[ep 1-7]
Damn this is hard to review. Full disclosure: I'm coming into this a bit hostile from the start since I have a sneaking suspicion this production right here is why I'm waiting so long for Warrior's Heart by Mortze (which I'm a huge fan of). The disparity between the quality of the productions is miles wide, sadly.
Let me explain. (TLDR at the end)
I'll really do my darndest here to be constuctive.
I think what we have here is a fundamental misunderstanding of how to tell a story using a visual medium.
What I feel good VNs and comics do is a thing called "show, don't tell". Maybe you've also heard "A picture says more than a thousand words".
What turns me off completely from this VN is that it does this exactly backwards. It seems the mantra is "tell, then tell again. Then maybe tell again." And the focus is never "showing things happen", it's "showing people talking and/or having sex". It's very one dimensional.
Imagine watching a TV show where suddenly there's text on the screen: "Alex smiles.", when you can clearly see her smiling. Then "Joey frowns" when you can see him frowning. This is exactly what this VN does. It feels like watching texting-for-the-deaf with inserts like [phone rigs] [footsteps] and so on, but for blind people. Reading a VN! Yeah it's absurd.
When working with a visual medium there's absolutely no need to add descriptive text to an image already showing what you're trying to convey. That's just weird. This VN not only does this, it does this constantly. And it never shows anything happen without added text. I have a really hard time watching a visual medium being misused like this. It's really cringe-inducing.
Now on to the story telling:
Most stories start with establishing a protagonist. Not this one. I can't say it seems to work.
To be invested in a story you'll need someone to identify and sympathize with. In the short span of the first 20 minutes I've been reading the story about 10 characters have been introduced, none of which get enough screen time that I feel like he or she could be a protagonist.
Well, maybe I'm wrong here, the title alludes to an "elsaverse" so maybe there are stories predating this one where a protagonist has been established. But if that's the case then I wouldn't have minded a short "Previously, in the elsa-verse"-segment to bring me up to speed, or some links in the thread pointing me to the start of this story.
Characters are introduced at machine gun pace. The introductions are always in dialogue format and then BAM straight to sex scenes. I never get the chance to invest in any of the characters before they're banging so it just feels like watching nice renders of some random characters. The stories skip around randomly between new characters constantly, making everything really hard to follow.
I mean the renders are super nice, but it feels really hollow. I'm just watching random people having sex.
Now talking about the renders:
They are glorious! The visuals during sex scenes are steaming hot and shows real passion.
TLDR: There isn't really anything interesting going on here besides the amazing renders. It's a cringy misuse of the VN storytelling format. The story is jumbled and lacks a protagonist.
Rating this a 3 although that may be high. The renders really carries this production. If this VN had average renders it would be a 1.