Recommending Butter's Ultimate(?) Wholesome Games/Doujins List! (a la VoltageFlame) || Also a Discussion and Recommendations Thread! (Announcement: 09/23/25)

[butter_scotch13]

Something that I will say though, is that Annie and Luna (mostly Annie) seem to have the most reasonable/developed paths.
Specifically for Annie- theres so many events and story moments that give you the option to remain friends even AFTER getting somewhat intimate (like, there were 5+ checks to see if the player really wanted to continue), and it's taken SO slow compared to everyone else.
Like, Alex had sex with the MC 3+ times after I.. brought her an eggdog to cheer her up. Everyone else also kind of ends up having sex with the mc out of complete lust and horniness (besides Luna).
Annie's path has actual dates leading up to everything, and until the final SUPER cute & romantic date, there's not any real sex! When it finally happens, it comes after lots and lots of intimate foreplay, and its gentle & passionate rather than lustful- plus CUDDLES. ALL of her scenes have so many cuddles and kisses! It's taken so slow and at her pace, and she's given so many scenes to confirm her feelings for the MC. Also, she's been with him since forever, and had a crush on him since 6th grade!

 

[TK-20-21]

View attachment 4953208

Despite my constant grievances about it- I am infact playing mostly harem.
I just.. i can't reject anyone even though I want to, and i feel so bad for Annie (and everyone else)

That's the mark of a good harem story, it's not that the guy is a cheater who's playing all of the girls it's that he can't help but love each one of them

 

[butter_scotch13]

My computer appears to have broken itself (and deleted most of my reviews) so the update… may be delayed by a little bit. Sorry about that \pensive

* I've got them saved on a text file, but unfortunately f95 does not save formatting (even within itself- copy and pasting text always sets to default color, format, and size)

 

[Deleted member 9147997]

My computer appears to have broken itself (and deleted most of my reviews) so the update… may be delayed by a little bit. Sorry about that \pensive

* I've got them saved on a text file, but unfortunately f95 does not save formatting (even within itself- copy and pasting text always sets to default color, format, and size)

No need to rush, we can wait. After all, it's not even your fault.

 

[butter_scotch13]

... Goodness, I'm just playing more and more games while forgetting to work on the update

By the time I finish this, there's going to be a dozen more games to add

 

[Deleted member 9147997]

... Goodness, I'm just playing more and more games while forgetting to work on the update

By the time I finish this, there's going to be a dozen more games to add

A dozen? Darn... That's basically half the amount of games you already have here!

Rather impressive that you found that many. I myself have tried searching, so that maybe I could recommend some things to you, but um... All I see are games that make me question "Who in God's name is playing this!?", so I decided to stop that endeavour.

 

[butter_scotch13]

A dozen? Darn... That's basically half the amount of games you already have here!

Rather impressive that you found that many. I myself have tried searching, so that maybe I could recommend some things to you, but um... All I see are games that make me question "Who in God's name is playing this!?", so I decided to stop that endeavour.

I don't know where these games are coming from either, I check f95 with my filters so often that I've found essentially every game that would fit my criteria, and then i go onto any nsfw game discord and immediately get sent a wholesome game that I've never seen before

 

[Deleted member 9147997]

I don't know where these games are coming from either, I check f95 with my filters so often that I've found essentially every game that would fit my criteria, and then i go onto any nsfw game discord and immediately get sent a wholesome game that I've never seen before

It's sorcery, I tell you, sorcery! They're using forbidden magic to summon games!

... However, the game are nice, so I suppose we can let it slide.

 

[Reckoning10]

I have been waiting for the update before I start hunting for more games. I was starting to wonder what happened to it. Lol XD

 

[butter_scotch13]

I have been waiting for the update before I start hunting for more games. I was starting to wonder what happened to it. Lol XD

I'm so sorry lmao, I can't find the motivation to work on it since these games are so good that i want to give them at LEAST a 500+ word long review for each of them.

If you're interested in the games, I have a comment here with all of them that are going on the update, and those i'm interested in.

Additionally, I am playing Living Together (Hutarigurashi) right now, so definitely check that out.

 

[Reckoning10]

It's no problem. I've got a stack of games I still need to play anyway.

