I am more willing to try a game where the writing and story takes priority over the gameplay, since those two are what makes the scenes/scenarios more hot for me
But I had also like games where it was the opposite, where gameplay was so good that it carry me to end. Dark Hunter Kuro is am example of this game for me, the story was okay-sh BUT the gameplay was so much fun that I couldn´t stop playing
The best scenarios are where the game reward with sex scenes by playing good and not just by failling, Fallen Rose does this really well because you can unlock all scenes by getting the true ending. Or other example is games where you can keep playing after defeating the game to collect more scenes/endings like Rookie Knight Rathi and the others games from the same developer
Obviously all of this is considering than the art or pixel art can accompany whatever choice you end up going