VN - Ren'Py - Defending Lydia Collier [v0.17 Beta 1.3] [White Phantom Games]

Review of v0.15.5

After having tried it earlier and it not really clicking with me I just tried it again and have to say, this is one of the best games on the site.
The quality of the story and the difference between the routes really stands out.

The biggest downside is probably the art, most of the models are very attractive but it feels a bit dated compared to a lot of other games. The animations are also few and far between with most scenes only consisting of stills.

But this is a VN that goes up in quality with every release and as such I highly recommend this one.

Good game, with good scenes and amazing plot. 10/10 would play again.
Only thing i missed was the ability to use the phone whenever. Otherwise the plot sucked me in. I was so invested and can't wait for the new update.

One of the best Ren'PY game ever made. Was looking forward for the next release!
I'll be more detailed once the "complete" final version is released. For now I'll just say that I recommended it.

Been following this game for quite some time and would give this 6 stars if I could. There is so much depth in this game, and so much content that the developer keeps on adding.

The plot is cohesive and convincing, as well as unique in how the developer implements the protagonist's law career into the plot. The protagonist's interactions with other characters and the decisions they make are also well thought out and appreciated.

The cast character design is hot as fuck, and further enhanced with each person's unique backgrounds, intentions, potential routes and kinks. CG and sex scenes take advantage of this and are well made and sexy as heck. There are a wide variety paths diverging and intertwining the player can take, in both romancing different characters, as well as the main story (e.g., which team you choose, etc).

There are many small details as well, such as the implementation of the computer, betting and the social/communication media platforms in the game.

Overall, a really well made h game that I can see has had a lot of thought put into it. I applaud White Phantom Games and wish them well in this and future projects!

Great game. A bit complex at times, but does well what it is trying to do. The characters are well-fleshed out and all routes you take go into a great deal of detail. Any girl route you pick will not only be well written but has a different style of life story that plays into the whole scenario.

And Steph is crazy.

This is an extraordinarily good game. The writing is well done, the characters are hot and well rounded. I don't hate anyone as a partner or choice and they are all relatively believable within the constraints of a sex game. The sex is very good, as are the game elements.

Really interesting premise, great breadth of choices and some fun mechanics.
Really enjoying multiple playthroughs to explore the whole story from the different viewpoints.
The phone apps could possibly be used a bit more, but that's a very minor criticism, as the sheer volume of differences between the paths and love interests is a lot more than expected. I can only imagine the time taken by the dev to fill out all the paths in this sort of meaningful way.

Downloaded this a while ago, haven't played it until this weekend, and I have to say it's an AMAZING GAME!
Awesome, interesting story, with well-written dialogues and believable interactions. I love how the game combines mystery, drama, murder, and sexual content.
To be honest, I came for the good-looking female characters in hopes of an averagly good story-just to be able to play it through, but in the end I got hooked on the story. Gorgeous characters are always a plus, so this game is top notch when it comes to that. There are different paths that really work well, the music is amazing, just everything in this game deserves 5 stars.

Wow, just wow.

I am impressed with how the story and dialogues are written.
Definitely one of the best done games of this type I have played.
The different paths really make a difference, even if you're not interested in a girl it's still worth checking out her story and her ramifications.
While Steph is the most interesting girl in terms of fun, her bimbo path really disappointed me.

In my opinion the author should do something about the repeat missions, with 12 saves it gets boring.

Sum up;

Graphically top tier
Story very good
Models refined
Girls diverse and well written
Writing and dialogues top
Music very fitting

One of the games you just have to play.

Absolutely Top Tier Storytelling. This game goes to lengths when it comes to its worldbuilding, plot and solid characters. Enough to make you realize that its not the run of the mill random quick fix adult game, but an actual mystery thriller which keeps you on the edge of your seats, and completely immerses you in its plot.
The Character wrting is done excellently, the art is pretty, and Writing is pretty Good as well. The Protagnist is one I can get behind and how the story progresses i.e. the Pace is what really made me admire the effort put into this game. Sure the Sex scenes could use more polish, but beside that, this is one hell of an adventure.
All characters feel distinct, the world feels REAL and The story flows so naturally as if we're watching it real time. Kudos to the devs and I can't wait to what they bring next. Excellent Effort.

I have more than one reason to give five stars. First of all, nearly all girls are fiting my taste, looking excellent. Second, the different ways of entering into relationships with the different women result in a high level of replayability. And last but not least, the name giving main story is very exiting. Looking foreward for the updates.

For me the writing is some of the best I've experienced for AN's. Loads of variety makes it possible and even enjoyable to do multiple playthroughs. I like the escalation options too that open if as you get more comfortable with your chosen.

TL;DR: Play this game for the kinks, the character interactions and the story.