 

[gabrielgg0]

best person on this platform (Not that i know of anyone else)

 

[VisualNovelEnjoyer da 3rd]

It's been a while since I've checked here... but I can't believe someone recommending this game here, lol

BLACK SOULS:
erm.. this is not going on my list
whoever keeps recommending this to me, you already know my hearts too fragile to play this!

I've been playing 1 AND 2 a couple days ago, but I still haven't finished either since I'm following a walkthrough for both, (I finished 1, but didn't get all scenes/true ending and gotta do walkthrough for it since I hit a spot in 2 where it sorta has lore from 1 and I want to understand better) and MAN... all the ways you can mess up in those two games... I thank the walkthrough for existing.

I don't know where these games are coming from either, I check f95 with my filters so often that I've found essentially every game that would fit my criteria, and then i go onto any nsfw game discord and immediately get sent a wholesome game that I've never seen before

You have a discord?

 

[butter_scotch13]

You have a discord?

Yep! I'm very active on most servers I'm in- if you want to know which:

From my most active to least active,

1. Strive4Power (Strive:Conquest's Server)
2. Incontinent Cell Hideout (MDRG's Server)
3. Isle of Robo Maid (Electric Sheep Server)
4. Head-Pat Club (Teaching Feeling Server- mostly dead but there's some people active.)

I'm in the servers for a few other games, but I don't talk there.
The MDRG server is definitely the biggest and is also where I get most of my nsfw games from. They're usually wholesome, but basically anything is posted there so quite a few unwholesome games are thrown around in #other-nsfw-games .
My username is butter in every server I'm in, so it should be pretty easy to find me.

 

[mambosky]

This thread is my last saving grace of my humanity before I get completely corrupted for soaking in toxic NTR vats.

So seriously, thank you very much for this!

 

[Deleted member 9147997]

The more I look at other threads in this site, the more I realize this thread might be the only good one on it. Which makes me question... Why?

 

[SiriusBeesnas]

Hello! I rarely post on this site, mostly I just lurk, but I do have to express how thankful I am for this list; it's very hard to find wholesome stuff even on this site, so thank you for sharing and reminding me that I'm not alone when it comes to enjoying fluff!

I don't know if/how often this list gets updated, but I do have to recommend my personal favorite wholesome game aside from Teaching Feeling: Jellyfish's Life

It's a very lovely management sim-kinda game starring an adorable shut-in character. There are a couple of unwholesome elements thrown in because of the setup for the plot (and because the dev does make other games featuring the dreaded NTR, so I assume they're just jokes or force of habit), but the game itself does not have any untoward stuff and if you do fail you just get a Game Over screen, no loss here! Give it a try sometime, it's excellent.

 

[butter_scotch13]

Hello! I rarely post on this site, mostly I just lurk, but I do have to express how thankful I am for this list; it's very hard to find wholesome stuff even on this site, so thank you for sharing and reminding me that I'm not alone when it comes to enjoying fluff!

I don't know if/how often this list gets updated, but I do have to recommend my personal favorite wholesome game aside from Teaching Feeling: Jellyfish's Life

It's a very lovely management sim-kinda game starring an adorable shut-in character. There are a couple of unwholesome elements thrown in because of the setup for the plot (and because the dev does make other games featuring the dreaded NTR, so I assume they're just jokes or force of habit), but the game itself does not have any untoward stuff and if you do fail you just get a Game Over screen, no loss here! Give it a try sometime, it's excellent.

It's really, really hard for me to enjoy games from devs that also make unwholesome stuff- especially when those things involve ntr.
The premise sounds cute though, if I ever get through my incredibly long list of games to try I might give it a shot, thanks!

 

[Deleted member 9147997]

It's really, really hard for me to enjoy games from devs that also make unwholesome stuff- especially when those things involve ntr.
The premise sounds cute though, if I ever get through my incredibly long list of games to try I might give it a shot, thanks!

Couldn't you just... not look at their other games? I mean, obviously not if you already know they have other games with bad things in them, but I believe this would solve the problem. Ignorance is bliss.

 

[SiriusBeesnas]

Couldn't you just... not look at their other games? I mean, obviously not if you already know they have other games with bad things in them, but I believe this would solve the problem. Ignorance is bliss.

That's what I try to do most of the time, personally. If there is literally nothing salvageable, I just shrug and move on, no point in torturing yourself. And if there is ever a chance to spend money, it's better to let your wallet do the talking. Show devs and creators that wholesome makes even more money than NTR and corruption!