From a writer's perspective, the entire trope is completely reliant on deus ex machina levels of stupidity. It's lazy. I don't mind any of the action that occurs in such a game, I simply think it should be done much much better. California Bound is an example of this. It's a girl who gets coerced into greater and greater sexual acts by the nature of her choices. The main character in that game isn't stupid, however, she wants to make it on her own, so when she's presented with her choice of sex or homelessness, she chooses sex. That's how a good blackmail should work.I like lechertowns, i don't care whether you, DarthSeduction, like it or not. They doesn't need fixing, they aren't made for you. They aren't broken. They are only broken for your taste to be able to enjoy yourself. The difference is real. Your preference is your own but leave those poor lechertown fans to their on fun by leaving lechertown games well enough alone as they are now. Not all lechertowns are good though, they are just games, they can be done poorly. I for example couldn't stand Devin's Life. Too overdone. But it has its fans, i wish them much fun
Well, guys, aren't the philosophical debate about whether lechertown setup is good or bad a tad bit off-topic? Maybe we cut it short right here?
Take Anna's Exciting Affection again. What if, she'd never had the coffee shop, her sister had gotten evicted, and the day she she had to move into a new apartment her boss decided to move on her, telling her that if she wanted to keep her job, she'd have to play by his perverted rules. Now we've got a realistic blackmail scenario. She really needs that job, since she really needs a place to stay. Or, you could go with a "lesser of two evils" approach. The fat greasy boss vs the more attractive partners. If she chooses to do favors for the other partner, they protect her from him.
I'm not saying you can't have a molestation premise, I'm not saying you can't do all the same types of scenes that you see in these games all the time. I'm saying the writing is fucking shit, and could be 100 times better.