I was quite pleasantly surprised by Fetish Locator. I originally played the first 2 weeks about a year and a half ago, and was excited to see the full game on Steam the other day, and powered through several endings before feeling satisfied with the game.
Typically with these kinds of, I guess you could call them "High profile" hentai VNs, I usually go in with pretty low expectations. They are usually as vanilla as possible, and are usually the same old story of "John VNprotagonist", the white college kid banging every girl he sees. And more or less this game is that. But despite the milk toast back drop for the story, Fetish Locator manages to tell a decently gripping story with characters you may even feel yourself growing some attachment too.
Fetish Locator has a interesting hook with the premise of a sex app that leads the MC into basically fucking every girl he comes across. At first it seems like a pretty cliche way to lead to easy sex scenes, but it quickly turns into an intrigue plot as the app starts blackmailing people and the MC and co need to try and figure out who's behind it while simultaneously keeping up with the demands of the app.
The sex scenes themselves are all very well done too. Animation quality and Model design of each girl is topnotch here and they do their best to appeal to a broad audience with their kinks. But for a game who's namesake is devoted to fetishes, the game falls into the trap that many other games like it do by trying to cram tons of fetishes in, especially ones the author is obviously not that interested in. Most fetishes come out feeling rather dull with little screen time, while others get multiple in-depth scenes over all 3 weeks. Watersports must be a dev favorite, because the amount of times you drink piss, piss on other people, get pissed on, and see piss in general is staggering, when compared to the amount of attention foot fetishists got in this game. BDSM too takes up a large amount of screentime, in which you are constantly the dom, but if you prefer being a sub you get maybe 1-2 scenes tops. All this to say its not bad necessarily, but it does mean you're more than likely going to sit through multiple scenes dedicated to fetishes you don't care about, to maybe see that 1 kink you want to have explored. It's a little disappointing at times.
Characters, like the kinks in this game, are also very inconsistent in depth and quality. Characters like my personal favorite Min, get full backstories, with character growth and struggles written believably and concluded satisfyingly. However other characters like AmRose feel 2 dimensional. Like if you didn't exist this character would have no motivation whatsoever. Even your own sister Stacy, seems to have 2 motivations. 1.) she wants to use her tech skills to help you. 2.) she wants to have sex with you. I also couldn't help but feel Lydia, your main love interest, was the least attractive and least intriguing girl of the entire cast.
The story also goes from mystery and intrigue, very quickly to quite silly and unbelievable. You're willing to suspend your disbelief when the Fetish Locator app always knows exactly what and when people do things. However when the villain is revealed, and you wake up drunk one night inside a comic book villains sex lair, while they twirl their moustache and monologue to you... I couldn't help but roll my eyes.
The Endings, while I didn't get to all of them, range from lack luster, to very satisfying and well written. My first ending was a solo ending with my favorite girl Min, and it was not only surprisingly lengthy, but also had it's own plot to follow that had me feeling quite mushy after a touching love story. However the canon ending, which they are basing a sequel off, with your sister Stacy, basically is just fucking constantly then rolling credits. So, much like many aspects of this game, your mileage may vary.
All in all, this is a hentai game. You download it to jerk off, and hope to get some good content to help get yourself off, so the story is really secondary. In that aspect, Fetish Locator does a great job. The scenes are hot, the women are hot, and there's a good amount of variety to be had. It also has an added bonus of being a pretty decent story, and even had me emotionally hooked in with some of the characters. I wish this site had a 10 rating scale, because on a scale of 10, I'd put this game at a high 8 or low 9. It's not exactly genre defining, and it's not a game I think I'll come back to to jerk off to now that I'm done, but it is an excellently made game in it's genre with a ton of love and polish put into it.
ViNovella also deserves a gold star for being one of the few hentai VN devs that doesn't needlessly drag their game out to milk patreon, and for actively updating their game and working to pump out their art. Being an honest and hardworking dev can sometimes be thankless, but they have won me over as a fan and I look forward to whatever they have coming next!
Thanks for reading!