If you browse F95 then PhillyGames/City of Broken Dreamers is a must try. An obvious 5 stars but let's break it down.
Firstly the plot. There is a lot of care to characterize each person and define the relationship between characters. Choices matter primarily from the standpoint of accumulating relationship points with the characters. Now the way in which the game defines the world will be polarizing to some: this is a sci-fi alternate universe and some of the things and concepts are foreign. A good amount of people are probably invested and there is a optional glossary but the game will literally spell out some of these sci-fi elements when, just in my opinion, it could have been left to the viewer's imagination and been less heavy on the words. (otherwise I have nothing but the highest praise for the writing)
The irony is that in the end, this is some of the best world building anywhere. For me it's not just the writing, it's the gorgeous visuals, the tone it sets, the music. Things are technologically advanced but grimy, things are bought and sold without much care for ethics. That matters in this game where sex is really prevalent. You've got characters that just do it without care and live in this morally corrupt environment but also some conservative characters. So it's not really the technical concepts like the content in the glossary that do it for me, but rather the more subtle elements of world building that do it for me.
To emphasize again the visuals, you won't find a game that has better visuals than this..the stills are some of my favorites anywhere and the animations are very good too.
Regardless of whether or not you're a fan of themes in this game (sci-fi, depravity, corruption), this is objectively one of the top games on the site when you factor in scope, quality of visuals, storytelling, etc...can't miss it.