Pros:

• Mature protagonist, a bit of a macho-man but not the ridiculous exaggerated alpha-protagonists that we get in most adult-games
• A very large choice of kinks, all avoidable.
• Multiple paths that really affect you play-through
• Plausible character interactions. There are some times that the scenario will stretch you sens of disbelief but the characters feel like human beings, not just plot devices. They all have a distinctive voice, a life outside of the MCs actions, etc. This is the best part of the game
• The plot is interesting, there is an investigation going on but not the whole focus of the game. Just enough to keep your interest while letting you "play" with the girls

CONS:

• The biggest cons is the renders. Well the girls are fine but the sex scenes are quite lacking on the graphic side. There are not many animations and sometimes very few images. I've seen far worse games though, but this is a part that could definitely be improved
• The sex scenes can sometimes feel a bit short. They are not always satisfying. But I've also seen far worse.

Thank you White Phantom for this game. This is something refreshing, not set in the US and with a different perspective. A mature, interesting, well thought-out plot and character interactions. Thanks!

Easy five star and easily one of the best games on here. Good story, smart dialogue, great renders and filthy protagonists/antagonists. And since the plot develops nicely, you can actually engage with some of the characters, or at least empathise with them. Well worth your support, currently the only dev worth it imho.

I have to admit i really enjoyed the story most. It has an interesting plot and a lot of exciting females for everyones tastes.
The only negative point would be that it is not finished, yet. But if the dev can wrap up the story good as he had been i am looking forward for a grand finale.
5/5 for me.

good game.. even without many animations this one really benefits from a good story,the amount of kinks (that ALL are completely avoidable) and good looking Renders.

player decisions really have an impact. i mean after i played several playthroughs i still find new dialogues or scenes^^ almost every girl has more than 1 path so that you can play her differently. the only criticism would be that the animations should be at least have an infinte loop instead of a 10 sec animation where you need to click on "replay" to enjoy the animation a bit more.

edit for Version 0.15.9

the game is turning into a pretty boring direction as pretty much every (thressome)path leads to lydia. steph/lydia,ellie/lydia and now jenna/lydia for people who have absolutely no interest in lydia but wanted a threesome with someone else, well not gonna happen. furthermore is jenna's story timeline totally mixed up seems like it has a lot of bugs. bc of that and the long wait for content of your fav LI i have to remove another star.

In a world where adult games are tiring repeats of the same niches made by creators with good intentions, but a scarce sense of creativity, Defending Lydia Collier grips you with murder, mystery, and and dames so beautiful that you'd think you were thrown back to the golden days of the PI.
Yes, sure, its got some stuff like scat, but its all avoidable and frankly not that bad as far as scat scenes can go, but I mean I get it. Its shit. You're not supposed to like it.

The amount of attention given to this title is quite impressive.

Story, Renders, Character arcs are all top shelf material. When I was checking out the description of this VN, it looked too good on the surface. But damn have you delivered.

I'm loving the mystery side of the story, very immersive. I can see how much effort you're putting into trying to satisfy all types of readers. And to be honest, I think you've knocked it out of the park.

I'm not one for the lewd scenes, so I for one, appreciate the liberty you give your reader to keep it at a strict minimum should one chose to do so. So thank you for that.

So aside from a few literary mistakes (which I'm not really bothered to enumerate), you've done a stellar job concentrating on the story content. Just one tiny suggestion though, I'd relax on the word "whilst". I've only noted 3 instances where it's actually correct to use. And many other times where it's just out of place. other than that 6/5 stars if that rating would be possible.

Keep up the fantastic work.
A title absolutely worth getting.
Eagerly waiting for more.

Well , I didn't expected it ,but this game is surprisingly good , there are different paths , numerous choices that affecting outcome which making playing it a vast experience and charming characters, beautiful artwork, polished story , lawyer and crime theme is refreshing , it's preferable to repetitive inauthentics.
Story has a good potential to captivate , because we expecting investigations reaching an answer or mysteries to be solved , that is keeping us hooked always , sometimes choices can be overwhelming and difficult to be made, but not if we really dig into story .

Defending Lydia Collier is definitely a unique remarkable game.

An excellent game/story if you don't mind a slow burn or thinking. This review is for v0.15.2 and I'd guess there are over 5 hours of gameplay here if you try all of the romance paths.

Defending Lydia Collier is easily one of the most successful crime dramas made into an eroge. Without spoiling anything, it's the kind of game where your character starts out by just trying to do a good thing while making a paycheck, but then increasingly finds that things are not what they seem. The author does a good job of making you feel like you're in over your head.

While juggling that intrigue, you're also given the choice of several different love paths which are also not exactly simple either. You have several love interests with which you can encourage bimbofication and submission, you can do some crazy family corruption, or you can go for wholesome romances.

It's honestly kind of crazy to think about how many different paths the author is managing between the romances, types of romances, and the semi-open-ended nature of the main story.

The only complaint I have about this game is that the graphics are a bit dated compared to some of the stuff coming out now, but that hasn't stopped me from enjoying this game on any level.

I highly recommend checking it out even before it's complete.