I found this game randomly when I saw it on the front page and was intrigued by Astrid's design as I have a thing for muscular females. I usually keep my expectations low, but Exiles did a great job exceeding them. The setting and worldbuilding are especially interesting as there is political intrigue and conflict on different levels. Thus far we see aspects of discrimination between cultures, socioeconomic disparity, slavery, etc. The main character is charismatic, and while dumb, he clearly has progressed over time due to exposure and willingness to learn, which I find to be a good character trait for future progression.
A lot of jokes from the MC are due to the third person "narrator" which is usually done on a meta level, but also seems to have possible other story implications. Even though I picked this up due to Astrid, the other primary love/sexual interests, Tahir and Kadijah, are great in their own right and I came to like them very much as well. Tahir seems very down to earth and in many ways can relate to the MC more, though isn't entirely true to himself. Kadijah is very motivated and kind of bossy, but she has good intentions and is a pretty good person underneath all of that passion and motivation driving her. Kadijah means good and seems tired of the continuous cycle of people with power doing as they please, but there seems to be more to her motivation. Astrid is very cute in that she wants to be seen as a person despite having a dick and seen as a sex object or an abomination. Astrid seems to be juggling this, yet also wants to seek something more with her life and does try to open up more towards the MC. When I picked up the game I had no idea that Astrid would end up having a dick, but how that played into her character and interaction I ended up loving her even more.
All three of them are varied and have very interesting personalities, and their stories and subplots have very great foundations. Each of the three has their own sexual kinks such as Astrid's muscles coming into play during sex scenes which is nice and well done. The other side characters like the three princes each have their own motivations and dynamics as well as ultimate goals which as of version 0.3.1 is starting to really show. Due to being very interested in the game I actually replayed most of it, and while I probably won't do this going forward, I did want to experience as much as I could since I fell in love with it.
Though I haven't done everything possible as of this update, my one complaint would have to be how the relationships with the three main interests are being handled primarily Astrid. For Kadijah and Tahir, it seems you can do a straight up romance route if you so choose, but with Astrid you are required to choose between her being more dominant which means calling the MC a bitch and being rougher during sex scenes and having the MC be on the receiving end. Or, had her be a bit more submissive which means she is on the receiving end and is a bit more soft during sex scenes and still pretty protective outside of them. Based on the interactions thus far for her character and my personal preference in sex I chose submissive, but this came with the backlash of a sort of master/slave bit of dirty talk and roleplay during sex. This is a turn off and while its a nitpick, I just hope that as this relationship progresses it won't strictly be about either her taking charge or just MC with master and slave talk and taking charge and more mutually balanced like their first sex scene together.
Also, while testing different choices, a lot of choices didn't seem like they mattered which I guess is fine since its understandable for choices to be flavor text, but sometimes it felt like it happened a lot. These choices could play more major roles later and the dev did say they wanted to experiment with more choices, so if it is feasible I look forward to it. I have to say though, I feel how the dev has handled writing more heavy subject matter is very well done and pretty respectful. Though there is a lot of humor and jokes, the more heavy stuff regarding slavery, politics, gender identity, etc. is handled pretty upfront for the most part. In the end of the 0.3.1 update several things are stated about Astrid and the fact she has a dick, and it is played pretty straight and seriously as it was pretty hurtful things to say.
Also, things regarding how Astrid is trying to come to terms with herself and her body since she has a dick. There is a choice relating to this, where you can choose for her to keep it or seek ways to get rid of her dick, but I didn't think that was right and glad it was at least a choice for those who wanted it. Though I initially thought Astrid had a vagina before starting the game, some story things suggesting maybe Astrid would like to have a family one day and thinking maybe choosing to get rid of her dick later could result in magic giving her a vagina or something to have kids later, I chose to support her and motivate her for how she already is. I rather her grow and be herself and accept herself and help her through that, and the writing around this was solid and expect it to continue to be this way going forward. Lastly, on the topic of choice, I am glad so many options for sexual content is behind choices. You don't have to fuck everyone and you can choose to fuck certain people(s). There is straight, gay, trans, etc. content so for those who like certain things I think this approach is really good especially for accessibility.