- Aug 23, 2024
- 72
- 157
You are making assumptions based on a flawed perspective presented by a celestial being who is still adapting to life on Earth. She claims they are abominations, but that doesn't make it an absolute truth simply because Eliette and M's mother believe so. The game demonstrates that the undead can, and often do, live relatively normal lives. We lack sufficient evidence to categorically condemn all forms of necromancy. Eliette is clearly depicted as flawed in her beliefs, though always well-intentioned. In fact, the first thing Maryen says to her after "usurping" her title is, "You want those purification armies back, right?",a line that hints at how those armies might seem righteous to some but fanatical to others.First, spoiler that chunk of ingame dialogue. It happens pretty far into Maryen route, so counts as a spoiler.
Second, there's no distinction. All undead we saw so far had their consciousness. Even poor skeletons near Makla's home. They all are affront to nature and life itself.
Third, you are the one who fails to make a distinction. In case of Makla's victims, it'll be an act of mercy to release their souls from captivity. There's also ghosts who can't pass onto the afterlife and stay trapped in the world of living, we've seen one in halloween episode.
Also, the line about millions of undead being killed just tells us how dire the necromancy situation is on the continent. We just learned that Homaspernia keeps rising uncountable hordes of undead for one reason or another.
Sidenote: If it was a D&D module, "Purification Crusades" would have been a huge campaign about saving the world from an entire nation of necromancers and demons.
As for "Makla's victims," you may be correct, but from their perspective, it’s not as simple as labeling them as tortured souls. They feel a sense of gratitude or even loyalty toward her for their continued existence. While it's a complicated and morally ambiguous situation ( asking enslaved individuals about their captor always is ) dismissing them entirely as mere victims of torture would be an oversimplification of their experience.