Hi there Dragon,The journal suggests there's a potion ingredient that looks like cherries - I have 0/4 of these. Where is this thing found - I've never seen it! (I've got a dozen each of every other ingredient from searching the woods but zero of that one).
UPDATE: Okay, I just had to find and read the Walkthrough document. The cherries are never VISIBLE by just looking at the screen so I'm not sure if they ever showed up in the forest but if you go to the Archery screen and mouseover EVERY bush it turns out that one of the bushes flashes to indicate the presence of the cherries. Ugh. I would never have found that if it weren't for the walkthrough.
BUG: If by chance you never introduced yourself to Penelope in the first month, it makes no sense that in subsequent months your only option is "Re-introduce" (Whereupon you know her well and she doesn't know you) - why can't you just normal-introduce at that point? Getting to know her a FIRST time shouldn't gate on having the potion unless there's actually something she needs to remember.
Thank you for reporting this! This is definitely a bug. For me it seems to be working both when exploring the forest and visiting the archery range however. Does it not look like this for you? If so, do you so happen to have a save file where I can check it?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/42178/421785ce2924c0306a81f1d0362660da555027a2" alt="berries.jpg berries.jpg"
As for not having to re-introduce yourself to Penelope if you hadn't started her story yet, that's a very good point. I'll change that for the next patch.