I'm looking for games with a male protagonist fucking female monsters, as opposed to monster girls. More sex with a sharpclaw with tits and a pussy, less sex with a monster anime waifu..
Uh, have you played Teraurge yet? It's the definitive "hard xenophilia" game- nothing in the game looks even REMOTELY human (at most, some of your potential partners have 2 arms, 2 legs and a head). Just be warned, updates come out every few years (we're hoping for version 3.0 some time this year).