Recommending Butter's Ultimate(?) Wholesome Games/Doujins List! (a la VoltageFlame) || Also a Discussion and Recommendations Thread! (Announcement: 09/23/25)

[butter_scotch13]

why there are some people recommending games with netorare shits in it then tell you to "just dont mind it"?

wait is this referring to anything sent right now or just overall

 

[Caelt559]

Games actually good af even tho any other route than chris is just blasphemy. Yea girl u were bullied but like--- get a grip.

agreed! Chris for the win, knew from the start that Sophie was a Bitch.

 

[butter_scotch13]

Okay.. once I finish Eiyuu Senki GOLD and Castle Meister, I'll begin working on this list again. I've taken a break from porn for like, at least a few weeks now so my mind should be clear.
Not that I really do anything with it.. more so I just need to rest my eyes and look at some eyebleach so I don't get fully taken over by lewdness or something.

 

[dagotto]

Now this is my kinda thread. Thanks for giving me some stuff to fill my downtime with

 

[butter_scotch13]

Now this is my kinda thread. Thanks for giving me some stuff to fill my downtime with

you're welcome! i haven't actually seen your game before (i think), but it looks cute!

 

[Jaike]

butter_scotch13, have you tried Tune in to the Show? It's a harem game but 1 LI routes are possible. Overall pretty wholesome with gentle paced writing and a lot of focus on LI characterisation, maybe starts off the wrong way for you. If you try it I predict your fav LI will be, and don't click this before you played it, Maya.

 

[butter_scotch13]

butter_scotch13, have you tried Tune in to the Show? It's a harem game but 1 LI routes are possible. Overall pretty wholesome with gentle paced writing and a lot of focus on LI characterisation, maybe starts off the wrong way for you. If you try it I predict your fav LI will be, and don't click this before you played it, Maya.

I have not! This gives me eternum vibes (maybe just the artstyle), so I'd love to try it!
I feel like you already know my type, so your guess will probably be accurate- I'll check the spoiler once I play it : D

 

[gabrielgg0]

Looks cute, I'll check it out eventually.

Also, quick ranking/list of EVERY game that is planned for the update (including the ones i just played) based on enjoyment and planned tier, just so it's easier to tell.
In the meantime, please play these games. Review making has kind of burned me out so the update might be pretty far away, but these games are great.

1. Eternum (God Tier), also my new favorite game.
1.5 Eld. This isn't going on my list, I'm just putting it here to say that it's a wonderful game with beautiful graphics. Just... maybe not for everyone if you aren't really horny... would be (embarassingly) my new favorite game if it wasn't a demo.
2. Fallen Brand New World (...high tier?)*
*I have not finished this game yet, and a requirement for being God Tier is to have SOMETHING that takes it far above normal wholesomeness, which is usually some sort of super happy ending. This game is beautiful, though. Same dev as 1Room.
3. Futarigurashi (God Tier)
4. MAOUISSHO (High Tier?) ^^ same reason
5. Terrene (High Tier) as of now, I'll see where it goes when I get deeper into it.
6. Fall In Labyrinth (Mid Tier)
7. MUFF (Mid Tier), too short to be considered a game
------- Untried/Too early to tell --------
Haremon
Magical Monster Girl Academy
Crimson Keep (as of chapter 3). I don't know if this is going on my list, it really depends on how the story goes. As of now, it doesn't have true romance (just like Eld)


*I had Futarigurashi written as Hutarigurashi since it's called that in the files, but ふたりぐらし as the game's title (and correct translation) says otherwise

Isnt Futarigurashi a bit incest? The girl is your mother's cousin

 

[butter_scotch13]

Isnt Futarigurashi a bit incest? The girl is your mother's cousin

oh, what?
The translation in the intro was so bad that I couldn't really tell- I just assumed it was a mistranslation.
I thought she was a friend of a relative, I personally wanted to think that so I didn't have to deal with the whole incest thing

 

[gabrielgg0]

oh, what?
The translation in the intro was so bad that I couldn't really tell- I just assumed it was a mistranslation.
I thought she was a friend of a relative, I personally wanted to think that so I didn't have to deal with the whole incest thing

Yeah, MC even mentions he's rarely seen her at family gatherings

 

[butter_scotch13]

Quick announcement for everyone here, incase you didn't see my profile post.

I'll copy and paste the rundown below.

So... it's been 5 months without an update on this list.
1), Sorry about that. I lost motivation a bit ago (ever since f95 deleted the update I was working on /rage), but the delays are pretty inexcusable.
2), The update probably won't be coming anytime soon. I explained the reasons both somewhere in this thread and on my profile, but to sum it up:

I'm... not really dependant on these games anymore, nor am I really playing/watching nsfw stuff much anymore. As you'd know from my profile page, I'm getting my life together and I'm also in a healthy relationship again (she's wonderful, ILY) which kind of pushes me away from staring at porn all day.
This isn't a permanent end to this list, I still love that this exists and I'm happy to talk about anything related to vanilla stuff. I'm just updating the list on the main post to let people know what's been happening.

