The Gay Tag Review
Gay content almost 100%, which is bizarre considering all the main characters are fathers, but that's the gist of the game. Also, expect very little nudity: this is a wholesome romantic visual novel.
Dream Daddy got surprisingly popular mainstream, so I was curious to see what the fuss was all about. After playing for a bit, I can state clearly this game doesn't do it for me. First of all, the general tone of the script with all this exceedingly-witty-slash-snarky dialogue got tiring very quickly. It just feels forced and fake. And all those dad jokes are just not funny (not even as "jokes on dad jokes") and, again, get very repetitive very fast.
Second, the main character: when you want to punch your dad in the face half of the time for the things he says and you have no control over, there's a problem. In addition, it's basically an ectoplasm of a character: you don't know what he does for a living, his hobbies, no development nor personality. Also, the graphics for your character are terrible, not just in itself but because all the rest is carefully drawn, so your head-on-a-stick level face doesn't fit the rest at all.
Then, the story. Or, the absence of. The dad-facebook is a device that allows the player to go on dates with the chosen dad, but it's just a collection of scenes separate from each other except for the story of that individual dad. The small scenarios that are triggered between the dates do not really help too much to get close to the other characters.
The dads themselves oscillate between cute and boring\cliché. Among the ones I played, I quite linked the twist around vampire-dad and the moral implications of the "good ending" of church-dad, whereas the drama around bear-dad was completely and annoyingly manufactured. They are all quite flat, though (the fact that I can't recall their names is an indication).
Avoidable.