The Five of a Kind game has a great potential and is another personal favourite of mine. I'm rating current content as of v0.3.0.1 Public.
Story: 4/5 - The story itself is not too innovative, we have a geeky/nerdy MC, an annoying popular sister (not roommate), a conflicted mother (not landlady), a dodgy friend, even a ghost and most action happens in the house as of now. However, the texts are great, it has great humour, characters show strong different personalities and the 1985 setting is amazingly implemented and adds a lot to the game itself, therefore I'm scoring on the higher end 4/5. I'll ellaborate more on this 1985 setting in the Gameplay section.
Art: 4/5 - The 2D artwork is unique and there's a lot of effort put in backgrounds and objects. Characters are well drawn and consistent in different poses and scenes. Animations are solid and consist of scenes as well as the MC and NPCs moving around and performing tasks. I'm not rating the art as 5/5 as facial expressions are too static and don't reflect well different emotions. However, the eyes movement makes them feel more "alive", so maybe implementing smile, talk and other expressions in the same line as the eyes would help a lot. With more effort put towards facial expressions and emotions of the characters I'd rate 5/5.
Gameplay: 5/5 - This is the big highlight for me. The game feels like a classic graphic adventure (point and click) from the late 80s/early 90s where you're actually interacting with the surrounding environment, collecting items and resolving puzzles/situations while the MC moves around different rooms and places. I really like the amount of objects the MC can interact with, and loved the MS-DOS interface of the computer, as well as the effort put on sound effects (modem, floppy disk!). The hint system is very good and you get extra benefits/milestones when performing specific tasks. Lots of hidden Easter eggs, and I loved when the developer "himself" interacts in the game, it shows a great sense of humour.
Sexy times: 5/5 - I'm rating it as top quality since animations are very smooth and consistent, and the NSFW scenes progress though interacting with the NPC and conversation, avoiding the boring "slow, fast, cum" button approach. Female NPCs are attractive and the sexual tension escalates at the right pace.
Future potential: 5/5 - I'm sure this game is going to be a reference on its genre once more content is added to the game and I wish the developer the best of luck with this project.
Final rating: 23/25 - 5 stars