Creating a game. Need an advice about the plot

[ironmanamg]

First, i must admit, i am noob in developing, but still, i WANT make a great game by myself.
So, i started to write a script. It was really simple, classic incest scenario. But i think i can do something new. So, i have 2 options in my mind:
1. Classic incest game, pretty big, with big amount of variations, but including not more than 5-6 characters.
2. Incest too, but the main plot will be about how the main character is back in the past, using time-machine, or some superpower, or some serum, and fucked with a young version of mom / aunt and so on. But it will be most likely visual novel, almost without choices
1 option will be easier to make, and updates for it will come out faster
2 option obviosly harder, but the game will be much more interesting to play
The question is: what should i choose?

P.S. Sorry for my bad english

 

[Humlebien]

2.

Everyone and their mom, pun intended, does nr 1. Also with option number 2, there is no limit how far back, and therefor different theme, you can put into the game. Would be a very good way to stand out from the others. Specially if you can get some good writing on it.

 

[ironmanamg]

Actually, good writing is not a problem, i have good imagination, and i very friendly with logic. Like i sad, im new in developing, so my most priority problem is to put in the game ideas from my head

 

[Ataios]

Version 2 could create a paradox world, where the MC is his own father.

Version 2 would be a unique story, and as a fan of science-fiction and fantasy, I would really like to recommend version 2, but there is one serious disadvantage to version 2: It does not have the taboo notion of a typical incest plot. Basically it is sex between strangers who are of the same age. Therefore, there is far less taboo involved than in a "normal" incest game.

If you use version 2, you should possible not let the whole plot take place on the time journey, but also add a part when the protagonist returns to the current time and asks with an evil grin: "Mom, do you know, who fucked you so hard 20 years ago?" The protagonist could fuck the women in some compromising way (make a video, fuck them in public, whatever) in the past and use this to blackmail them in the present. Or he (or even better she) could lure them into meeting their long lost lover who fucked them better than anyone else, again and then tell them who he or she really is.

 

[EisTeeAT]

Definitly do the second one.

As some ppl already said there are so many straight up incest games that it gets kind of stale.
So if you want ppl to enjoy your sotry and not jsut the graphics(you might be good at) then the second.

On the other hand there are still lots of ppl who will just enjoy the simple incest stuff, but you will not stand out for sure, no matter how good you might be at creating characters.

But to get a good picture maybe you should add a vote to this thread .. some ppl prefer to just do a quick vote instead of typing something.

 

[DarthSeduction]

First, i must admit, i am noob in developing, but still, i WANT make a great game by myself.
So, i started to write a script. It was really simple, classic incest scenario. But i think i can do something new. So, i have 2 options in my mind:
1. Classic incest game, pretty big, with big amount of variations, but including not more than 5-6 characters.
2. Incest too, but the main plot will be about how the main character is back in the past, using time-machine, or some superpower, or some serum, and fucked with a young version of mom / aunt and so on. But it will be most likely visual novel, almost without choices
1 option will be easier to make, and updates for it will come out faster
2 option obviosly harder, but the game will be much more interesting to play
The question is: what should i choose?

P.S. Sorry for my bad english

I'd go for the cooler option. You wouldn't be completely unique of course. The Artifact did something where you went back in time and fucked your hot grandma and fathered her twin daughters, you mom and aunt, making all the incest you're having so much worse.

 

[ironmanamg]

Version 2 could create a paradox world, where the MC is his own father.

Version 2 would be a unique story, and as a fan of science-fiction and fantasy, I would really like to recommend version 2, but there is one serious disadvantage to version 2: It does not have the taboo notion of a typical incest plot. Basically it is sex between strangers who are of the same age. Therefore, there is far less taboo involved than in a "normal" incest game.

If you use version 2, you should possible not let the whole plot take place on the time journey, but also add a part when the protagonist returns to the current time and asks with an evil grin: "Mom, do you know, who fucked you so hard 20 years ago?" The protagonist could fuck the women in some compromising way (make a video, fuck them in public, whatever) in the past and use this to blackmail them in the present. Or he (or even better she) could lure them into meeting their long lost lover who fucked them better than anyone else, again and then tell them who he or she really is.

What if i will combine both options? that the protagonist can move through time in any moment he likes?
Or maybe 1 day in the past, 1 day in the present, so he could see the consequences of his actions?

shit, that a looot of work here..

