Recommending Butter's Ultimate(?) Wholesome Games/Doujins List! (a la VoltageFlame) || Also a Discussion and Recommendations Thread! (UPD: 12/17/24!!)

Arabi1

Member
Donor
Oct 23, 2023
842
2,566
But.. Black Souls is.. depressingly PEAK..
You are absolutely right and I recommend it, in general. But the gore and a gameplay similar to Fear & Hunger I wouldn't recommend it to casual people especially those who are looking for wholesome and vanilla content but to hardcore gamers like myself who have spent 10 thoaunds hours playing Dark Souls 3 online and know every inch of it.
 
Nov 5, 2022
245
172
Read the reccomendation, bro plz, keep out of Black souls, that thing gonna broke you, i reccomend you add "Haremon" is a real good dating sim game, with good story, good characters and good and funny scenes, saddly aside the name, you cannot make an harem, only have girlfriend (You can broke with her and feel like shit, then change to other girl, but that is be a dick)
well, i dont like harem so thats a plus
whats wrong with black souls? everyone tells me it's going to traumatize me but i can't find a reason why it would
 
Nov 5, 2022
245
172
You are absolutely right and I recommend it, in general. But the gore and a gameplay similar to Fear & Hunger I wouldn't recommend it to casual people especially those who are looking for wholesome and vanilla content but to hardcore gamers like myself who have spent 10 thoaunds hours playing Dark Souls 3 online and know every inch of it.
oh gore & death
fear and hunger but h?
 

Arabi1

Member
Donor
Oct 23, 2023
842
2,566
oh gore & death
fear and hunger but h?
Black souls is the berserk of eroges if you know what that means. Watch a minute of walking around the mental ward and tell me if this creepy environment is good for a casual player. It needs a strong mind like SiNiSistar it was gruesome but I didn't blink an eye cause I'm used to worse than that. If you don't mind walking on a sea of blood and hearing humans in form of pigs being slaughtered and avoiding rape and lolicons then yeah you might find that wholesome stuff they are talking about after all these tragedies. Hope this answers your curiosity.

Also Mr. Cofman I found a good song while looking for some video to proof my point, you may like it:

 
Nov 5, 2022
245
172
i prefer to stay away from hard topics and gore, but i'm not completely opposed to it unless it's just pure violence with no goal (no happy ending, no wholesomeness, nothing but death)
probably down on my 'to-try' list a bit, but ill still check it out eventually
 
  • Like
Reactions: Arabi1

Mr. Cofman

Member
Apr 16, 2024
443
758
Also @Mr. Cofman I found a good song while looking for some video to proof my point, you may like it:
As a person who takes Black Souls' lore seriously, this makes me die from cringe~
But I'm still leaving a like under such content, because even though I may not like it, it gives life to Black Souls' community.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: nnt1996 and Arabi1
Nov 5, 2022
245
172
Currently playing eratouhou (and it's adorable, once I'm done it's 100% going on my list as an easy top tier), anyone able to check Hypnosis Reimu for me? I got it from the same thread as everything else but the images and name doesn't make me too confident in it's content..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Arabi1

pir

Newbie
May 20, 2019
34
15
well, i dont like harem so thats a plus
whats wrong with black souls? everyone tells me it's going to traumatize me but i can't find a reason why it would
The story is peak, but the game is real dark, real, real dark, so take care, most if you go for vanilla stuff, you wont find it here, but if you are brave enough, the first game is not so good like the second, that one is the peak of H games in my opinion, btw another one you can maybe try is "Pronant Symphony" it have two sides of the coin, be very vanilla, with love, or a lot of NTR and shit, all is avoideable. Another one is "Sequel" Saga, these are good, not bad things, and you can marry the girl you most like in the end of the game, saddly for the next game is resseted since in the main story you character is the MC of all the games
 
Nov 5, 2022
245
172
Gonna add eratohoTW along with just the entire series (it's like.. 6+ games or something) in a few hours or so
I'm not done with TW, but I LOVE this game a lot- I'm having a bunch of fun with the general gameplay and also the sex is really fun and unique : D (<-- still, does anyone know how to type that face regularly? it looks weird with a space)
 

Skandranon

Well-Known Member
Nov 28, 2016
1,458
3,316
https://f95zone.to/threads/frontier...st-in-poluluka-v1-1-fushidaratei.15230/page-3

I think someone mentioned this, but I just wanted to elaborate a bit - one of the most wholesome games possible. 3 sisters basically adopt a slave and treat him like a sibling. Whole game is just doing rural activities - fishing, farming, running around talking to people, and various chill slice-of-life events. Extremely laid-back and cozy.
There is slight femdom, but purely on the "aggressive teasing" side of things.

Might fit in your list of things you won't play due to tags.



https://f95zone.to/threads/wolfrpg-...n-himegashima-island-1-1-fushidaratei.168827/

TBH I just started this - but its 95% the same thing as the above game, same creator and graphics and all. Slow, slice of life wholesome stuff.
 
Nov 5, 2022
245
172
im so lazy :sob:
the thing is, i want to add eratoho but
i can't justify giving it less than 5 pages of the highest possible praise i can..
so im just stuck in an endless cycle of 'should i? shouldn't i?' because i want to but doing so will force me to write a small novel on why i think it's the most well made, complex, and indepth yet adorable game ever..
 
Nov 5, 2022
245
172
Just had a bit of an argument with someone, and it made me realize some of the stuff on my list are very strangely rated, and I'm not too consistent with what i determine to be 'wholesome'
Added a few extra notes to stuff and admitted my bias on games (sfc) that probably should be rated lower if not for the fact that i'm biased because i really like the game/dev- also bumped lillith's throne down to low tier, to be honest it probably shouldnt even be on this list
 
  • Yay, update!
Reactions: Lerd0