VN Ren'Py Giant Guardians [v0.3.92] [Giant Guardians]

[MorallyLucky]

It has been said many times that the queen is the most powerful giantess on the continent, I doubt she can't do it.

Most powerful doesn't mean omnipotent, she explicitly says she can't conquer the continent implying that Guardians and perhaps other Giantesses are too powerful for her to take on. This isn't a controversial take, the game explicitly says multiple times that some spells that may work on small humans, don't necessarily work that easily on Giantesses (if at all). And beyond that, as stated before, she can't just mandate to stop a war. All she can do is make sure it's not a bloodbath, otherwise no one would respect her as a mediator.

 

[Yamoshii91123]

Most powerful doesn't mean omnipotent, she explicitly says she can't conquer the continent implying that Guardians and perhaps other Giantesses are too powerful for her to take on. This isn't a controversial take, the game explicitly says multiple times that some spells that may work on small humans, don't necessarily work that easily on Giantesses (if at all). And beyond that, as stated before, she can't just mandate to stop a war. All she can do is make sure it's not a bloodbath, otherwise no one would respect her as a mediator.

Good point, but if he really can't use that magic against the guardians, let him use it against the protagonist. Remember how, in neither route, did the guardians have anything to do with the attacks on the neighboring kingdom?

 

[Joe ligma]

It's time for another tierlist this time, based on how well they treat the MC (best case scenario) and how far their relationship is progressed (so it's a mix of both)

 

[LeDumbApe77]

This tierlist showing both affection and romance progression is very confusing. Croixelle route, for example, has much more romance than Makla or Kive routes, despite her being more cold with MC (can't really say that Kive or Makla are much "warmer" towards him, Croixelle is just trying to hide her feelings).

Naya loves MC as one would love a perfectly cooked steak, not as a partner.

There is no way that somehow Yakuu treats MC worse / has less romance development than Kendra. For the most part of her route, all that Kendra did was reflecting on her relationship with Maryen, it looks like she's not really into MC at all. Only in the middle of the route she appreciates MC for the first time (I'm talking about Vai'Klis house, when they were casting away ghosts), the rest of it is basically treating him as her posession.

Nyxmay is unfairly low because her "romance" side collides badly with her "treatment" side. She opens her most sacred memories to MC every night, but at the same time keeps beating most lethal bodily harm world record every afternoon, so it's confusing.

Pyeka is... hard to tell, but definitely more than B. Yes, she sees MC more as a very lovely thing to have, but that's the closest you can get from a Homaspernia giantess in owner-slave relationship. MC is more like a super VIP slave to her, yet she appreciates his kind heart at least.

Not sure if Diula belongs in A, she's a bit slow after all, so it's hard to determine what exactly does she feel towards MC. Same goes for Sheina, but because it's her thing to be teasing and all, so it's also hard to say if she "loves" MC or just having a good time with him.

By the way, Geminigems didn't make it to the tierlist. I bet they would go in B tier, because they are not that much into MC as a partner, just very kinky about his size. Also Helga, but she would probably go into "Don't know yet".

The only one I'll debate is Naya which back when the game had little content and her route was really short I would've agreed with you, Naya would only treat the MC as a "toy"
But with recent updates to her route she has definitely changed, her relationship with the mc although still pretty sexual its gotten a lot more personal
She has definitely opened herself towards the mc and told us stuff that one wouldn't really tell to someone's "plaything"
Naya is happy to have the MC's company and not only for sexual reasons now
This is why my stance on Naya has changed, back then I didn't really like her just cause it felt just like another giantess who thought the MC as a disposable dildo, but with recent updates she actually feels like a partner by the way she interacts with the MC which has turned her into one of my favorite characters

 

[DiddleKidPlusDiddler]

Regarding Nyxmay, I'll tell you this:
♂— Hey buddy, I think you've got the wrong door, the fans of crazy bitches club's two blocks down!♂

Spoiler: ♂touch me♂

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I don't know, she doesn't really interest me at the moment. There's nothing about her that I really like. In theory, she could be the kind of giantess that could fulfill almost any giantess fantasy you could have, due to her special abilities. So far, she's the only one.
Yeah

As for Eliette, I like her looks, as well as her awkward and very shy personality. However, there's another side to her character that worries me. And after I came across a comment (I don't remember who wrote it here) about Eliette and tried to look at her from a different perspective, I began to doubt it. Was Eliette really the person we saw? Or was it all a clever pretense?
Theoretically, I think it's possible to build a relationship with her in which I wouldn't be left a sexually unsatisfied man
I can't say for sure right now that Eliette is my potential waifu. Nope.

What about you? What do you think of these giantesses and their routes?

Damn... calling me out like that's crazy...

I think you'd fit right in!

Anyways... is it so bad to see MC be flattened by all that and go: "It should've been me! Not him!"?
I mean... especially since she can keep you alive... ooough.

Eliette can do that soul link stuff too, but she chooses not to. I really like the personality she has when MC first interacts with her. I think since both Eliette and Nyxmay give such a big contrast in personality while still being... very ample ... is what I like most. Like the tiny angel and devil on your shoulders, but you're the tiny one and can't even hold one on your shoulders...

 

[ControllerMan]

The only one I'll debate is Naya which back when the game had little content and her route was really short I would've agreed with you, Naya would only treat the MC as a "toy"
But with recent updates to her route she has definitely changed, her relationship with the mc although still pretty sexual its gotten a lot more personal
She has definitely opened herself towards the mc and told us stuff that one wouldn't really tell to someone's "plaything"
Naya is happy to have the MC's company and not only for sexual reasons now
This is why my stance on Naya has changed, back then I didn't really like her just cause it felt just like another giantess who thought the MC as a disposable dildo, but with recent updates she actually feels like a partner by the way she interacts with the MC which has turned her into one of my favorite characters

I mean Kendra is also concerned about the mc atleast 2 times in her "nice" route and in that route it mentions her being careful or atleast far more gentle than before so yeah, she cares, and red mini giantess (forgot her name) even said : "if i didn't now any better i would think you have a crush on this little human" she dismisses that but blushes so she definitely has a crush on the mc in her "good" route.

