Unfortunately, I don't know as many that are actually religious but here are a few that are relatively hesitant at first
College Life - Kara is not religious but quite hesitant sexually. Freeloading Family - Karina is actually pretty religious. She is a little naughtier than she lets on but nothing like the other girls. Sisterly Lust - Liza; If I remember right, I think she isn't exactly religious herself but volunteers at the church and is very, very hesitant. Melody - Rebecca is not religious but likes to take things slow. Man of the House - Ashley and especially her friend Sophia Mythic Manor - Naira