthusiast

jungmonk

Newbie
Nov 9, 2023
48
48
Heya, I’m still in the beginning stages of making a real-porn game - where you will be an Ass Hunter (any of you remember the MILF Hunter days?).. which is really the first stage in creating something more ambitious in the future.. Tangential Prologue: Isn’t it funny how once you set out to do some project with your time, then suddenly six other opportunities show up and you’re like, where’s that time I definitely had at that previous moment in time? Anyways, just figured I’d come here and spew a thought that’s come up for me about ye ol lewd games..

I could probably link a hundred examples of porn games where a fetish is included in a chosen event (like anal..), and in subsequent events where that fetish can be chosen (*with the same girl*) the exact same scene is shown - even though it was a different context or a new set of events that lead up to that opportunity. As it relates to this thread, I can’t be the only one who loves the idea of anal-only, but am disappointed by the simplicity in the execution of it (no disrespect meant to any devs in here, you all have my genuine admiration for being able to commit to making a game/VN in the first place - none of this is about any one game). I have to admit that it disappoints me when I get this crazy great buildup in writing and gameplay/choices, I usually even love the art-style, I feel like I’m connecting to the game or at least enjoying it, but then I see a repeatable scene shows up and I’m like, ah, yes , me boner has ran away. Am I the only one who can’t really tap to the same scene twice? At least not like, without a year’s gap of time in between.

As it pertains to the real-porn game, the decision I realizing every dev has to make is ultimately when to be satisfied with the amount/variety of actual [lewd] content that is provided and when to accept that someone out there (even ourselves) will always wish there was more. I just wondered if any of you had some strong opinions (or weak, even) on the topic. On a related note, given that there are possible pivotal characters chosen, or even just more options for the fact that a character has a wider range of scenes/skills/fetishes, how many of you have issues with developers who push characters you don’t even like (I’m thinking like Josy in Being a DIK, for me) - how could a dev know in advance or is it just necessary to take that feedback and implement it.

Also, I appreciate all the encouragement on my first comment about making this game/VN. It definitely gave me the push to do it! Anyone who takes the time to read this gibrish I appreciate you, if you decide not to I get it, but seriously dude. and otherwise I am glad to see there’s more games in development that are opting for anal-only. See you on the other side
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: kazumeister

bigguy_foryou

Well-Known Member
Jun 8, 2018
1,090
948
On a related note, given that there are possible pivotal characters chosen, or even just more options for the fact that a character has a wider range of scenes/skills/fetishes, how many of you have issues with developers who push characters you don’t even like (I’m thinking like Josy in Being a DIK, for me) - how could a dev know in advance or is it just necessary to take that feedback and implement it.
I hate any game that habitually grows its cast. Less is more, and when developers add more and more characters I'm just not interested in to their game I find it to be quite the let down. Their existence negatively affects the depth of the character(s) I actually care about, both sexually and non sexually. Almost every time the game becomes incredibly generic and dull, every girl has the same four fork sex scene (or no choices at all). And don't get me started on being forced to engage with characters I don't just lack interest in, but actively dislike. It really kills the mood.
It usually ends up with me skipping 80% of the content in the game just to get to the girls I like, and then usually I leave unsatisfied because skipping kills the immersion and the scenes are not that good (because of how diluted/wide the game is).

My Pig Princess is a good example. Emelie is great, in part because of the uniquely good anal only content. Then you're forced to engage with a range of other characters (who I am not interested in), and it feels very annoying because I just want to go back to having Emelie call herself my anal slut again.
 

randomname2243

Active Member
Oct 26, 2017
513
532
I hate any game that habitually grows its cast. Less is more, and when developers add more and more characters I'm just not interested in to their game I find it to be quite the let down. Their existence negatively affects the depth of the character(s) I actually care about, both sexually and non sexually. Almost every time the game becomes incredibly generic and dull, every girl has the same four fork sex scene (or no choices at all). And don't get me started on being forced to engage with characters I don't just lack interest in, but actively dislike. It really kills the mood.
It usually ends up with me skipping 80% of the content in the game just to get to the girls I like, and then usually I leave unsatisfied because skipping kills the immersion and the scenes are not that good (because of how diluted/wide the game is).

My Pig Princess is a good example. Emelie is great, in part because of the uniquely good anal only content. Then you're forced to engage with a range of other characters (who I am not interested in), and it feels very annoying because I just want to go back to having Emelie call herself my anal slut again.
That's the best example of no " player agency" or also,"player freedom", the player in hentai games; always has to follow what the developer wants to follow and witness every fetish the developer wants to have. Not to mention, with so many characters but even with just 4(in some games) there is a bias. Some characters have more uptime, more content, more closure. Others, are left in the corner.
What's the word? Not coherent? No flow?