 

[ControllerMan]

Some additions and changes

 

[Notsohotmail]

Some additions and changes View attachment 5300326

reasonable but care to explain the reason for a few of them (if you made the tierlist that is)

 

[Johnjacky]

Guys let the man have his tier list with his own opinion. It's clearly a subjective thing lol

 

[Johnjacky]

The only one I'll debate is Naya which back when the game had little content and her route was really short I would've agreed with you, Naya would only treat the MC as a "toy"
But with recent updates to her route she has definitely changed, her relationship with the mc although still pretty sexual its gotten a lot more personal
She has definitely opened herself towards the mc and told us stuff that one wouldn't really tell to someone's "plaything"
Naya is happy to have the MC's company and not only for sexual reasons now
This is why my stance on Naya has changed, back then I didn't really like her just cause it felt just like another giantess who thought the MC as a disposable dildo, but with recent updates she actually feels like a partner by the way she interacts with the MC which has turned her into one of my favorite characters

Yep. Naya is underappreciated. But I'm personally waiting for the queen route. I know no one expects it to be much, but ik it's going to be the bomb if they give it enough attention.

 

[nikkieliot]

Yep. Naya is underappreciated. But I'm personally waiting for the queen route. I know no one expects it to be much, but ik it's going to be the bomb if they give it enough attention.

you think that in queen route there will be no kinky stuff like insertion for e.g. ?

 

[Johnjacky]

you think that in queen route there will be no kinky stuff like insertion for e.g. ?

I think there will be eventually. Just hope the project doesn't get abandoned before that, as it's definitely going to be a slowburn.

For example, with Naya, we went third base in the 2nd scene itself. With Margarita, it took like 4 scenes. Being the queen, prim and proper, it would probably be 20 scenes later that she decides it's okay to fuck around a bit lol

 

[nikkieliot]

I think there will be eventually. Just hope the project doesn't get abandoned before that, as it's definitely going to be a slowburn.

For example, with Naya, we went third base in the 2nd scene itself. With Margarita, it took like 4 scenes. Being the queen, prim and proper, it would probably be 20 scenes later that she decides it's okay to fuck around a bit lol

it would be disaster is this game would get abandoned. but yeah for example with princess no action so far except of some accidents .

 

[verdammen]

You must be registered to see the links

 

[Kendra step on me!]

I mean Kendra is also concerned about the mc atleast 2 times in her "nice" route and in that route it mentions her being careful or atleast far more gentle than before so yeah, she cares, and red mini giantess (forgot her name) even said : "if i didn't now any better i would think you have a crush on this little human" she dismisses that but blushes so she definitely has a crush on the mc in her "good" route.

Bro, the mini giantess's name was Trish, if I'm not mistaken
And yes, you can notice something similar in Yakuu's route: her old kitsune friend notes that Yakuu talks a lot about her slave, as if he's special to her. Yakuu tries to deny it and says...

Spoiler: check this out

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

But her friend probably understood how things really were here.

Also, during the second walk with Yakuu as her shoe insole, there are no death scenes. And no matter what answer you choose during the walk, Yakuu won't get genuinely angry with you.

Spoiler: look at this

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Just to compare how it was last time: a completely different mood and goals.

Spoiler: look at this 2

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: note

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Personally, I noticed a change in Yakuu's attitude toward MC even earlier.
This is also true for other routes, where there was initial indifference and MC could even be killed over something trivial, but then things gradually change.

 

[nikkieliot]

You must be registered to see the links

wau what is this man?. 0.88 was few days back, this is 0.89? whaaat? what are new routes added?

 

[nikkieliot]

hmm .89 seems legit. but we should leave guys at least really minimum 7 days to earn some cash. they need to pay rent too. eat too....

 

[Kendra step on me!]

Damn, the rhino chic must be truly evil then for ending up on E. Haven't played that route yet.

Her name is Yakuu and she's an Oni. Half-ogre, if I'm not mistaken. Don't expect a negative experience. If you're not too reckless in her route, you can avoid death. In any case, everything is subjective, and another person's experience is their own, not yours.
Ogres can be cruel and terrifying, or they can be sweet and gentle.
As in this case...

Spoiler: look at this

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

At first glance, Yakuu seems completely devoid of feminine tenderness and kindness. But this isn't entirely true. Furthermore, it's worth considering that she was once a shogun. However, this doesn't mean it's impossible to awaken some feelings in her.

 

[Kendra step on me!]

It could just be that a lot of people played Regina's route before Naya's and have inherent bias. Or they're believing whatever the story wants them to believe without forming their opinions and using logic.

Or my own logic is inherently screwed up and I'm the odd one out. I'm not so arrogant as to say that I can't be wrong.

This is one of many cognitive distortions. Yeah. I'll go further: many people, without even realizing it, approach everything subjectively and tend to choose between two options: good and bad, black and white. However, the truth is, the world works differently. There is no black or white, only gray.

Spoiler: note

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[verdammen]

hmm .89 seems legit. but we should leave guys at least really minimum 7 days to earn some cash. they need to pay rent too. eat too....

I mean ok
But they do have 733 paid members on Patreon and we know people mostly don't bother with €2 option with no game update. So it's mostly €9 and €27 . And it's common for € 224 tiers to appear , for their favorite characters.
Only on subscribestar they have 4 subscribers. I guess, makes sense, didn't subscribestar months back, has become a worse option now, or is it no longer viable at all for some people?