If we are talking about VN's, BALDR SKY is an instant mention, when bringing up the ones that incorporate some form of gameplay. Personally, BALDR SKY is overrated, and what we have here is a VN with an equal distribution of good and bad. That's not the most important thing i have to tell you however, if you are interested in playing this "Go melee specc". Your sanity needs to be preserved, ranged is a bad idea.
Positive:
- Great Setting/Worldbuilding - This is one of the smartest approaches to how different kinds of A.I could function and evolve in the future, (as far as VN's go), and there are SEVERAL similar concepts that are incorporated into the world of BALDR SKY, and properly explored. Impressive, relevant, instructive.
- Gameplay elements - It's "RPG deep", has real time combat, and feels like any other videogame. This is a strong positive because VN's with gameplay elements, usually struggle to present something with quality in this department.
- Story and characters (eventually) reach top tier - There are great characters, themes, moments, twists and ideas in BALDR SKY. No question whatsoever, eventually this will pay off. The thing is that we are talking about a 100 hour VN (2 dives), and these "Great Heights", only make a (very) small part of the duration. It's a serious commitment, by today's standards.
Negative:
- Pacing is atrocious, maddening even; More repetition than any entertainment fit to be consumed, should ever have; I had the misfortune of trying to play this with a "ranged build", back in the day; So much Infodumping, and different materials to be absorbed, enough for a sizable glossary, and an encyclopedia for the title.
Score: BALDR SKY (both VN's put together) is a 7/10 and a good VN. I cannot recommend this to anyone however, because the time invested is massive, and the compensation for it inadequate. Even if you have a lot of time on your hands right now,i'd still argue against trying this.
(H-scenes aren't worth it, don't bother with them)
Positive:
- Great Setting/Worldbuilding - This is one of the smartest approaches to how different kinds of A.I could function and evolve in the future, (as far as VN's go), and there are SEVERAL similar concepts that are incorporated into the world of BALDR SKY, and properly explored. Impressive, relevant, instructive.
- Gameplay elements - It's "RPG deep", has real time combat, and feels like any other videogame. This is a strong positive because VN's with gameplay elements, usually struggle to present something with quality in this department.
- Story and characters (eventually) reach top tier - There are great characters, themes, moments, twists and ideas in BALDR SKY. No question whatsoever, eventually this will pay off. The thing is that we are talking about a 100 hour VN (2 dives), and these "Great Heights", only make a (very) small part of the duration. It's a serious commitment, by today's standards.
Negative:
- Pacing is atrocious, maddening even; More repetition than any entertainment fit to be consumed, should ever have; I had the misfortune of trying to play this with a "ranged build", back in the day; So much Infodumping, and different materials to be absorbed, enough for a sizable glossary, and an encyclopedia for the title.
Score: BALDR SKY (both VN's put together) is a 7/10 and a good VN. I cannot recommend this to anyone however, because the time invested is massive, and the compensation for it inadequate. Even if you have a lot of time on your hands right now,i'd still argue against trying this.
(H-scenes aren't worth it, don't bother with them)