...I would be an awful game developer.

Anyways, this is goodbye for a little bit! I'll be back on and off maybe, and I'll reply within a few days to comments on my list.
- butter_scotch13

 

[nezumitori]

Aww I'm late, not that I have any recommendations but I just wanna say that this list warms my heart. Also Parthia Kyodan (1room and Fallen Brand New World) really knows how to make a character and their interactions very loveable.

 

[butter_scotch13]

Small update, not to my list but to a game-

Electric Sheep has removed Yui's old storyline and made it wholesome.
I haven't played the update, but just note that my rant about it no longer applies. Yui is safe and you can actually headpat her now.

 

[Copen_]

you know what butter, never in my life i've identified with anyone's post so much. Cheers friend

 

[Pebbles44]

What about The Last Sovereign ? I'm sure it won't be in the god tier, and there are enough 'wrong' tags that may scare you away (especially harem), but the game itself is absolutely well done and, since it's in RPG Maker, bad scenes (for this kind of list) are quite rare and can be dealt with in a matter of 5 seconds at most, with the option to turn off images (those were added later, for many years there were none).

I may not have sold you well this game, but if you're curious enough to try it the only requisite is to play until a bit after the title of the game appears on screen (if you'll play you'll understand.) IMO it should be placed mid-tier/low mid-tier as a wholesome game, because it takes some play time to get it, but it's an AAA-tier game exploring many themes regarding sex with loads and loads of wholesome content in its entirety.

 

[butter_scotch13]

What about The Last Sovereign ? I'm sure it won't be in the god tier, and there are enough 'wrong' tags that may scare you away (especially harem), but the game itself is absolutely well done and, since it's in RPG Maker, bad scenes (for this kind of list) are quite rare and can be dealt with in a matter of 5 seconds at most, with the option to turn off images (those were added later, for many years there were none).

I may not have sold you well this game, but if you're curious enough to try it the only requisite is to play until a bit after the title of the game appears on screen (if you'll play you'll understand.) IMO it should be placed mid-tier/low mid-tier as a wholesome game, because it takes some play time to get it, but it's an AAA-tier game exploring many themes regarding sex with loads and loads of wholesome content in its entirety.

Swinging/Cheating tag, that's why I haven't played it. Also the whole harem thing- though it could be fine if it's done well. I just don't like those two tags, even if it's avoidable.
I won't seek out a game knowing it's likely low tier (or even mid), I always go for high tiers and the remaining tiers are for when the game doesn't live up to expectations, but my list will never contain cheating/swinging as a tag on any of the games.

 

[Copen_]

butter_scotch13 btw, i hope you are doing well. I just wanted to send my game recommendation to you and whoever interested.

You must be registered to see the links

is a story and turn based RPG focused exclusively on a couple stranded on an alien planet. It aint got nothing explicit, but the story is good and very wholesome. The whole point of the game is to explore the map while you control both characters (masc/fem Yuu, masc/fem Kay) while discovering partial pieces of lore whenever they interact. It's a great indie because meanwhile it does not have a masterpiece of story, the attention on small details (like when you are AFK for too long and the characters hug to regen HP) makes it an enjoyable experience. Idk if it interests you, but check it out anytime

TL;DR: its niche, but very good with cozy type wholesome momments 8/10.

Spoiler: also,

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[butter_scotch13]

butter_scotch13 btw, i hope you are doing well. I just wanted to send my game recommendation to you and whoever interested.

You must be registered to see the links

is a story and turn based RPG focused exclusively on a couple stranded on an alien planet. It aint got nothing explicit, but the story is good and very wholesome. The whole point of the game is to explore the map while you control both characters (masc/fem Yuu, masc/fem Kay) while discovering partial pieces of lore whenever they interact. It's a great indie because meanwhile it does not have a masterpiece of story, the attention on small details (like when you are AFK for too long and the characters hug to regen HP) makes it an enjoyable experience. Idk if it interests you, but check it out anytime

TL;DR: its niche, but very good with cozy type wholesome momments 8/10.

Spoiler: also,

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

that sounds so
fucking
cute

i will be playing this right now as a matter of fact, having no nsfw is fine because i don't really even mind anymore

 

[berdly (official)]

I would be an awful game developer.

Even game developers get tired of games in general after a while man, its only natural that things slow down/end after a while. You already did help many on their search of good games and If this list is to actually end for you to live a healthier life besides someone else, do it and don't look back brother. Hope all goes well for you life and future endeavors, thank you for the list.