Oh my, how can I start? Am I right?
First of all, I'd really want to say I like Caribdis. I can see the significant improvement since your latest game. And I also can see the love you put on both of your games and some elements of my review on this game are based on my view (I didn't submit an review yet) on your latest game.
Nonetheless, let start this review, shall we?
Renders (5): I've played good games with shit renders and shit games with good renders, so I simply don't give so many fucks about this topic. Altough, I like the noticeable improvement since your latest game.
Dialogue (5): Funny, I'd say. Like, dunno, that's some silly good humor, It's kinda rare for me to caught myself giggling while playing an VN, and you really know how to play with the break of expectation.
Playability (3): I mean, when I insert the name of the MC, the least I hope is that I can change who he is, his personality, his actions, and I feel this game didn't gave me that chance. The dialogue options are very clear about what you must choose to get the happy ending. There's just no opportunity for being the asshole in any situation and bad attitudes are punished. unless your goal is to lose your time. This just doesn't happen IRL and you won't get shit by being the good sheep the whole time. The MC isn't even neutral, in 100% of the game, he need to be straight up 09's John Cena, unless, he won't get pusspuss... and speaking about it...
Sexual content (2): That's the number of main characters you engage in sexual intercourse in 13 hours of gameplay. And when I mean sexual intercourse, I mean fucking foreplay. (lol) I get it, the game is on early stages, but seriously, 13 HOURS of gameplay and 4 sex scenes while half of it contain one of 8 main female characters and they're all foreplays? C'mon, I know you can do better than that, bud. (Did we normalize porn games without porn?)
Story (5): Pretty interesting, I feel it contains a lot of potential for late stages of the game and It's really different from almost everything I saw until now. Good bloody job!
Ambiance and SFX (5): Tried to play it while high on cannabis and that was an experience I think everyone in the Earth should do before dying. Literally felt myself inside the game. Nonetheless, both are amazing.
Characters (5):
-MC's straight up copypasted from your latest game, like it both.
-Female main characters are, dunno, good? I like the fact they both have completely different personalities, their visual are pretty good, btw.
-For the antagonists I'll give another chance on the next patches, I think they're pretty unexplored until 3.0.
I think that's it. Pretty solid and beautiful VN, both story, render and dialogues are good. But, It just can't be called an porn game. It doesn't have porn, and it can't be played like a game (unless you are the protagonist himself lol), it's like I'm watching a pretty long and interesting movie. Dialogue options are rare and the good ones are obvious (ex: would you rather pet your dog or kill your whole family with a chainsaw?), so they're completely unnecessary.
Altough, as I said before, I know this game have a lot of potential!