 

[DarthSeduction]

What if i will combine both options? that the protagonist can move through time in any moment he likes?
Or maybe 1 day in the past, 1 day in the present, so he could see the consequences of his actions?

shit, that a looot of work here..

Something like that would work pretty easily in RPGm or something. You'd simply have to make an object or item cause it. Take a look at Zoe's Temptations for an idea of how they did that. That said, if you use RPGM I suggest you use it well.

 

[Lykanz]

Option 2 would be interesting... To be honest I plan on doing something kinda similar on my game later on, when I get the main plot finished (Chapter 4 or 5, maybe).

 

[Ataios]

When traveling back and forth in time, they way you interact with the women in the past could influence they way, they are presented in the present. If you don't do anything they behave like they did on the beginning of the game. If you act dominant in the past, they may become submissive in the present and vice versa. You could hurt their feelings so bad, that they forfeit men alltogether and become lesbians (porn stereotype, I know).

You could also tell your mom (or yourself) the lottery numbers to get in rich in the present. Time travel is quite a powerful ability after all. You could also take a more sinister approach, travel to the near future for next week's lottery numbers, get rich that way and let the women "earn" their share of the cake.

 

[DarthSeduction]

When traveling back and forth in time, they way you interact with the women in the past could influence they way, they are presented in the present. If you don't do anything they behave like they did on the beginning of the game. If you act dominant in the past, they may become submissive in the present and vice versa. You could hurt their feelings so bad, that they forfeit men alltogether and become lesbians (porn stereotype, I know).

You could also tell your mom (or yourself) the lottery numbers to get in rich in the present. Time travel is quite a powerful ability after all. You could also take a more sinister approach, travel to the near future for next week's lottery numbers, get rich that way and let the women "earn" their share of the cake.

This could get dangerous as well though... Unless the time he's traveling back to simply creates an alternate timeline... But that defeats some of the purpose... essentially if you want to affect the current timeline you can't make any drastic changes because anything too drastic would lead to you not existing or to the timeline you return to not being the one you created in the past, because if your life changed that drastically the events that led you to the time machine might not have happened.

 

[anne O'nymous]

Like everyone I stand for version 2, for the reasons explained by the others.
Plus like the MC quit his time line, there will be no direct visible link between him and the other characters, which will make it easier to switch between an incest version to a patreon compliant incest free version, if you plan to use Patreon.

 

[Ataios]

This could get dangerous as well though... Unless the time he's traveling back to simply creates an alternate timeline... But that defeats some of the purpose... essentially if you want to affect the current timeline you can't make any drastic changes because anything too drastic would lead to you not existing or to the timeline you return to not being the one you created in the past, because if your life changed that drastically the events that led you to the time machine might not have happened.

To be save, the protagonist could choose a time, where he already existed. Assume the protagonist is 20 at the start of the game, he could savely go back 19 years and be sure, he still existed upon his return. It's basically a choice how much danger the developer wants in his game. Let him go back 21 years and risk everything or let him go back 19 years and be on the save side.

On the other hand, as I said before: He could also create a paradox, where the character is his own father.

 

[DarthSeduction]

To be save, the protagonist could choose a time, where he already existed. Assume the protagonist is 20 at the start of the game, he could savely go back 19 years and be sure, he still existed upon his return. It's basically a choice how much danger the developer wants in his game. Let him go back 21 years and risk everything or let him go back 19 years and be on the save side.

On the other hand, as I said before: He could also create a paradox, where the character is his own father.

I assumed he would create the paradox. But if he "stumbles on" some magic or something, then he's not likely to be in that situation if he changes the past so much that his life is different, making him never discover time travel. If he meets a mad scientist then he's probably not going to be in the situation that introduces them. However there is a fan theory about Doc Brown of Back to the Future wherein he had to have gone full Rick Sanchez to actually get Marty to exist in a timeline and then still be in the situation to have him as his protoge. So if he writes in his own Rick Sanchez like mad scientist then yeah, he can do whatever he wants to the timeline.

 

[Boomerang]

Ergh, option 2 is more interesting tbh. But idk, it might work as an RPG rather than a VN. Could even work as a platformer depending on what you would like to tell in your story.

 

[NTR is love NTR is life]

The plot needs to be big and bouncy.